Rated 3.16 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing liquid eye line
This eyeliner is pretty good. It lasts all day and is highly pigmented. Smudge free because it has tiney wheel it gently glides so it's very easy to use. Not probably a everyday eyeliner to use because it's very pigmented.
Most Helpful Critical Review Wont buy again.
I was not a fan of the wheel. I thought it would make it easier to apply but it made a mess. I do love the color.
Reviewed by 38 customers Poor pigment
Mariia from TX
Too much liquid and transparent.
Wish it came in different color selections
MrsDKG from Mobile, AL
I was very curious about the roller disc applicator, and I have to say I thought it was extremely quick and easy~ goof proof. Goes on smooth, in a nice fine line, very easy to build for a more dramatic look, if desired. Unfortunately I prefer jet black eyeliner and the MVP is more of a flat black/charcoal color.
Aly from Valencia
It takes a bit to get the hang of. And it flakes easily if you dont use a primer. I feel like you have to hold on an extreme angle for a true Application.
Stayseaq from Springfield
This is not an eyeliner. It barely shows up when I tested it out. Very transparent. Would not recommend to others.
Did not like it
MommaJ69 from Victorville
There is not a lot of eyeliner that comes out
I would by again
G from Massachusetts
I love the product only wish it was a little darker or thicker.
Excelente for straight lines
Lucy from El paso tx
i love the color and the wheel helps stay straight
chrisp from north texas
This looks like little girl makeup. I wanted a plum gel eyeliner and this is pretty close, but it has so much glitter in it! Probably would work minus the glitter. Easy to put on in a straight line, and I'm new to liquid/gel liners. Can't recommend!
purple water - no payoff - can't even tell i put it on :(
Nikki from MA
Save your money - so very watery - can't even tell it is on... :(
Weirdest eyeliner ever
Sam from Penn Valley
The whole rolling disk applicator seems like it could work well but the liner is watery and bleeds, plus the disk is wobbly on the holder. Not even worth a sale price
Horrible. I don't recommend to buy it.
Dani from Washington Dc
There is a rolling disc that should be full of ink and design the line but the disc on the eyelid is not pleasant at all and the ink is super watery.
Good formula but runs out quickly
Mikayla from Cleveland
It's easy to apply and seems to last pretty well except for my outter corners (I do have watery eyes due to allergies though) but it doesn't come with much product. It ran out in less than a month for me. Kinda expensive for such little product.
Not that great
JM from Boise
Not the greatest makes a straight line but it is not dark at all you have to apply many coats.
Watery clear mess
mad dog from michigan
Horrible waste of money. :/ Seriously clear watery mess. i shook it up after realizing that to see if it would help, nope. Worst product i've ever bought haha
Who has the time?
BlessedBeyondMeasure from Texas
Yes the little wheel does make the makeup go on straight but it's so thin that you're going to be there all day putting little lines on your eyelids. Also, I have oily lids, so this stuff came right off with the first I forgot Iput eyeliner on wipe I made.
Eyeliner junkie from Why
The wheel eyeliner is really precise, however it's not very long lasting. If you so much as accidentally tap where you placed it, it just crumbles and flakes off. Also the shade MVP isn't a matte black like I was expecting but rather a black with sparkles in it which isn't bad just unexpected.
Mollie from NY
Applicator is user friendly, especially to people like me, who aren't all too good at doing eyeliner. Color is awesome and I was enchanted by the fun sparkles in the eyeliner
I love this product, its my 2nd one,back stock!!
Faery from NC
this is a fab product, lucky me that i back stocked 1 more, as it was on 1/5 purchase price sale,im sure it was a sleeper. the sparkle adds an awake look not discoey, i thought it would be flat liquid black, but its so much better than that. i use it alone for a clean line and also over my gel black liner on top to 'seal' it. 80s girl from the 80s, so i love that smokier look. simple,easy and the roller is fantastic, not choppy like the 3-dot liquid, not fumbly like a paintbrush style.total love, maybe i should buy a 3rd backup!
Easily the best and funkiest liner
Faery from NC
Simplest liner ever,tiny roller wheel easily provides colour,mine in blackest black had wee sparkle! Gorg. Received compliments! Pix look pretty too.
I loved this product
Kennedy H from Lake Ozark, MO
I absolutely loved this product and how long it stayed on. The application wand is just very strange and difficult to get product off of but other than that it's amazing!
Perfect line eyeliner!!
Margy from San Marcos
Loved this eyeliner ! Found it on sale at ulta decided to try. Love the roller effect great precision and stays on!! No smudging whatsoever !! Lasts all day and night!!! Must get every color!!
christy from undisclosed
A bit liquidy
Long lasting eyeliner!
Mallory from undisclosed
One positive was that it was very long lasting. However, it was glittery and light blue. Definitely not a color I would ever wear day or night. Would definitely love this product in a black or brown though!
Catherine from undisclosed
The formula created an uneven application and appeared splotchy, applicator was hard to use. Wouldn't recommend.
Precise, but eyeliner does not stick to skin
Hailey from undisclosed
The roller was very precise, which I liked, but the eye liner itself would not stick to my eyelid. I tried the back of my hand and it would not stick to that skin either.