Rated 4.16 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review My go-to
This version of makeup remover sometimes burns my eyes if I don't squeeze out the liquid from the pad before wiping my eyes. Might be a mix of my watered down mascara, though. It doesn't have a greasy residue that is difficult to get off, unlike the waterproof makeup version. Do not use this if you wear heavy gel liner.. it will NOT remove it. You'll rub your eyes raw! This is for more simple makeup removal. I find that it works much better if I gentle rub my eyes with some hot water before using it to loosen up dried mascara, it won't be comfortable or effective otherwise.
Most Helpful Critical Review Ugh
I decided to try this product because it said oil-free and gentle.
About the only good thing I can say for it is that it doesn't leave an oily residue behind. I really have to work to get my eye makeup off (I wear eyeliner and non-waterproof mascara) and I always end up losing a few eyelashes in the process.
The main reason I would not repurchase and would not recommend these pads is that they sting and burn my eyes worse than any other makeup remover I've ever used (and I've tried many, both in wipe/pad and liquid and lotion form). Ultimately, I'd pick the litle bit of oiliness from other makeup removers over the literal pain of using this one any day.
Reviewed by 506 customers Only thing I use to remove eye make up
CC from Petaluma, CA
I never want to run out of these pads, so I keep an extra around. My only complaint is the don't make it super easy to see which ones are oil free, and which ones are not.
Nichole from Ks
I have found these to be quite effective in removing my eye makeup. I usually have done an prewash oil, facial wash, and then use these. They work at removing the residual eye makeup. They are gentle. They are effective. I've found them to be quite used in removing my glue on falsies. Only downside is the smell. It's a chemical type smell. Kinda like acetone maybe? Great product for the price.
Love to Use this Product to Remove Eye Makeup
Rosemarie D from Charlotte
This is a great product to remove eye makeup. Don't have to tug at your eye. It's very gentle but thorough.
I'd say it's pretty good
Court from Texas
I use two of them per night so you might want to upgrade to the bigger side but that's alright I guess lol they do sometimes smear it first before taking off the product though.
🤨 from 👁👅👁
I keep rebuying these!!!so gentle and so worth the price.
Great for light makeup
MichyT from Dayton, NJ
These pads are thin but well-saturated (down to the last sheet in the jar!) The material is very soft and gentle on the skin without any irritation. On light makeup days I can use one pad for my whole face. They leave the skin feeling clean/refreshed without any residues. Fragrance free and contains plant extracts.
Not good from Raleigh
They advertise oil free but I have to wipe my eyes a few times with a dry makeup towel because my eyes will be so wet from the remover. And not because of the make up remover residue but because of oil!
small pads but love them
celia from maine
remove makeup really really well but the container is smaller in real life than online
good at removing eye makeup
GIFBK from Brooklyn, NY
I originally got a container as part of some promotion and used it up so now I bought a container of this remover and also the waterproof makeup remover... I was surprised to like it... the pads are gentle on the eyes, easy to use, and pretty effective... I wear a lot of eye makeup so sometimes one pad is not enough to remove all makeup... but generally, they give me very good value for money spent... I am a convert from more expensive brands...
Does the job
akv026 from Bethlehem, PA
These pads are gentle and remove my eye makeup without much effort. The only thing I wish is that the pads would be bigger. I have to use multiple ones to remove my makeup, which I don't even wear that much.
Love this product
Msmary from Minneapolis
I am on my third container of this product. It works great.
greasy and ineffective
mackenzie from north carolina
my friend has these and i used them to try to take off my mascara once, needless to say nothing came off my eyes and my face was left covered in residue.
Get what you pay for
HebrewHammer from Simi Valley
Not only does it smell terrible, but it burns my eyes. Also, you have to rub super hard to even take off a smidge of eyeliner and mascara (I don't even have waterproof makeup). Used a Aveeno sensitive skin makeup wipe, that took my eye makeup off in one swipe and didn't burn. I suggest buying that instead.
I have bought this over and over
All made up from Midlothian
I use it to remove my eye makeup. And mascara. I use it to clean my dogs eyes too.
AlmaLaMala from Chicago
There is nothing more annoying like the feeling of greasy eyes. This eye make up remover is fantastic! No gross greasy feeling.
Glory from Hollywood FL
Removes all eye makeup without irritating my sensitive skin.
I purchase this item over and over....
jpls48 from Huntsville, AL
So happy I found this product years ago. I've been a contact lens wearer for over 50 years and oil makeup remover has never been a good mix...
These little pads are wonderful and gentle. Tho expensive
BMama from State college Pa
These gently remove ALL eye makeup! Feel clean and soft afterwards. Love!
Roni from Florida
I've used these for years. Love Love Love!! It's gentle on delicate eye area, removes most of my eye makeup (I wear a lot!) and the oil free is awesome because I feel very clean and not greasy so that my eye cream goes on beautifully afterward.
Been using these for 15 years!
Shopgirl11 from New York
I loveeee this makeup remover. My eyes are so sensitive & the oil free formula MIRACULOUSLY does not irritate. I sometimes have to use a couple to get mascara off but I do not mind!!! I feel like Almay is getting phased out at certain drug stores so I love that Ulta still carries cause this is maybe the holiest of my holy grail products. I've certainly used it longer than any other beauty product!!!
Megan___ from Michigan
Okay so these are great and all and I love the smoothness, but I need at least 4 pads to remove ALL my eye makeup. I typically wear a couple layers of non-waterproof mascara and light eyeliner (no eyeshadow) and it takes 4!!! These won't last very long so defiantly get the larger amount if you do decide to purchase.
Does not remove eye makeup
bug1414 from Minneapolis, MN
Product does not remove my waterproof mascara. I soak and rub and I always lose a few lashes.
These are the best
Aliee from Detroit
I've been buying these consistently since first trying them in 2017. Best bang for your buck and works so well.
Best eye makeup remover
Cher from AZ
Removes eye makeup without oily residue
soph from IL
Not only does the pungent smell make me hate it, but immediately after using this, I broke out. It does not remove all eye makeup and it dries out your skin.