Product Reviews Rated 4.66 out of 5 stars
226 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Just received Naturally Matte Eye Shadow I love this kit! I have green hazel eyes and the colors compliment my complexion quite nicely. I had previously purchased the Getaway Eye Shadow kit and found the Starry Night color was just too severe for me. All the colors in this kit are perfect. I've worn it a few days now and it stays on well. I wear it over the eye primer (canvas) and use the Pommist spray to set. (You can tell I've been a loyal Jane Iredale shopper for years) This is the only brand of eye of shadow that doesn't irritate my skin. I also like the thin compact over the steps shadow kit which seem bulky to me.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great eye colors; cheap compact! I love the way these colors go on and look- very natural and soft. But, the new gold tone compacts JI has started using for beauty products seem very cheap and cheesy-- not at all like the quality of the past. JI, please consider bringing back the nicer compacts that distinguished your brand!
Reviewed by 226 customers Best eye shadow for older women. 5
MaryAnn from NC
I love this eye shadow. The matte colors are perfect for very fair, older skin.
Smooth application and looks beautiful! 5
jnjranch from Indiana
Just received this and am already loving it! It goes on smooth, colors are subtle and natural.
Pretty eye shadow colors 5
Layne from Southeastern Wisconsin
This is my second palette of this eye shadow grouping because I think the colors are beautiful and they wear well. I like to underlay with the pale pink, which makes a nice base for any of the other colors. I find when I add any other color that it remains truer to its original color. All are a bit sparkly and add happiness to my face. I tend to have dry skin and some eye shadows are irritating. Not this one! I'm 72, have silver hair with brown eyes and light skin color.
lovely but sparse 1
still looking from texas
I was very excited to find matte shadows in an array of pretty colors -- ones I actually might use. The size of this compact was ridiculous -- the case was very small but the color pallets inside were like little sample sizes. As this was rather expensive to begin with, to say I was disappointed would be a gross understatement. It went back and this brand is now off my list of future purchase.
Great coverage 5
Fern from Arizona
A little bit goes a long way. I suggest using a brush rather than the pad.
Soft and natural 4
Dotteo from Verona nj
Overall pleased with product. Wish the lightest shade was a bit more obvious as my red spidery lids are not covered.
Ordering Purple Reign was a mistake 3
Squirrel Lover from Havre de Grace, MD
I tried Jane Iredele for the first time with this order of the eye palette in Purple Reign this past December. I have tried for months to make it work for me, but I doesn't. The colors are too pink for my skin and looks very strange. The oyster base color is stark white and bizarre on my skin. I should have returned it right away, but I wanted so badly to make it work. Now I am stuck with a very expensive product that I can't use. I am bummed. The actual performance of the product is excellent, it's just the color that is the problem.
Solar Flare 5
Natmiller from York PA
I absolutely love this kit! I have hazel eyes, fair skin and dark blonde hair. The kit is easy to use and looks amazing. The colors also allow for different variations depending on the look you are going for.
Fun colors!! 5
JennB from Beaverton, OR
Lovely spring color palette! I never thought much to use pinks on my eyes, but these are subtle and blend well. Eye makeup is almost all I've been doing lately as I have to wear a mask to my dermatology office, so this is a fun palette to play with!
Horrible and tiny 3
live laugh love from Nampa ID
I purchased this because of the glowing reviews. Now I honestly believe that this company pulled a Sunday Riley and posted a bunch of fake reviews. This palette was so bad that it would have to be the case. There was next to zero color payoff, it was chalky. any color would immediately blend away. I feel like I've been punked by this company. seriously feels like a joke.
Don't understand the good reviews 1
The Brute from Dallas, Texas
The dark color in the compact is the only shadow with any payoff. The lightest colors are like using nothing. The palette should be good for beginners, it's hard to make a big mistake with so little color payoff. It's waaaaay to expensive for what you get.
Natural Beauty! 5
Lorieschu from Libertyville
I have the Come Fly with Me kit. The colors go together perfectly and look beautiful. The shadows blend nicely and the darkest color can be used as a liner with a small brush, wet or dry. Just a beautiful, useful, everyday kit!
Nice color choices all in one 4
beachgirl from beachy
a great little compact for eyes with nice neutral colors
Nice color choices all in one 4
beachy from beachy
a great little compact for eyes with nice neutral colors
Too small for price 3
Frankie from Mesa, AZ
I was shocked! How small this pallet is
Become My New Daily Favourite! 4
GoddessAnanda from Killingworth, CT
This has become my go to make up for the day as a busy mom. I can get a gorgous clean look in under 10 min that blends incredible well with my skin tone!
Needs a much better brush. 2
April from Asheville
For a palette like this the company needs to consider getting rid of the cheap applicator it comes with. This palette needs a brush like what comes in the Urban Decay naked 2 and 3 palettes.
Naturally Matte is Perfect! 5
Fleurygirl from West Virginia
The Naturally Matte kit is absolutely perfect! I love the colors. Soft and subtle, they blend perfectly, they look good with my skin tone and eye color, with everything and anything I wear and were just what I was looking for. At my age, 73, I don't want bright or sparkly eyeshadow colors so when my esthetician showed me this kit I was sold. I hope Jane keeps making this kit, it is the best. These eyeshadows stay on all day and are weightless. And if she decides to make a new duo, a Buttercream and Slate Brown would be perfect!
Versatile Colors! 5
lauriepg from Camas, WA
I ordered this palette as soon as it came out & was not disappointed. I hope that this is not a limited edition kit & that it will be available indefinitely. The colors are bright & can be mixed or layered to create different effects. Truly beautiful!
Amazing Eye Shadow Kit! 5
mypinkyoshi from Asheville, NC
I've been using this kit and I love how well the eyeshadow stays on and how it applies on. I have dry skin and have not experienced any irritation with this product. Love the colors and how long lasting it is for the whole day.
Perfect! 5
DMZR from Arizona, United States
Just what I was looking for. All in one daytime shadow kit.
Beautiful, Non Irritating Purples! 4
Maggs from California
This beautiful purple palette has the same great formula as all of Jane Iredale's eyeshadows. Just minerals, some colorants; and Pomegranate and Pine Bark Extracts. No talc or teflon or any other nasties..
-
Pine Bark Extract and Pomegranate Extract are included as antioxidants and, I assume, to hold the dry minerals together. These extracts each require more discussion as to efficacy and safety, but for now I am happy that the @paulaschoice Ingredient Dictionary rates them both as "best" in the antioxidant category..
-
I have been wearing Jane Iredale eyeshadows for years and have never had any skin or eye reactions. The colors are beautiful purples that wear well with an eyeshadow primer..
-
My only complaint is the price. $56 for a rather small palette. Look at the application wand for size reference. You will get much more bang for you buck from a Jane Iredale single color or even from one of the triples. Jane Iredale is the healthiest shadow on the market, which is how I justify buying it. I have had so many bad reactions to other eyeshadows.
Perfectly polished 5
Cheryl from Boston MA
Love this -glides on easily. The color is perfect just what I was looking for!
Gorgeous 5
GlammaSusie from Orange County
The colors are simply stunning. I am obsessed with this eyeshadow pallet. I thought the green and blue might be too outrageous, but they are subtle if you apply lightly or dramatic if you go a bit heavier. I swear, this is the only pallet I could find anywhere with this exact color combo, which is precisely what I was looking for. I'm totally ready to Party!!!
Shadow palette 4
KSilva from undisclosed
I thought I had reordered Daytime palette as the colors are close. This one has glitter. It is lovely, applies gorgeous on the canvas lid primer. Some light fallout of glitter which is unusual for Iredale.
