Product Reviews Rated 4.25 out of 5 stars
63 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Fills in my sparse brows beautifully! I love this brow pencil because it glides on so easily and stays on the entire day with no touching up! My hair is platinum and my brows have lightened up in my 65 years so this works for me in the Blonde shade. This is honestly the best brow pencil I have ever used!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not Worth It I hate this brow pencil. I only gave it 2 stars because of the natural ingredients. It's WAY too soft, so every time you use it the point smooshes all the way down. Because of this, it's impossible to get a clean line and it looks horrible in the sparse area under my brown bone and towards the tail of my brow where I actually have to draw in as opposed to just filling and coloring. It's like trying to do your brows with a dull crayon. Also, I feel like I'm going through it at an exponential rate as I have to sharpen it every time I use it (but still can never have a crisp point as it instantly wears down the minute I press it into my skin). Also, it doesn't even sharpen smoothly so you have to stop sharpening before you can even get a good point. ALSO, the pigment in the brunette shade is a bit red tinged, almost Auburn. I much prefer a more brown or even just a slightly darker shade. The Found brand eyebrow pencil, a natural cosmetics brand sold at the big blue store, is a thousand times better and costs less. I went back to that and will not be using this ever again.
Reviewed by 63 customers Very nice 5
Tanamarin from Juneau, AK
Goes on easy and stays put. Good color match for brunette. Love the brush, which blends it perfectly.
Excellent while new. 5
kandygirl from Phoenix, AZ
I love the color for blondes and how easy it is to apply. However, it is impossible to resharpen. I have tried all kinds of hand held sharpeners and all it does is break the "lead". Any suggestions?
how do i sharpen it? 4
Amy1999 from California, LA
it works really well, i stupidly tried to sharpen it with a normal pencil sharpener. besides that it works amazingly
Best Blonde Eyebrows ever 5
Squats4cookies from Boise, Idaho
This is the only eyebrow pencil I've used that is actually blonde and made for blondes. Most are dark and come out even darker when applied. Burt's Bees comes out blonde and fills in the brow where needed while still looking natural. I love getting compliments on my brows! I haven't used any other brand in almost 3 years!! I received a free sample to try out. My review, opinion & love for the brow liner is all based off my own personal experience. I have since purchased more and will continue to recommend to everyone who loves amazing brows.
Nice Color - Poor Quality 1
SeaGirl from Seattle
I do like the color of the eyebrow pencil and how it goes on, but it has proven impossible to sharpen without the tip constantly crumbling in the process; no matter how shallowly I try to expose it. So it worked once and now is useless. An unfortunate waste of money I'm afraid.
Overall great 4
Qing from Columbia SC
It's soft and easy to apply! Wish it had black color!
Love the Brow Pencil 5
hopflower from Santa Rosa, CA
After buying more expensive brands looking for a good eyebrow pencil, I found Burt's Bees version and purchased the Blonde shade. I have a lot of red in my hair, and the blonde is a good shade. The brunette would not have worked at all. I think there should be one or two more shades in this excellent pencil, as some people are brown haired; some lighter and some darker. Perhaps an auburn shade would be appropriate as well. But for me, the blonde worked quite well and applied quickly and easily. I am tired of having to comb through layers of powder and pencil to get the right application. This was quick, accurate, and easy to apply. It looked very natural on; and it is organic! What more can we ask for? I will be buying it again.
Fills in my sparse brows beautifully! 5
Jody R from Irvine, CA
I love this brow pencil because it glides on so easily and stays on the entire day with no touching up! My hair is platinum and my brows have lightened up in my 65 years so this works for me in the Blonde shade. This is honestly the best brow pencil I have ever used!
Not Worth It 2
Coco Beware from Atlanta, GA
I hate this brow pencil. I only gave it 2 stars because of the natural ingredients. It's WAY too soft, so every time you use it the point smooshes all the way down. Because of this, it's impossible to get a clean line and it looks horrible in the sparse area under my brown bone and towards the tail of my brow where I actually have to draw in as opposed to just filling and coloring. It's like trying to do your brows with a dull crayon. Also, I feel like I'm going through it at an exponential rate as I have to sharpen it every time I use it (but still can never have a crisp point as it instantly wears down the minute I press it into my skin). Also, it doesn't even sharpen smoothly so you have to stop sharpening before you can even get a good point. ALSO, the pigment in the brunette shade is a bit red tinged, almost Auburn. I much prefer a more brown or even just a slightly darker shade. The Found brand eyebrow pencil, a natural cosmetics brand sold at the big blue store, is a thousand times better and costs less. I went back to that and will not be using this ever again.
Best eyebrow pencil! 5
VessyAnn from Atlanta, GA
I've spent so much money on high end eyebrow pencils and this is the best! It's very creamy. I use the blonde pencil. The only con is that it comes in two colors, but I have blonde hair and the blonde is the perfect color for me.
Nice and soft but hard to sharpen 3
CassF from Columbus Ohio
I like this pencil. It's soft and try blonde color is light. It's a little lighter than my eyebrows and gives a nice natural look. The problem is it doesn't sharpen well. The crayon part broke off the first time and now I've sharpened away a bunch of product. Like it butnot sure I want to repurchase if it doesn't long because of this.
Good brow pencil 4
Cori Renee from Indiana
I bought this because I plan on switching from high end beauty products that are full of chemicals, to more natural beauty products. I bought blonde and it's the perfect color for my brows. It's a bit difficult to use, but I attribute that more to the fact that it an eyebrow pencil and not a pomade like I'm used to.
Literally The Best Brow Pencil Ever 5
lindseymatthews from Lillington, NC
This is one of my favorite holy grail products! The smooth and creamy texture is really what makes this products so phenomenal. Not to mention it comes with a spooly as well. Amazing product for quick natural brows. I don't like that every time I sharpen it the product breaks and doesn't create a sharp point which makes me go through the product quicker, however, I think that has more to do with my sharpener than the pencil itself. I would also like to see more shades as there are many more colors of hair other than brown and blonde.
Love the color... needs a sharpener though 4
povdesigns from Phoenix, AZ
this is a good color for strawberry blonde's and light reds... not too dark like most. I only wish it came with a sharpener. I have one, but it eats up the pencil too quickly and doesn't give me a good point. I had to buy a couple different ones till I found one that works with this brow pencil.
Good product, not the right color 4
caitbell43 from undisclosed
No complaints about the pencil other than the brunette color being too orange. Spoolie is a great tool. Hopefully they will add a darker brown/black, because unfortunately, I can't keep using this product
Disappointed 2
Kate13 from High Point, NV
I bought this to try out and was super happy with the application and color and stay. However after two uses of minimal application you must sharpen...well I'm not sure if I just had a broken product but the tip kept breaking during sharpening and now I have maybe half the pencil gone and still can't get it sharpened enough to apply. I have a great sharpener.
Great product 5
Kelly from California
I bought the pencil because my regular stuff was out. I didn't think I would like it I just needed something to fill in my brows for the time being but, I LOVE this brow pencil and the color is perfect. My new favorite! will definitely buy again
Good pencil but very soft 4
SamanthaS from undisclosed
Overall the pencil is pretty good. It can be applied easily and I love the all natural qualities. However, the pencil is very soft, to the point that I have to sharpen after every other use. So great pencil but feel that I might have to buy a replacement more frequently than other pencils I've used in the past.
Good. But needs improvement 4
Brianne from Florida, USA
It does the brows well, but the formula needs to be improvement because it is waxy goes on too light. Please include more colors.
LOVE LOVE LOVE 5
MMichaelaM from Oxford, MS
This is my first ever brow pencil. I've hardly ever filled in my brows, but I thought I needed a little something extra on my face. Boy am I impressed. The color is perfect for me, and the pencil is so easy to use. It's very buttery and pigmented. I do very light swipes and then go over it with the spool, and my brows are perfect. It really brings my whole face together. One of my girl friends saw me and the first thing she said to me, not knowing I was trying new things with my brows said, "Oh my god your eyebrows look so great! They make your whole face pop!"
Even though my skin tone is cool, my hair is brunette with red in it. The color is truly perfect for warm toned hair color. I wish they had different color and tones, just so everyone could use this pencil!
Lastly, I know the pencil is made with all these cool oils and butters that are supposed to be good for your hair and skin, but I just bought it two days ago and have only used it twice. It seems like my brows are a little darker now, but I'm sure I'm just imagining that. Regardless, the oils and butters make the pencil glide so well, and makes it so you only have to use a little bit of product. I think this will last me a long while as well.
Love, love, LOVE 5
MaddogMama from Seattle, WA
I was using the Pixi brow gel pen for over a year. Then I decided to give this burt's Bees brow pencil a try and I'm so glad I did! It's amazing! I will definitely be buying it again!
Good product! 4
Ab-solutely Abby from Seattle, Washington
Surprised that a Burt's bees makeup product works just as well, If not better, than the Anastasia Beverly Hills brow whiz that I used before! It goes on easily, stays/holds super well, and looks natural! Only complaint is that it lacks a sharpener...
Color options! 1
LankyLinguist from Southington, CT
I've only swatches the brow pencil in store just to gauge consistency as compared to others. However, I was automatically driven away because of the two shade choices for blonde or brunette and brunette isn't even solid on color. This brand needs to diversify their color range in all products...as a medium/almond skinned black woman your brand offers me and others my tone and darker nothing though I dig your natural ingredient stance
It's a shame that I have never bought from the brand because of your lack of inclusiveness in terms of color range in the brand. Highly disappointing in 2017 so I'll be spending my time on brands that thrive with their pigment ranges! I hope you follow their model eventually because the world is not Caucasian and tan Caucasian...people come in so many pigments and it's a shame this brand is so behind in realizing that...you lost a customer :(
FANTASTIC! 5
Kat E from Orange County,Ca
Long wearing, long lasting on brows, good color, easy application, good ash brown color, natural ingredients. Great price for a generous amount of product. I have looked for a long time for a natural based, inexpensive brow pencil, this is it!
Love the shade and easy application - but took off one star 4
Gin from Fallbrook CA
I would have given 5 stars for this brow pencil as I love the blonde shade for me even better than my higher end brands. I have platinum blond hair and some blondes and even taupes have red or yellow overtones in them. This shade is very natural looking and applies almost like a powder thus it does not last long!. I have been trying several 'toppers' like brow gel, hair spray etc to keep it on my brows longer than a few hours....so far no luck.
