Product Reviews Rated 3.98 out of 5 stars
87 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review OH Wow! This was part of an "update and replace" purchase when I realized how old my makeup had become.
My first eye palette in more than a decade. This replaced some old singles in the brand.
I use these over the brand's shadow primer, and they stay put on my oily lids and look the same at the end of my day. The different was surprising in the softness between the old singles and the new palette.
I am using the two darker shades on a dampened brush instead of an eye liner pencil.
I am working on my smoky eye look and more casual looks.
These smoothly apply on my crepey hooded eyes.
My one concern is how well this palette will travel, when I do travel in the future.
Would I buy this again? yes!!!
Would I suggest this for others wanting a matte range of shadows? yes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Nice colors - terrible formula I bought the Rosy Revenge palette, because I love the colors. The shadows apply and blend like a dream. It had become my favorite, until I pulled it out one day and two of the shadows had crumbled into dust. This was after 2 weeks. It had happened just moving the bag from my closet to the vanity. I ordered another one from Ulta, and it arrived completely crumbled and broken. The item was packed and wrapped well. I also own the Partner in Crime, and the first shade crumbled and fell out after the first day. I'm not sure what about the formula is different, because I own the Most Loved Mattes and use it a lot. That palette doesn't have the problem at all. I love Milani, but this range is just not worth the hassle.
Reviewed by 87 customers Disappointed 2
TAmber from Northern California
I ordered this pallet in person from the store. It was out of stock at that location and the display photo offered what I thought would be the perfect group of nudes with one plum taupe kinda color. NOT ONE SINGLE COLOR IS THE SAME as the physical display at the store l. One pan of shadow was loose in the case.
I have also since seen it in other stores for an average of 30% less money.
Since I'm for sure returning the product, I haven't tried the quality of the product itself. So I'm not able to offer any opinions about application/blending, pigment, or how long it stays on etc.
Would NOT recommend 2
Taylor from Colorado
Was so excited to get three of these because of how much I love my "most loved" pallet, but I very quickly realized this product is not similar at all. The formula is definitely not the same. They don't blend well, there's fallout, and they don't last through-out the day. More so than this, all three of my pallets broke simply from being in my makeup bag, essentially rendering them useless.
Good product 4
Yoli from Oklahoma
Colors are nice & last all day. I have sensitive skin & am Leary about trying new products but I really liked the colors & price.
Product fell out of tray & crumbled 2
CC from ELK GROVE
I was really excited about the product I love the colors. However, during the second use the entire selection of colors came loose and crumbled. They were set out on a makeup counter so not thrown in a makeup bag so there was no cause for this. Unfortunately ended up being a waste of money
Terrible 1
B from Glassboro
Pallet came completely shattered!! It was even on the outside of the shipping box! Ups refused to damage the box out. I wouldn't buy again
Nice colors 5
Dee from So Cal
Have the Jewel Heist colors and their beautiful. Very pigmented and blend out nicely.
Good product for the price 4
Becca from Jacksonville, FL
Nice pigment easy to use
It was good but 3
Valued customer from Kansas
Love the colors
Nice supplemental palette 5
Kim S from Houma,LA
Another great Milani product. Personally I use this as a color enhancer or shade shifter, as all the shades are shimmers. But if you can pull off shadows with no mattes I say go for it!
Partner in crime eye palette 5
Elizabeth from Undisclosed
This is a great eye color palette! Colors stay and stay.
Very nice natural colors 4
Lacy from Maine
Said it all
Burning Desire has vibrant nude colors! 5
Single Mom Review from Oklahoma
These are beautiful, vibrant nude colors! I love these colors & the color pigment stayed all day!
Love it 5
Cmendoza from North Carolina
Works as good as my urban decay pallets and lasts just as long . Very pigmented !
Pallet: Partners in Crime 5
Sparky from NC
So many times, I read a review for a product that comes in different colors but no mention of which color is being reviewed. This review is PARTNERS IN CRIME. If you love a matte pallet, this is the one for you. Not a shimmer or glitter in the bunch. I gave up on the shimmer/glitter stuff a while ago and haven't looked back. These colors are very neutral and cool. They are VERY blendable and the pigment is good as well. I do like a pop of color now and then so I just use a different matte pallet for a green or blue pop. I've purchased more expensive shadows with disappointing results. Give this a try. I believe you'll like it.
Perfect 5
Mayra from Undisclosed
If you don't like sprinkles on your eyelids and want something neutral. This is the perfect nude palette!
Beautiful color combo 4
Debra from Undisclosed
Great color combination, goes on smooth, and is long lasting
I will purchase again, best price. 5
Janice from FL
Super easy to apply due to soft powder. And lasts until removal.❤
LOVE LOVE LOVE 5
Lillie from Scottsdale Arizona
Goes on so smooth and are so pigmented! By far the best eyeshadows I have used
I would buy this product again! 5
Jen from Bay city mi
I love all the colors. It lasted all day and I would buy this product again..
I would buy this again. 4
Karen from Florida
Good matte finish neutral color
Don't waste the money 1
Dawn from Akron oh
Doesn't blend at all the colors are terribly boring on. Waste of money.
Breaks easy 3
Deebee from Los Ángeles
Nice colors but lasted not even a week when they shadows fell off the pallet.
Nice colors - terrible formula 1
BB Bronte from Chicago, IL
I bought the Rosy Revenge palette, because I love the colors. The shadows apply and blend like a dream. It had become my favorite, until I pulled it out one day and two of the shadows had crumbled into dust. This was after 2 weeks. It had happened just moving the bag from my closet to the vanity. I ordered another one from Ulta, and it arrived completely crumbled and broken. The item was packed and wrapped well. I also own the Partner in Crime, and the first shade crumbled and fell out after the first day. I'm not sure what about the formula is different, because I own the Most Loved Mattes and use it a lot. That palette doesn't have the problem at all. I love Milani, but this range is just not worth the hassle.
Love Love Love it!!! Goes on smooth and blends well. 5
J from Dallas
This is a great product especially at this price point. Goes on smooth Blends well stays true to color all day
OH Wow! 5
MoreLikeMom from TX
This was part of an "update and replace" purchase when I realized how old my makeup had become.
My first eye palette in more than a decade. This replaced some old singles in the brand.
I use these over the brand's shadow primer, and they stay put on my oily lids and look the same at the end of my day. The different was surprising in the softness between the old singles and the new palette.
I am using the two darker shades on a dampened brush instead of an eye liner pencil.
I am working on my smoky eye look and more casual looks.
These smoothly apply on my crepey hooded eyes.
My one concern is how well this palette will travel, when I do travel in the future.
Would I buy this again? yes!!!
Would I suggest this for others wanting a matte range of shadows? yes.