Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review This lipstick makes me feel like the Pumpkin Queen.
I was worried this shade wouldn't be flattering on me, but I was intrigued by the packaging and the scent so I ordered it. First off, it smells amazing and the scent lingers. If you are sensitive to scents you may not like it. I also enjoy the shade more than I thought I might. It's not too orange, but is still a great, flattering autumn shade. It does feel a little drying, but on the plus side it barely budges. I think it would be a great lipstick to wear under masks. A lip oil on top makes it more of a creamy finish but that takes away the long-lasting and transfer-proof properties.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not what I expected
I prefer the gloss version, this was too brown for my fair complexion, but I'm blending it with a deep red to create a fall color. I love the gingerbread girl lip, it's a perfect color for any skin tone. But it's pumpkin spice so I had to get it. 🍁
Reviewed by 71 customers Beautiful color, drying formula
maria1130 from New York
I love the color! And the scent isn't overpowering which I prefer. The formula is really drying on my lips though.
Katie from NYC
I originally got this in the holiday mini set a couple years ago and the color was absolutely perfectly. I would get compliments every time I wore it, and I loved it. I have been rationing it and wishing they would release it in a full size ever since, so I bought this as soon as I saw it. I'm so happy to finally have a full size of this color.
Chey from Spokane, WA
The product isn't bad- just wish the scent/taste was more there. But it lasts awhile and does not dry out lips too bad.
elop from san antonio tx
The color is a perfect fall color, it's beautiful. I'm still giving it 5 stars but I wish it came without the scent
A big fan of Too Faced
Sharon from Louisville
I have so many different colours in this I love it the way it smells the way it stays.
Rach from IN
I love the fallish color, the smell, and how long it lasts!
Love love love!! Smell and color are great!
Labradfi from OKC, OK
This Liquid Lipstick smells great going on, and the delicious pumpkin spice scent lasts for hours with the color. Too Faced Melted Mattes are some of my favorite lipsticks, I need a lot of staying power throughout the day and these usually work for me as long as I'm not drinking carelessly.
I was nervous about the color and afraid it might be bright orange, but it's deeper and a little redder than I expected. It looks fantastic. I have fairly light skin with pink undertones, but it really works for me. It seems pretty universally flattering, based on other reviews as well. Get it!!
TrashPanda from Orland Park, IL
This product is awesome! I have never had a lipstick that doesn't smell like lipstick, so it is pretty cool! And the color is so pretty!
Love love this !!
Rose21 from Chicago
I honestly got it on a whimp was not expecting to love this so much! The color is beautiful not orange and smells amazing I loved it so much that I actually bought two of them.
Doesn't Smell like Pumpkin Spice
SoExcitedForChristmas from NC
It smells kind of like medicine that's supposed to taste like fruit. I bought it for the smell so I'm bummed. Everyone described it as being so yummy and festive- did I get a bad one?
My new favorite lipstick!
CourtSport from Basalt, CO
I'm a huge fan of liquid lipsticks and this one knocked it out of the park! It's fall ya'll and this color is perfect! The only downside is wearing masks in public so I can't show everyone how great it looks.
The perfect liquid lipstick!
Emily F from Columbus, OH
This is my first time using Too Faced lip products, but the pumpkin spice color caught my eye for fall. The color works perfectly with my olive skin tone, even when I'm not as tan as I would be in summer! The consistency is smooth, it just rolls onto your lips. The staying power is insane! I wore this through two drinks and dinner, and it was still there after. Besides a little here and there on a napkin, it didn't transfer at all for me. Work of advice for those who say lipstick bleeds - wear lip liner! That's how I lock in the perfect lip. I will definitely be buying this lipstick again.
Obsessed. My new go to color
Meg from Arizona
I've been hunting for a shade like this for months. Perfect. Smells amazing. Nourishing and a soft finish. No cracking.
Morgi from Monroe,MI
I love it and think it a beautiful lipstick and it smells amazing!!!!!
NK from Michigan
Love it totally..looks very good on my brown skin.
Beautiful Autumn shade
Lulu from PA, USA
I have fair skin with neutral-warm undertones, and this the Pumpkin Spice shade is absolutely gorgeous. I'm not sure how well it would look on skin with cool undertones. It's definitely an "autumn" shade which is in the warm color category.
I don't usually wear matte lipsticks, but the Melted Matte formula is slightly buttery and smooth - it doesn't feel or look dried out like other matte lipsticks I've tried. I will probably gloss it over with a clear gloss or warm-red lippie for an extra spiced kick.
OMG LOVE IT!
Nerdymom93 from Cleveland, OH
Such a beautiful fall color! I love the scent they added to this pumpkin pie edition! I think the applicator brush is basic but that's it. Even the bottle is super cute too. It stays on all day! The only down side is it drys your lips a little bit.
Not what expected
Princess Fierceness from FL
This is the beautiful melted matte consistency and finish but is VERY orange/terra-cotta. it does not look like the color in the tube or swatch on the listing, if u want a red/brown orange...go for it!
lily from NY
Usually lipsticks fade away but this one stayed on for hours and it smells amazing. I also really love the color!!!
CatLady from Chicago
If you've never tried the Melted Matte formula before, you're in for a treat. I've found that it dries down about 90%, which means that it's not as drying as other liquid lipsticks (Kvd, etc.) The color of this one is gorgeous and the smell is perfect. You won't regret this!
Perfect pumpkin look and smell!
Chelebelle from Texas
I love everything about this lip matte... color and smell😊
Love it !
Jayh from Sc
A from Los Angeles
This isn't as brown on me as I thought it was going to be. I have a medium skin tone with yellow undertones and it has kinda red/pink undertones on me. Either way, it's still cute. I haven't bought the melted matte formula from too faced in years and they have improved it a lot! It's really lightweight and lasted ALL day on me without reapplying. It was super comfortable. The scent is not too strong, but if you don't like scented products I do not recommend because it lingers for like an hour.
Janie from Texas
I really love this, it is a true matte and as an older woman I appreciate that it does not bleed into those tiny creases above your lips.
A must have for fall!
Ana from Kissimmee, FL
It's a beautiful shade for the fall season. Not only is the pumpkin spice scent and packaging a bonus, but the formula in itself is a velvety matte that's long-wearing and comfortable. This is a must have lip color for the fall season!