Rated 4.31 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love this line
I really like this line. I have fair, oily skin with some uneven skin tone, but otherwise no big issues. However, I am someone who doesn't really like wearing makeup or putting it on, so I value things that are easy. I like Glossier's skywash because of how easy it is, but the colors in that line are kinda wonky for my taste (lots of oranges, weird). I've been looking for something similar in different colors, and this is a good line.
I bought Chocolate Malt, Tiramisu-me, and Amaretto. All are great. Tiramisu is my favorite as it's a mauvey purple tone. Amaretto is more redish/pink brown, and Chocolate Malt is more traditional brown with a more faint pink undertone. These pack a huge punch in terms of pigmentation, so I apply a few tiny dots to the eye and blend with my finger. Easy peasy, my favorite type of makeup.
A prior review mentioned that there wans't a choclate scent, but there is. It's very faint which I actually like because if I smell something too long it makes me kinda nauseous, so scented makeup is a nightmare for me. You won't be able to smell it on your face (thank goodness) but you can smell it when swatching on your arm.
The only con is that the makeup is legitimately hard to get off your face. I used a makeup remover wipe, micellar water, and washed my face to get it all off. I guess it's a testament to how it'll hold up, but it's kind of a nuisance.
Most Helpful Critical Review Yuck
Warm and fudgey color...makes me look bruised. I am Mac nc25 and have some redness around my eyes. I picked this color, because all the other browns looked orange based. I don't care for orange based colors on my eyes. This is a red/brown on me. Not attractive at all. No comments on how this wears, because I had to remove it right away, lest someone set off the zombie apocalypse alarm.
Reviewed by 35 customers LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this eyeshadow.
Goldilocks from Davidson NC
No Flaking, Lasts all day long and the color is great!
andi from Kansas City
These are so good! They're very pigmented and last all day. A little bit goes a very long way. They also dry very quickly, so you'll want to do one eye at a time.
Love this! Amaretto is the perfect fall simple eye color
Gb2003 from Charlotte, nc
I use it just for an everyday daytime look. I apply all over the lid and use a little bit on the bottom of the eye. A little bit of a dark brown liner and that's it!
Thick and full
Little Red from Brighton, Mi
Love how they took my thin sparse lashes and made them look full and thick.
Great easy look with depth
Nat H from Denver, CO
This is my new go-to when rushing out the door and want to look polished without the time to layer on eye shadows. A little bit of this smudged across the lose and brow and I'm out the door. Beautiful hue and color.
If you work in healthcare you need this
MakeupRN from Michigan
As someone who works in a hospital and is always running around, this is amazing and stays put. This just makes me feel more put together w out all the effort.
Glow Phoenix from Tempe AZ
Working from home, but I still like to wear eyeshadow daily b/c my eyelids are somewhat discolored (comes with age, I'm 56) . I want something that looks nice, but not overdone.
This is really good , Reminds me of the original BE 5in1 that I loved.
It was hard to pick a color b/c most of them look too dark. Went with Chocolate Malt and it's pretty perfect.
LO from Santa Cruz
Bought it on the fly in a recommendation of your staff! Love it!
Color was too red
Bama Girl from Montgomery
Didn't like this at all
Will Buy More!
Taun from Corpus Christi, TX
I absolutely love this product and will be buying more colors. It blends easily and is very pigmented. It lasts all day.
Kelly from Deerfield Beach FL
This works perfect for someone who is in the go and just needs a pop of color. A little goes a long way, and it sets rather quickly. I like to dab it on my lids and use my fingers to blend it. I enjoy that this is a matte finish as I don't need shiny lids all the time. Also works great as a eye base. Amaretto is such a beautiful color, works well with different complexions. Will repurchase for sure.
Trina from Daina Bch.Fla.
LOVE IT PIGMENT VERY WELL
Quick out the door prime and color!
Kerrybabemagnet from Detroit
I DONT KNOW IF ANY PRODUCT IS BETTER THAN THIS!! THANK YOU TOO FACED
Best eyeshadow no lines no fading
Shamara from Ca
Work in the ER were it's hot and your always busy. But you would never have known. My eyes looked just as good when I left as when I arrived. No lines or fading nothing. Wish this had been around longer
Nice liquid matte eyeshadow
Saspants from Houston, TX
I purchased these on National Lipstick Day, for whatever reason these were included in the BOGO free and I got them all since I had been wanting to try them out. Beautiful pigment, but not a total dupe for my beloved Chanel liquid eyeshadows that we're discontinued more than 15 years ago! I am still looking for something to replace my love for those shadows!
These are nice and well worth the price. The color is not as opaque as the Chanel, but definitely buildable. They are quite comfortable to wear, are long wearing and the colors I have used thus far are beautiful.
Best liquid eyeshadow
Heather from Kansas
I love the colour I got, it looks like it would go well with the Too Faced Gingerbread palette. I just have terrible blending it eventually around the outside of my lid.
lane from Oklahoma
I don't normally use Too Faced because the facial products like bronzer, foundation, etc. break me out but I tried this and it's probably the best thing that I've ever discovered. Definitely going back to buy more colors
Highly Recommend Chocolate Malt
Nitsy from Waynesburg, PA
Five stars for Chocolate Malt--it's wonderful. Easy to blend, stays put, a perfect all-over wash of matte color. I recommend using the applicator to dot three spots into the crease and blending immediately--one eye at a time. I find a finger works better than a brush.
With that said, I don't know that all shades are created equally; my first try with this product was with the color Chocolate Wine, and that shade was extremely difficult to blend and patchy. I'm glad I held off on reviewing it until I tried a different color.
Macie from Michigan
Yes, i have its AWESOME!!!! DRIES FAST LAST THROUGHOUT THE DAY, IT DO NOT CAUSE DRYNESS TO THE LIDS, DO NOT FLAKE,
Easy to use
Kstarns from Tx
I really enjoy this product. Its such a pretty color- easy to use and lasts all day
Goes on like liquid chalk
Monica from Baltimore
It has a very dramatic look. not for everyday use!
No Chocolate Scent Whatsoever :-(
Bex from Pasadena, Ca
I like the formula and colors I chose (Chocolate Chai and Chocolate Wine), but I was SOOOOOO looking forward to that rich, lasting chocoate smell I've come to love from Too Faced. I guess if that wasn't the expectation, I would've given it a higher rating. I'll probably still get some good use out of these. They last forever and I am blessed with oily lids so the matte texture is appreciated.
New Holy Grail shadow for me! One and done!
Hollybell from West Palm, Florida
I wear scrubs all day and I love makeup. Walking around in scrubs with a full face done can be a little ridiculous. I'm in love with this product. This is what I wanted the Glossier skywash to be but it fell very short. This is.one and done. Colors are so pretty and easy to blend. You do have to blend it right away then it sets and doesn't budge! I have the chocolate wine and tiramisu me. Love them.
Stays put ALL DAY!!
Lisa11 from Michigan
I love this eye shadow. I'm 53 years old with naturally oily skin. I don't need glitter or anything that is going to emphasize that! I put this on in the morning and it stays put! It doesn't get stuck in the creases and doesn't fade away. The colors are great and I have even used it as a base under another powdered eye shadow and it made that stay on pretty good.
I Had No Idea It Was Going To Be This Perfect!
Kaylieghpooh from Springfield, MA
I didn't think Too Faced could do better then they already do! It's unbelievably gorgeous!! Using just your finger, you can make a perfect blended look, looking just like airbrushed eye-looks u see online... the shade I got (Amaretto) is GORGEOUS & really brought out the green in my eyes, but I honestly think it would be a good shade for all skin tones. Formula-wise? A LITTLE tiny bit goes a longggg ways. Dried without creasing whatsoever and just looks so great. I've already ordered more shades. It looks like the eyelid is just colored that shade naturally when you put it on, and just makes ur eyes have that low, sexy, bed-me eyes;) it's a gorgeous piece of makeup.. Also can be used as a eyeshadow primer, it's so amazing i am so glad they released this! If u had any doubts, just don't! 🥰 100/100 points for me