Rated 4.58 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Finnicky Eyeliner
Let me start off by saying that when this eyeliner works, it is amazing. The tip is super fine and makes a wing extremely easy. I have been using this eyeliner for over a month and the tip is still as good as when I purchased it. It is very pigmented, and once it is on, it is ON. I have watery eyes and it stayed on all day. It isn't a pain to take off though, so the formula is bomb.
The main problem I have with it is that unless you store it tip side down, NOTHING will come out. If the pen is sideways for too long the ink will get runny/patchy. This is my first eyeliner pen, so maybe that is typical, but it's a big pain.
Most Helpful Critical Review If I could rate this 0 starts I would
I only was able to do half my eye before it just dried up and wouldn't apply anymore. No amount of shaking or anything seems to get any product out. (Can hear the mixing ball rattling about but nothing.)
Reviewed by 71 customers Great eyeliner
Landa from Los Angeles
Lasts all day, very fine tip, easy to draw very fine cat eye, isn't shiny. Only con is it takes a while to draw a line across the lash line because the tip is so fine. I used to use the NYX one and this is more pigmented over eyeshadow. Love it
Nick_mo from Denver, CO
This just isn't. Good product. I gave this a try based on the positive reviews. The tip was flimsy and bent immediately upon application. The product was not evenly disbursed, it was patchy and seemed a bit dried out. I don't know if I just got a bad one but I won't be trying this out again.
Love it !
Jennsan from Albuquerque nm
So easy love it! I don't if it was me but it made me my inner corner tear a bit
L from pa
Its so sharp and stiff that my eyelids got red. Also it barely gave any collor. Like a dusty light black. Really bad.
Boba from Nyc
I love eyeliner. I have so many, from expescive to drugstore. From pens to inkwells. I do sharp catseye but this was horrible. I love the brand but the pen had no give. It was wayyyyy too stiff, where it felt like a actual pencil. It also gave a light grey line when pushed. The color was so light and had to apply a lot to get black. It was like a faded black. Also it hurt to apply after time. It is very precise though but the application isnt worth it. The best is maybilne hyper easy. It's beyond perfect.
Jayy from undisclosed
A staple. One of my favorite affordable felt tip liners
great liner !
danny from colorado
i was skeptical at first , but it's pretty good after you get used to the tip of the liner. i have pretty shaky hands so it took me a couple days to get it down. this doesn't smear and there's very little run off (from tear build up) at the end of my eyes. would recommend !
Soso from Montréal, Qc
The best eyeliner I've used to far. It doesnt smudge and doesn't come off easily. The point of the eyeliner is sturdy and I love it
This is an awesome eyeliner
Teen Adult from Cincinnati, OH
I use this product every single day. I LOVE IT!!!
A Hidden Jem
Becky from Vancouver, WA
I would never have expected an eyeliner that's so affordable to produce such an amazing result! I've always been loyal to Stila for eyeliner, I think this comes pretty close. I love the very fine tip and it makes the process of shaping wings much easier with my hooded eyes.
Lisa from Detroit, MI
I got this liquid liner to try out because I didn't want to spend a lot on a higher end brand one (Too Faced Better Than Sex is my go to and is AMAZING). I read some reviews prior to buying and there were a few that made me want to try it. I figured for the price, it wouldn't be that great anyways..it's awful. The brush tip is so rough. It actually hurt putting it on. It was not smooth and did not go on smoothly either. And it didn't dry fast either, so when I went to wipe it off right after, it easily came off and made a mess. I normally don't write reviews for products, but this was so bad, I had to.
LindsayM from Maine
This eyeliner is the best eyeliner I've used! I've tried many eyeliners, but this product by far is the most impressive. The eyeliner lasts a good 10 hours or so without smudging/running, and stays matte black throughout the day. The pricing for the product makes it even better! Overall, it's an amazing product, and I can say it's better than a lot of high-end eyeliners I've used in the past. Will continue to use!
Vidhi from undisclosed
This is the best eyeliner you will ever find. Period
TristenF from Searsmont, Maine
Perfect for making cat eye with. Love how it looks on me.
Nicc from Az
Great coverage doesn't bleed
Mmkk from Portland oregon
Love how slim the tip is and how small the base is as well
My forever liner now
Jessica from Illinios
I wear winged eyeliner every single day... I have tried countless liners in all textures and finishes. I have hooded eyes and cannot deal with liners that smudge. This one does not! Although the tube is slim, this has lasted me a while. The formula is quick drying. I'd say if you are a beginner at eyeliner , you will not like this because the more you go over the mistake it will become dry and clumpy. This lasts all day and does not smudge. It's a fast drying one too. I just love it. And it's very black!!!< 3 and you cannot beat the price. This liner is it for me I don't think I will buy any other but this one.
SO long lasting
el from chicago
i invested in this eyeliner this summer, through 90 degrees fahrenheit and chicago humidity this eyeliner did. not. budge. affordable and a bargain for the performance it delivers!
My Go-To Eyeliner
nasai from Missouri
I originally bought this on a whim a few months ago having no successful experiences with eyeliner previously...it's now my holy grail makeup find! I have really shakey hands and my lashes make it difficult to apply liquid liners, so the fine tip marker-style of this eyeliner is so helpful. Super easy to apply--like a sharpie marker honestly. Lasts pretty much all day through school, work, and the gym with almost no smudging but will remove easily with micellar water. I'd love to see it come in more colors in the future!
Lexiewiu from Colorado
love, will keep buying
Shanshan57 from Colorado
This eyeliner is actually bomb for the price. Thin and dark and long lasting.
THE ABSOLUTE BEST !
Adcuenco from San Diego
This is legit my holy Grail eyeliner and I've used a TON as a mua and regular person. This one doesn't budge and I get super oily, sweaty and to top it off I have a slightly hooded lids... Basically the trifecta of things that are a nightmare for eyeliner wearers ! I wear it all day at the office and then go immediately to the gym and it's doesn't budge until I'm ready to remove it with a bit of coconut oil. Since it is liquid I obviously can't smudge or smoke it out like a pencil, but considering it's staying power and ease of use, I don't care. This will be my go-to liner from now on for sure ! :)
Jessica from North Carolina
I absolutely love this eyeliner. I am by no means talented when it comes to applying liquid eyeliner, and I just have very shaky hands, but this gives me so much control. It goes on so smoothly, is very pigmented, and it lasts forever, it is by far my favorite liquid eyeliner.
Victoria1 from undisclosed
Bleeds a little but not much, very pigmented, easy to use, great price.
Simply the best!
Missmarla from Austin Texas
I have repurchased this soo many times I need to start an automatic reorder every few weeks! So smooth and black and precise and the price is NICE!!!!