Product Reviews Rated 4.56 out of 5 stars
2476 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best liquid liner! Ordered this in black matte and have had it for about a week - absolutely love it! Liquid liner is staple in my everyday look and it is extremely hard to find a precise brush and one that lasts all day. After buying tons and tons of different brands, I have finally found my favorite. The matte finish is great and the flexible brush allows me to create any type of line from work professional, to fun and funky. The only drawback is that I wouldn't recommend this to someone just starting to use liquid liner due to the amount of control needed to apply since this tube is very skinny and compact and does not give a ton of control.
Most Helpful Critical Review Dissapointed in NYX I normally love most of NYX's products. They're at a good price point while still working pretty well. I was excited to try this eyeliner cause I love skinny brush eyeliners, as I have a hooded eye and not the steadiest hand. However, I was SUPER dissapointed in this. The application was fine, but the formula ended up awful. I think I had it on less than an hour before it start flaking off. And this is with a primed eyelid too! I ended up returning it and will instead stick with their Epic Ink eyeliner.
Reviewed by 2476 customers HUGE disappointment 1
Jen from Columbus, OH
For years my go-to liquid eyeliner was a $4 drug store brand with a brush/bristle tip (I personally don't like felt tip liners) but that one became nearly impossible to find. As a college student on a budget, I needed something cheap but reliable. I have used many NYX products before and felt satisfied with the quality for the price. But this eyeliner was a huge disappointment. It applies well; the color is very pigmented and the formula isn't watery/runny. But it dried up and flaked-off not even an hour after applying it & would peel off my false lashes with it. Judging by the amount of positive reviews, maybe I just had a product from a bad batch. Either way, I won't be spending money on this product again.
Holy grail liner!!! 5
Lilah from Washington
I've been using this eyeliner for yearssss and there's no better eyeliner out there especially for the price. I have oily lids so it's a pain to find an eyeliner that doesn't transfer or smudge but this one has never let me down
Cakey 2
LS from Las Vegas, NV
Really cakes up and flakes off. Glad it was cheap.
BEST EYELINER! 5
YaGirlMargaret from Hawai'i
I'm telling you, this is my car the best eyeliner I've ever used and I've been through a lot. My skin and eyelids and oily. My biggest issue with eyeliner was that it would transfer on to my lid because of how oily my face would get. Put this eyeliner. MY HOLY GRAIL!!! I don't know how much times I've purchase this over and over again. And for the price. I'm sold for life.
No need for any other eyeliner. 5
DarkskinGirl from Denver, CO
This is my favorite liquid eyeliner ever. I've been using this for the past 4 years. No need to try anything else. This is the one!!!!!
#1 FAVE Eyeliner 5
KC45 from TX
I've been using this eyeliner for probably about 2 years now. It's literally the only one I buy anymore. I used to buy pen liners but they would dry out so fast and never give me this same rich black color I can get from this one!! I tell everyone about this liner it's seriously the best and the price is awesome too. I end up buying multiples so I can have a stock!!!
It's super pigmented, easy to use, and matte which is exactly what I'm looking for
My fave eyeliner 5
Sos111 from Riverside
This is my go to liquid liner! It lasts all day but is very easy to remove. I love it!
Love it! 5
Celeste from Monrovia, CA
This eyeliner is easy to apply and lasts all day! I would definitely buy this again.
Best eyeliner! 5
Adri from San Jose
This is the only eyeliner I swear and have been using for the past 4 years. The pigment and quality is really amazing in comparison to the high end brands. This me does have a matte finish. It lasts a long time and doesn't come off that easily if you cry or whatever. Give this one a try and I'm sure it won't disappoint!
Matte for days 5
Jenjen1217! from Bloomfield, Nj
I love to use this before putting on my false lashes. I feel it helps adhere the lash better and also gives a more lush look.
love it! 5
helen from miami fl
extremely pigmented and black. best and cheapest i've used.
Great product 5
P from Texas
Absolutely love it
Makes the sharpest matte cat eye 5
Nicole from Miami, Florida
I use this over high end liners now. I get so many compliments on the wing I make with this. It drys down quickly and doesn't smudge even in the Miami heat and humidity I live in! Liquid liner is great because it glides right over any eyeshadow or glitter smoothly and effortlessly. Best Nyx product BY FAR.
Disappointing brush (And it leaks!) 2
Liv from Michigan
The product (liquid) itself is nice, but the brush and container are super frustrating... it leaked all over my hands and the brush is too long/thin/straight that it's hard to control and make a perfect wing. I've been winging my eyeliner for years and this brush made it feel virtually impossible.
I have used this eyeliner for year's 5
Sewcrazy from Modesto
This product is amazing for the price. Been using it for years and will continue. Stays on in cold or hot weather lasts all day loving it!!
My favorite eyeliner 5
Doja bay from Sj
I will not trade this in, she's my go tooo. That matte looks way better than gloss. Last all day and comes off completely in face wash. Drys fast and sharp brush.
Better Than I Expected 4
Jimena from Austin, TX
i'm a beginner and looking for affordable makeup. i heard great things about this eyeliner, and honestly, it's great for people like me who are just starting out. most of my wings turns out really good when using this and it stays on for hours and through sweating. my only complaint is the end doesn't hold a lot of product. other than that, it's great.
Not for dryer eyes 2
Kate from la jolla
It dries down very matte, is super budge proof but on my dryer eyelids, it becomes tight like when you put on a clay mask and cracks and crumbles as time passes. For oily lids, this product would probably be very good for but for my lids, they just hurt :( Would not buy again.
sticky mess with no control 1
Sarah from Augusta, GA
This was a huge mess. It was gooey and did not apply well at all. It takes a long time to dry and transfers everywhere, What were they thinking with this? You have no control over where the product goes with such a terrible brush. Most of NYX liners are amazing, but this one is a rare miss.
BEST EYELINER EVER 5
Molly from Seattle, WA
This eyeliner is amazing. So easy to apply and lasts all day! Makes the perfect thin line and wing. I was always afraid to try a brush tip eyeliner - but this one is amazing. Not to mention, it lasts forever. You honestly cannot beat this price and quality. Don't waste your money on high end products. This one does the same thing better.
Only matte liquid eyeliner i will ever use! 5
Dani from Texas
This is a holy grail for me. I love this eyeliner so much!
Best Drugstore Eyeliner!! 5
Sassy Cathy from Rochester, MN
I love this eyeliner and use it everyday! It applies easily and lasts all day :)
Bad Reaction on Eyes 1
Sam from Texas
After my first day of wearing it, my eyes were extremely red and swollen the next day. I don't have sensitive skin and this is the first time I've ever had a bad reaction towards makeup. I tried it again, just in case it could have been something else that might have triggered that reaction, but after just 3 hours, it was back to being red and swollen. The wear throughout the day was alright. It did get pretty flaky after a few hours, my elf eyeliner usually lasts a bit better.
Smooth application 5
Chavela from Oakland
First time trying this eyeliner and I love it!
Affordable.Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeliner! 5
CeCeChristophe from Marrero, LA
I'm SO GLAD I purchased this hidden gem! So inexpensive and performs better than prestige brands. Will be buying more in the future. This applicator is perfect for precision placement. Fast-drying and stays in place.
