Rated 4.55 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best liquid liner!
Ordered this in black matte and have had it for about a week - absolutely love it! Liquid liner is staple in my everyday look and it is extremely hard to find a precise brush and one that lasts all day. After buying tons and tons of different brands, I have finally found my favorite. The matte finish is great and the flexible brush allows me to create any type of line from work professional, to fun and funky. The only drawback is that I wouldn't recommend this to someone just starting to use liquid liner due to the amount of control needed to apply since this tube is very skinny and compact and does not give a ton of control.
Most Helpful Critical Review Dissapointed in NYX
I normally love most of NYX's products. They're at a good price point while still working pretty well. I was excited to try this eyeliner cause I love skinny brush eyeliners, as I have a hooded eye and not the steadiest hand. However, I was SUPER dissapointed in this. The application was fine, but the formula ended up awful. I think I had it on less than an hour before it start flaking off. And this is with a primed eyelid too! I ended up returning it and will instead stick with their Epic Ink eyeliner.
Reviewed by 2504 customers My go-to liner
Jj from Tyler, tx
Love this liner! It's pitch black, goes on smooth and doesn't take forever to dry.
Never buying another liquid liner again
Baileyyyyy from Oregon
I fell in love with this liner the first time I used it. It's perfect for everyday looks as well as more glam looks. I won't go back to any of the liners I was using before.
Using it for 6 years!
Dee from Phoenix
I started using this when I was a teenager bc it was so inexpensive and easy to use n clean up! Glad to say that it's still my favorite liner to this day and it still hold up. I'm literally never going to buy any other black eyeliner ever.
Fashion1st from Illinois
Great liner for the price. I can make smooth and effortless wings to my eyes with this.
Always reliable and great cost!
Ellie from California
This eyeliner is legit. I wear winged eyeliner every day and when someone suggested this to me I tried it out and was NOT disappointed. It lasts all day, even through tears and EVEN WHEN I WENT SWIMMING. But easily comes off with makeup remover or light scrubbing.
That being said, if you do disturb it too much it'll flake off, but that's to be expected. And while it holds up in water, it's not forever. (But still I was impressed when it didn't bleed off when I went swimming.)
My only con is that it's still not 100% matte, but I'll keep buying it because at this price point you'd be hard pressed to find something with such longevity.
I would buy again
Leen from Monterey park ca
Easy to use
Angela from Va
I suck at doing my eyeliner and so far it's made it easy to practice the wand is just so long but that's about the only issue other than that it's matte and easy to take off (pro tip use micellar water if it's not coming off for you!)
Amariee from Chino
Decided to give it a try because it had good reviews. Real smooth and easy to apply but once it's dried off and after a few hours of wearing it, it starts to flake. Wouldn't recommend if you want it to last all day. Easy to remove.
Fan for years
Jasmine from Oceanside, CA.
I searched for my eyeliners from high end to low. THIS product is the holy grail. The Matte finish is MATTE and I never have to re apply
Great for the price
Jenjen from CA
If you are looking for a good matte black eyeliner at the drugstore,one with a brush tip and not a felt tip, look no further. Doesn't bleed, or flake off as long as you prime your eye lids and set them afterwards you're good to go. It's also very black and it reminds me a lot of the NYC eyeliner from back in the day that was discontinued.
its a no from me
lucia from atlanta
i did not like it its so hard to take off and gooey and gross and ugh its j annoying and i dont like and i dont think y'all should buy it.
Jaz from Oregon
This eyeliner is amazing, makes a perfect sharp and dark wing. Doesn't flake at all and looks very clean after applying. I definitely recommend!
Good not great. A bit flaky once it dries but applies nicely
Tegan B from Hanover, MA
I've only used it a couple times! But use it when I want a bolder makeup look and it does the trick!
My go to eyeliner!
Blina from Texas
I love this product, it's not to watery, it glides in smoothly and it stays put all day and night. but it's easily removed! Greatest eyeliner in my opinion
Seriously The Best!
Liz from Iowa
I have permanent black eyeliner on and I am in the in-between stage of needing a touch up and needing to find a liner that matches it the best and that is easy to apply. I also didn't want to spend a crazy amount considering I won't need to use it much in the future. I came across this eyeliner and for like $8 I just had to try it! It's so easy to use, the applicator is user friendly I thought, and it creates the smallest line that allows for you to build upon it if you want to make your liner bolder. Very highly recommend!!
my all time fav
m from sf
i've tried legit 8 different eyeliners before this one, and it's a god send. i love it so much. it's what i use everyday! small tip: you can wipe some of the liner off against the opening/top of the container, and it'll work wonders!
Liv from New York
Absolutely incredible! So easy to use ! And doesn't budge ! One of the best drugstore products on the shelves !!
Oily Eyelid Gang: You'll Love This!
JimBob from Wisconsin
I find it hard to find a liquid liner I like because almost all that I've tried transfer to my naturally oily eyelids. This one, however, does not do this! I was scared I was gonna screw up the application coming from a Stila eye pen, but I didn't have any problem.
A very decent brush tip liner
Talia from Chicago, IL
This has been my go-to liner for years. Unlike most, I prefer a brush-tip over a felt-tip due to the precision I get. Brush-tips are usually harder to use but the long wand and handle on this one makes the task just a bit easier. My only issue with it is that it doesn't seem to last me very long and definitely cakes up a bit towards the end of its lifespan. Still, I never regret purchasing this.
Decent not great
CMeghan from Chicago
Nice applicator, easy to apply and detail, but doesn't last long. After a few hours I have black under my eyes and need to touch that up with a cotton swab, and reapply over the original line to keep it looking dark and black, not spotty and sloppy.
Not smudge proof
Ohmymaria from Maryland
Easy to apply however it smudges easily. Very watery.
Meg the makeup lover from Chicago, IL
I would NEVER spend more than this on a liquid eyeliner. This is truly all you need. This makes for a very precise winged eyeliner with sharp edges and the color is very black- unlike some others I've tried. This has been my go to eyeliner. 🙌🏽
nev from florida
I believe I left a review before? But I just spent an entire day wearing it and I have some qualms. After the first application, it wasn't super pigmented. like it almost looked faded. ok, I applied more. then, with the motion of my face, if i looked close it was cracking. Barely noticeable. I spent a few hours outside at a cookout, and it began to smudge all over the top of my eyelid! It did pretty much still keep shape but all these little things are not something I want to have to worry about. Not only that but the bristles on the brush? applicator ? Are messy and sometimes leave me with stray lines.
Jessa from USA
I used to use liquid eyeliner in my teens/early 20s but it always ran and/or smudged off. So I switched to gel eyeliner which worked well but wasn't great for getting thin lines. A few months ago I decided to try this and I'm so glad that I did. I use it in conjunction with my gel eyeliner to perfect my cat eye. Stays put all day and doesn't smudge, plus it's very pigmented.
Mary from Los Angeles, CA
My go to everyday eyeliner.