Rated 4.32 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Gorgeous colors
I bought both the Rustic Antique and Olive You palettes. I love both! I do find that in each palette, there are one or two shadows whose color payoff isn't great, but even those can work well enough with a little more persistent application, with a wet brush, or even as a sheer layer over another color. Most of the shadows have wonderfully rich pigmentation and go on very smoothly. Overall, it's the shimmery shades that perform the best, so if you're eyeing them primarily for the mattes, these might not be your best options. Both palettes work beautifully with my light-medium olive complexion and dark hair and eyes.
Most Helpful Critical Review It's just okay
Was hopeful this would be a good palette because the colors were so beautiful. It felt nice when I swatched it with my fingers, but I could barely get any pigment to show up when applying to my eyes with my brushes. None of the colors seemed to blend well, they kinda got all muddled together. I even tried using this with and without several primers. I would put on a primer and then set with one of the light shades, barely made a difference! Overall I'm pretty disappointed with this palette, it's too expensive for the quality you're getting, and usually I love NYX palettes especially the dreamcatcher ones! I'm going to return it and put the money towards a higher-end palette.
Reviewed by 210 customers No Pigment!
Ems13 from Indianapolis
Very chalky and NO pigment
New favorite palette!
Emily Formisano from Florida
Great pigment and blends amazing. My favorite palette now. Looks great on my skin tone.
Perfect filter shadow palate
Starbaby from Sacramento California
Great combination of light and dark, warm and cool. Great basic.
I Reach For This Often!
suzeann from Naples, FL
I've had enough time to play around with the pigments, and discovered that the application of each in the "Olive You" palette apply silky smooth, and stay put throughout the day. There is no fading, no powder all over the palette. Love it!
etherealfire from Lake Arrowhead, California
I love the color story in this palette!!! So very lovely.
Megajules from VA
I normally love Elf products but this palette was so bad, it did nothing. No color at all. I ended up throwing it in the trash in a rage, it was that bad.
They really are Perfect!
Marjorie from VA, USA
I have these in Golden Hour and Gloomy days, and they are just about my favorites! Gloomy days for when I want to go smokey, and Golden Hour for a more natural look. I have had no problems with the formula. Very pigmented, and work especially well over NYX Pearl White eye shadow base. Well worth the price!
Suprise and dissappointed
Dung_Nina from Usa
I receive it and They broke a lot. It is poor and cheap quality. When I open then wondering why it has a lot black color inside while its picture has no black color.
Finally a Green Palette!
Elai from Houston
I've been waiting for a good olive green palette and found one. I will probably use all the colors except the darkest and the yellow since I have a fair complexion. The colors are good and they go on well, especially if you wet them. Love the number of shimmer colors you get and the matte darker colors. Only issue is some of the darker colors fade after a few hours and you have to reapply. Overall, I give it a four star. The price is good considering how hard it is to find a cruelty-free, green palette. And I like the maroon they threw in, too. The palette has a good group of colors.
Mimidale from N. Texas
I love this palette!!! I use primer under any shadow & these colors are the perfect muted tones. My favorite (and the reason I've bought this 3x) is the 2nd shadow on the front. It is iridescent & is beautiful on the lid. I use the gray to the right of it for the crease & underlash line.
Scurry414 from Jersey
Great quality but not a huge fan of the color selection.
I like it!
minobia from South Dakota
I real like the colors and I didn't have a problem blending it. The value is amazing and it's NYX. It's a quality product that isn't expensive.
JH from Nashville, TN
Wouldn't repurchase. The shadows can be choppy and hard to blend.
nice colors, very good quality
deedee77 from alexandria, va
I love the colors in these Perfect Filter collections, I have three of them! Also, the quality is good, they go on well and stay on.
Nancy from Indiana
This palette is such a good deal!!!! Great everyday colors and blends easily.
Olive you, too
Projekt Aries from Tacoma, WA
This palette is fitting my grungy mood. The colors all swatch nicely, wear and blend fantastically and had some lasting power through a night with friends. Although the palette I received did have a slightly damaged corner of the bright yellow in the bottom left, it still works beautifully. All of the shades build up well, even the lighter more top-coat feeling shade with cute glitter in it. I'm very pleased with this palette.
Love this palette
BeckyKC from Kansas City
Really love this palette. Great color payoff, blends easily and lasts all day. The pans are large so this palette will last a long time.
Beautiful color and pigmentation
Mizz Lizz from New York, NY
I absolutely loved the palette for the orange and brown hues it offered. They are very pigmented and don't take much stroking for the color to pop on your eyelids.
Perfect for anytime!
Reese from Fishers, IN
Love this product! Very pigmented and easy to apply and blend!
Love the colors
Seaah from Stl
Great for every skin tone. Velvet soft. The colors are vibrant.
Good colors for every day
yesimthatlisa from Wisconsin, USA
Nyx eye palettes have become my go to palettes - so much variety and really good colors for every day.
Tori's from California
Pigmented shadows, perfect palette for cool tones.
Love, Love, Love!!!
TJ from Las Vegas
Bought this on a whim and it is a palette I return to especially this winter with my cooler tone outfit choices.
Not bad for the price
Zippy from Phoenix
The marine blue and green have more shimmer then what I would normally wear. The light blue and gray are good shades that work well together as does the dark purple. On the fence about this and may return for the Dream Catcher pallet again. Definitely worth the price.
Love the color choices
Brina from Ma
Yes NYX shadows aren't that pigmented but if you know what you're doing you can make it work. I love the color choices in this palette, I feel like not enough brands cater to the people who like grungy cool tones.