Rated 4.52 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Just as good as the more expensive makeup remover cloths!
I got a sample of the Makeup Eraser and fell in love with the product, but not the price point ($20 for only one cloth). I knew I would need more than one cloth and I knew there had to be another brand out there with a greater value. I was so thrilled to find this product by chance when browsing Ulta. I was so excited to try the cloth and it did not disappoint. They completely take off my makeup with just some water and rubbing. I have fairly sensitive skin, so this product is great for me because now I do not have to keep using makeup wipes that sometimes irritate my skin. They take the makeup off my face just as well too. I am very happy I found this product!
Most Helpful Critical Review I returned the product
I've been using Wonder Cloths and thought I would try another brand. So, I bought this at Ulta. Tried it once, and returned it because it did not remove my make up well, it didn't wash clean as the other brand does, and it left pink fuzzies all over my face.
Reviewed by 75 customers Makeup eraser
Bossbabe91 from Indiana
I use this when wiping/washing off my makeup.
Not Lovin' it
Skylar from Spruce Pine, NC
Wanted to try these out, because I cant seem to find the right cleanser. Not loving them so far.
Ally from Dacula, Georgia
I just started using it and it's great!
First time user
Allison J. from Omaha
The last time I was low on my cleansing oil, I was looking through makeup remover options and came across these. Now, I have of course heard of the Makeup Eraser but since I have never used a product like this, I was not going to spend a bunch of money on a single cloth. I bought this three pack and I love them so much, I'm about to order more!
1. Takes off makeup easily w/o an oil or balm
2. Much more eco-friendly
3. No buying new cleansing oils, balms, removers
4. Easy to launder
5. Minimal rubbing
6. The size is perfect. Not too big, not too small
1. I'm not a fan of the exfoliating side, I'd rather be able to use both sides for taking off makeup. The exfoliating side just feels weird on my skin.
2. They stain, which is fine, but for that reason, I would prefer a black or grey cloth - but this is also a preference
Ordering more soon
Katelyn from San Antonio, TX
I've been using these for almost 2 months now and I love them! I was definitely skeptical when I bought them, but they're effective and gentle. Single use makeup wipes are a drain on both the environment and your wallet, and normal washcloths irritate my skin. These cloths are the perfect solution. The only thing is that I haven't tried them with waterproof mascara. With regular mascara they work great, though. With these, I've managed to get thick layers of stage makeup off my face. I'm not sure what the other reviews meant when they said that these burn their eyes; I've had no problems like that and I have pretty sensitive skin. To prevent that I would recommend washing them before using them. I'm not entirely sure how those people messed up.
Mari Jo from Florida
These are so soft and gentle on your face! I tried it with makeup remover and with just water and got the same results! I now jump into the shower with this after work and take off my makeup with warm water and these cloths. They're amazing! I bought for my mom, sister, and cousins! They're amazed by these too! The makeup will stain them, but they get the job done better than anything else I've ever used! No need for harsh makeup remover or vigorous rubbing. And that price!!
My favorite reusable makeup remover wipes!
CaitlynBaitlyn from Chicago
These are like magic! They truly take all your makeup off with just water! The only thing they do not remove is waterproof mascara, so I use an oil cleanser first, and then use these to wipe my skin clean.
Amazing !! Money well spent !
Liv from New York
These are so soft and the perfect size !! So much cheaper and eco friendly than buying and tossing out makeup wipes and these are also better for your skin. I just use water and then go back over my eyes with liquid make up remover using the exfoliating side to make sure everything is gone and then use my normal face wash and a washcloth. To clean these I use Castile soap and rub the material together, and then I throw them in the wash with dark clothes or towels !!
Angie from Wakanda
I'm trying to cut down on single use products, including makeup wipes. Now I just use these which work extremely well for me. They're very low maintenance, and since I don't wear makeup often I don't need to use these too much. Three is just enough.
Caused major irritation
Adrienne from FL
I washed these before using but there is something in it that made my face around my eyes and eyelids extremely irritated. This was after just 1 use. I had a rash, puffiness, and itching eyes and swollen eyebrows for 2 days post use.
I wanted to love them but ugh
Lex from WV
Idk what the deal is with these. I wanted to love them so bad. I have super sensitive skin and every time I use them, my eyes swell so bad and end up flaming and peeling. I thought it was my cleanser so I tried multiple cleansers and the only time my eyes don't swell like this is when I don't use these wipes.
April from WV
I started using makeup remover cloths when I purchased my first Makeup Eraser cloth. I loved it but didn't see the point of paying so much for one. Then I found Vintage Cosmetic Co. I thought I'd give it a try and see how these cloths compared to more expensive ones. No difference at all. So soft, easily removes makeup, has an exfoliating side, washes well and lasts just as long. Very good quality product at a great price! I love that they have a 3 pack. I've even got my best friend using these too.
4teesomething from Midwest
These are so handy and work great. I usually use some warm water and my makeup comes off pretty easily. For stubborn eyeliner I'll dab on some Micelle water (I use the one from NYX). They wash up pretty clean - I just throw them in with regular laundry and then in the dryer. They come out almost brand new. Still super soft and maybe a faint stain. I don't use fabric softener on them. Oh, the rougher "exfoliating" side is great for wiping excess product off your makeup brushes! I love these so much because they work and I'm not wasting cotton balls or disposable wipes.
Works like a charm!
Kayla from East Lansing, MI
I love these. They work just as well as my Makeup Erasers and are much more affordable. Just add water and they waterproof makeup. Easy to clean and eco-friendly.
STOP USING MAKEUP WIPES
Brook from Dallas, TX
This is what EVERYONE should switch to. These cloths are very soft and gentle on the skin and are less likely to cause wrinkles like most makeup wipes tend to do. Easy to keep clean, reuse, and are better for the environment. Always feels like a self care night when I use these!
These are so cute and they work
Heidi from Texas
These are cheaper and better and prettier than the original. I highly recommend! you won't be disappointed. When I use make up wipes and other ways to take off make up, I still have left over make up. Using a makeup eraser will not leave any extra make up. Make sure you wash the cloth before use. Use circular motions to erase eye make up. I love love these and they work and you are not wasting. Also, using a make up wipe always left a film and these do not.
madi from manteca
idk they just were not that great and didnt really take my makeup off or anything. and they did not come clean at all
Renee from Eau Claire, Wi
Wish I would've picked the darker color just because of the makeup appearance. It doesn't wash out of the light pink.
These are amazing!
Keva from Palm Harbor
I never expected these to take off all of my eye makeup with just water but they do!
HOLY WOW never buying makeup wipes again
Lizzy from Chicago,IL
this is so amazing. its literally like a magic eraser. you have to gentle on eyelashes but they still remove waterproof mascara with a gentle touch. They also stain easily but i dont mind that at all.
Kay from Pa
I had very little faith that this would take my makeup off with no cleanser on it since i wear a lot of eye makeup, but i was proven wrong! I have NO idea how it works but it works so well. I've been using it over my makeup remover wipes. I've only ran then through the wash once so far so now sure how they will hold up over repetitive washes but as of right now I'm completely obsessed.
Sarah from Illinois
I wasn't sure what to expect.. it does sound legit. I have used olay wipes for year but I can go through them fast and also it's always 5-6 dollars. Wasting a lot of money. I wear a lot of bronzer, brows, dark mascara and I ran this cloth under warm water and straight into my face and VIOLA it took it off EASIER than my wipes!! Woo!! Invest invest this will save you money in the long run. I have already washed them and re used again. I'm in love. I do wash my face afterwards with basic liquid soap. If it didn't have this I would be wiping or either washing my face with wash at least 3x.
Skin care routine must have!
Lenzie ♥️ from Peoria, Arizona
I was skeptical about using a product that claims to wash your face completely free of makeup without the use of some sort of face cleanser.
Simply wet towel with warm water and wipe away all face and eye makeup without scrubbing and cleansers!
Amazing for the price!
AV from Scottsdale AZ
I tried the other "branded" one and liked it but needed more. I decided to try these since they're half the price for 3 versus 1. They get everything off, including waterproof mascara. I swear by these. Buy them, you won't regret it!!!
Bang for your buck
Ksaun from Chesterfield, Mo
These make-up cloths are a great value and great quality. They are super soft and get the job done. Snatch these up!