Rated 3.84 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love
I was hesitant to buy this liner because of its cheap price. I only use felt tips and do winged liner on a daily basis, but I recently switched from the Stila stay all day to the Kardashian felt tip liner for its affordability. I tend to only get about 1-1.5 months use out of any liner whether it's drugstore or not. But this liner was cheaper than my drug stores favorites and it is so pigmented and easy to apply !!
Most Helpful Critical Review It's OK but.....
It transfers if u don't set it.
It doesn't fully cover bold shimmery shadows
It doesn't glide over my wrinkly eyelids very well
The tip is very firm and short which I don't like
Doesn't flow very eell have to shake and give it a while to complete one eye .
I think thus would be perfect for practicing a wing placement but I don't wear this bc of the transfer.
Reviewed by 67 customers She Thick
JayJayCar from Solon, IA
This is good to use for the lid part of doing eyeliner. It's not good to use when you are trying to make a wing. The tip is too thick for that. But the quality is good.
Do not recommend
Emilee from Houston, TX
I wouldn't recommend this product. Was trying a cheaper alternative but this is not worth even the low price point.
sierra from pittsburgh pa
bought it expecting good things since bh is a p good brand. i was wrong. using this is like using a dried out mr sketch marker to draw on eyeliner. not very pigmented and the tip is way too hard. i literally have only used it once and it's like this.
rose from oregon
I used it once and its already dried out.
Far too little
FromTheWest from Wyoming
This eyeliner quit working after less than 4 uses. The super soft tip quickly became overly soft and the tip basically became useless. It left splotchy opaque lines instead of bold black sharp edges. :(
Reign7411 from South Dakota
Wasn't expecting much out of this liner simply because of the brand and discounts/price etc...but I do like to try new liners, hoping I'll find my #1! it was super cheap maybe even free with my purchase. I figured I'd try it quick just for the top lash line, no wing nothing fancy just add some definition. It was smeared before I was even done. I figured it'd be good for AT least a quick lil line of color.... Negative! it wears like a bad kohl pencil; smearing down onto the bottom lash and the crease. Wouldn't suggest wearing it for anything important. Don't care for it. Spend your money on something else.
smudged without touching
sharksgirl from san jose
I wanted to like this, but it didnt stay put as well as it should. once it "dried" it was way too shiny and looked weird with matte eyeshadow. I've left on crayon type eyeliner, gel, and other marker over night and they didnt smudge like this one did. I dont even finish a work day and its smudged under my eyes when I only applied on upper eyelid and never once touched my eyes. not worth it.
Not exactly waterproof
Verucasalt10 from Portland, oregon
This eyeliner is good value for the price. It goes on great, nice and smooth. The reason I give it 3 stars is that it is not as waterproof as it should be for an eyeliner labeled waterproof. It's also very hard to remove. This is a good product for day use or for going out but I wouldn't rely on it for all day and all night.
Steph B from Stl
I can't get this to work with eye makeup and without eye makeup. Don't like it at all. Tried on hand goes on great nothing on eye
Great for the price
Rissa from Oregon
Yes it does transfer slightly before it dries down, but I've had that issue with higher end liners all the same. Easy to maneuver and I think the felt tip is a good shape/size. Overall, if you're looking for a cheap black eyeliner that stays put, this is a winner
MY NEW FAVE
Kels from Jacksonville,NC
I recently bought this eyeliner and I absolutely love it. I use it every single day and it hasn't dried up on me. It makes such a perfect wing and it comes out so dark, I just love it. Makes the perfect wing every single time!
Amelia from Morristown, NJ
The very first time I used this product it literally dried out before my eyes. I couldn't even finish one side of my winged eyeliner before it got dry and wouldn't draw on my eye anymore. Disappointed and a complete waste of money.
Simpler is better
Jill from Tampa
I often find that cheaper felt tip eyeliners are better. When you buy from higher name brands they are always trying to reinvent the shape of the tip for application and I just need a simple felt tip for a wing. No bells and whistles and this works great
YES! I would buy this product over and over again
NG££ from Nigeria
Best eyeliner I've used
Xo.Zoey from Texas
This eyeliner is PERFECT if you are trying to get that perfect wing. I love this eyeliner and the price is unbeatable! I can never find an eyeliner this cheap and an amazing quality. Highly recommend
Is not was i expected
Banya from Kissimmee Fl
I was not satisfied with this eyeliner.
yessi from new york
amazing!! long lasting for sure
Jen from Chino
It bleeds like crazy and isn't that pigmented
MrsT from Jurupa Valley Ca
Bleeds like crazy. Transfers. Smears. Doesn't go on smooth. Not Cute. Was hoping this would be my new holy grail. Its not.
Stella from Canoga Park, CA
I love the price and product you cant go wrong. I'm glad i found this product.
Great Find for the Price
Ana from Austin, Tx
For the price point, this is the best eyeliner pen I've found. It's super easy to apply and VERY pigmented. It doesn't fade either which is a problem I've had with some other low cost liquid liners. I do wish the tip we're a little thinner so I had more versatility when doing a wing, but for five bucks or so I can't complain!
Mikaela from Nashville,TV
This bleeds terribly, and wears off after a long day. However, its not bad for the price---- BUT I still don't recommend this product.
this product is depends
spork the dork from alberta
it is good if you want something cheap and easy, but i would not recommend if you want something long lasting.
I was very impressed!
Anna from Castro Valley, CA
I loved it!... It was creamy and very easy to apply. It also lasted a long time. I was very impressed with the quality considering the price. I liked it better than other more expensive brands.
Grey ** from Victorville, California
it is so dry. I can't apply it.