Rated 4.04 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great Product But Color Selection is Off
I bought both the 005 and 010 colors as I did not know which one would work for me. They are both light colors but if you are super pale they may not be quite light enough for you. The 010 color is on the pinker side and much better at brightening the under eye area than the yellow toned 005 color that may even be a tad darker than the 010 color. The product blends out well and looks pretty natural with good coverage so if the colors work for you, its a great product.
Most Helpful Critical Review Can you say oxidation???
I cannot believe that more people do not complain about how terribly this product oxidizes! Yes it is ridiculous that they only have 3 shades, but I am Fair / Nude and still cannot make a single shade work for me...they all turn so dark when they dry. Also, there is simply no comparison to the coverage that these offer vs. the Tarte Shape Tape. Don't even buy into that whole conversation for a minute. So disappointed that beauty gurus sing the praises of this product.
Reviewed by 604 customers the scent omg
Sage from Alberta
This is a pretty great product in the sense that it's very transfer-proof and long lasting. It also gives you a nice matte finish and is pretty full coverage but can be sheered out. I'm really just taking off 2 stars because of the fragrance. I'm usually not bothered by scents in products at all, but the scent in this concealer is what's keeping me from repurchasing it. It smells like very very strong cleaning product and gives me a headache if I use too much. The artificial smell is a huge con for me but if you are very very impervious to scents and can tolerate the smell of sharpies and clorox wipes you might be able to handle this product. I'm gonna use mine up because I have it and the formula is actually pretty good but I don't think I'll be buying it again unless they release a version of the concealer that's fragrance-free.
(plz read this review)
Kadence K from Tennessee
This a great concealer but the tube came like 3/4 of the way full so a little disappointed (also go like 3 shades down it oxidizes like crazy)
Not for dry under eyes.
Smiles22 from LA
I heard wonderful things about this concealer but all it did for me sadly was just magnify my dryness underneath my eyes. If u have dry under eyes like me I wouldn't recommend you trying this. Otherwise, if u don't have that issue like myself then it might be worth a try since it did blend nicely underneath my eyes. It does cover blemishes as well.
Hands down my all time HG concealer
YoungNP from MPLS, MN
I love this concealer!! The new formula doesn't have the same strong chemical smell (but even if it did I would use it). I do think the new formula doesn't smooth out as nicely or go as far but overall I love. I am fair to light skin and often use porcelain or light bisque for my undereyes, or at times as my foundation. I purchased light natural in the new added color range and it pulls a bit pink on me. I have neutral to warm/yellow undertones. Cant beat it for the price!
Annie from Missouri
There is too much fragrance in this product. It also does not cover very well.
Jenn from Minnesota
Great product. Great price!
Ok, but changes color throughout day
Aisha from New Jersey
It looks great when it goes on but a few hours later it looks very yellow. The yellow is less noticeable under foundation but if you use a light coverage foundation or none at all the yellow is too noticeable
A little goes a long way
WiMama from Madison WI
I use shade 005 Light Natural. I use a small dot on the outer and inner corner of eye and blend with fingertip. It gives high coverage but blends out nicely. It is a creamy formula and dries down matte. I suggest prepping the under eye with an emollient moisturizer to prevent caking. I like this concealer!
Laura from Minnesota
Learning to use concealer the way people are using it today. Back when I started to play with concealer, we put this on then the foundation, so I'm still playing with the opposite idea!
Raqui from Maryland
This has to be my favorite concealer. The shade is perfect for me - I wear 001 and it's pale enough for my super fair skin, but is neutral enough to cover my dark circles and blend in nicely with my skintone. It is high coverage but not cakey. I love it!
Super high coverage
Sab from Las Vegas, NV
A VERY high coverage concealer! This thick formula goes great on my dark under-eyes and conceals them impressively well for how inexpensive it is. I do not like the brush very much as it scoops too much concealer at once, but the formula is so good I will probably buy again.
Best concealer ever
Ashleigh from TN
Love love love this concealer! About a dozen colors to choose from. I have light skin with slight tan, and I use 018 and 020, but really I could even use a couple of the lighter shades. Super disappointed that this brand has been taken out of my nearby Ulta store and hope it doesn't get taken off online.
Can't beat it.
Laura from Vermont
The best concealer I've ever used. Heavy coverage, and dries relatively quickly, so work fast. That said, it's very brightening and ideal for pale people with living dead eye bags. 🙃
And the price? I mean. Come on!
not that great
pheobe from la
this product does not do as good as other concealers i does not help that much with dark circles and if you ordering this online get a shade lighter than what you think you are
Best drugstore concealer!
Jess from GA
This is the closest I've found to the nars creamy concealer which I love, has less coverage but layers well and looks natural under the eyes.
Brightens my under eye
Ashley from Michigan
I wanted a concealer that would brighten my under eye, and this does exactly that. I have not seen any dryness or settling, and I was able to get this to blend easily just with my finger. Very happy I bought this!
n010 from ca
first time trying catrice concealer and I really like it. Pretty full coverage and has a nice feel under the eyes. Definitely recommend
Excellent Product for Oil/Combination Skin
Chels from 19116
I do not know why ppl insist on writing reviews when they do not know how to properly moisturize their skin or why they would write a review if they don't even know the type of skin they have. At Ulta the girls told me that woman swear by this concealer. Do yourself a favor and learn what "Cool", "Beige" "Fair," " Ivory" Or other warm tone definitions before you make a review thats not accurate. I have been on other reviews for the worst products for oily/skin types and sensitive where ppl do not know what theyre talking about. I tried this today and it not anywhere near that difficult to work with if you know how to use a 215
Mac brush then do so. Use a primer underneath as well. Stays on without gross talc to put on top so its excellent for ppl who wear contact lenses who do not want their eyesight obstructed from powder. I used the Porcelain shade which has yellow tones in it to counteracts under eye dark circles. Lastly, if you use foundation consider that the product could be causing mix to a color. Absolutely would recommend this concealer and the price point is spot on. Clean and great for sensitive skin as well.
Katie from Texas
I bought this because of beauty guru Tati's reviews from long ago and I was very curious. When I saw all the shades at Ulta, I thought, "Finally, I can see what the buzz is about!" I bought shades 32 and 36. For some reason, shade 36 was lighter? But, after inspecting all the shades as best I could at Ulta (without being able to swatch things due to the pandemic) the rest of the shades had the wrong undertones or seemed too light or dark.
I decided to go with 32 and when I swatched it on my hand at home, it seemed like a good match.
So, I applied shade 32 using Robert Welsh's concealer technique (a DOT on the inner and outer corners of my eyes), blended it out with my finger, and ended up with a sheer, patchy layer underneath my eye.
I didn't even try to build it up because multiple layers of concealer under my eyes just makes them look terrible. And for some reason, the shade looked far lighter underneath my eyes than it did swatched on the back of my hand.
Even for $6, this is not worth the money. I have other concealers that work 1000x better.
When I returned this, an employee said she wasn't surprised to see this product being returned.
Catrice, just because you are an affordable cosmetics brand doesn't mean you can put terrible quality products like this on the market. There's no excuse. Get it together.
Ana from Seattle
comparable to tarte shape tape. super sad they no longer carry in store.
Ciara from 30165
The coverage was just ehh. It was so oily and greasy feeling. Very similar to foundation. I could not get it to blend. Was very disappointed. I purchased this along with the foundation off the great reviews. I honest to goodness can't understand why this and foundation have nearly 5 star reviews. Both products were the worst I have ever purchased hands down. Had to return!
Literally the BOMBB!!
MsGam from HoosierHottie
Best concealer ever!!! My holy grail of concealers for sure! And the best part...it's waterproof! Dries great, no creasing, works very well under my Estee Lauder Double Wear foundation and the price is excellent!
I have used shape tape, urban decays concealer, double wear concealer...you name it and this concealer, by far, is my favorite!
Nice coverage but...too much creasing
Jen C from WA
I like the cooling effect and the coverage, but it gets cakey even when you set it. I've tried baking it too but it still creases up.
Much too thick - not what I was looking for
Desi.Shops from Jacksonville, FL
I was looking for a concealer to cover both blemishes and under eye circles, however, this goes on way too thick and I wasn't able to get it to blend.
Good for undereye, NOT for blemishes.
Ashley from Cleveland, OH
This concealer works well for undereye/dark circles, but it basically blended right off of my blemishes and left no coverage. Almost like it would not stick to the skin in those areas. If you're not very acne prone, this is a decent concealer, but I prefer to be able to use one concealer product for undereye and blemishes.