Rated 4.31 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Been using this for 20+ years
I've used this eyeliner since college. Lest you think I'm just stuck in the 90's wearing frosty blue shadow, I'm Not! I continuously try new makeup and I have everything in my makeup shelves from Chanel to MAC to NYX. I've tried other liquid and creme and gel liners but this is by far my fave. It really only comes in black and brown (to not buy the carbon black one that's super black it has some smelly chemical in it) but the regular black and brown are great. Stays on all day. You can sleep in It, wake up and it's still on. It's not hard to remove though. A bit of sweet almond oil on a cotton ball does the job. Anywat, if you're not used to wearing liquid eyeliner it will take awhile to get the hang of, but you can do a thin, or thick line and be as understated or dramatic as you'd like to be. After about 3-4 months it starts to peel easily and not last all day, so I replace it quarterly. It's my fave, hands down.
Most Helpful Critical Review Do not buy this
I love almost all L'Oreal products and I had this eyeliner recommended to me. However, I was not impressed AT ALL.
The brush was flimsy and didn't have enough substance to it - which made it extremely difficult to keep control of the wand. I have been using liquid eyeliner for almost 6 years now, and do not consider myself a novice. I have never ever had this much trouble applying liquid eyeliner. Every time I applied it, it wound up all over my eye instead of where I wanted. Then, once I did finally get a satisfactory application the eyeliner almost immediately began to crack, then peel away and flake off. I would find pieces of it scattered all over my face not even an hour after application. It would literally falling off my eyelid. It almost looked as though I had fallen asleep in my makeup and not bothered to clean up my face.
I will say that the color was rich, but overall I would not waste my money again.
Reviewed by 266 customers use to love this liner
cc from san diego
i used this liner in my teens and early twenties. the applicator is the best ive ever used and glides on smooth and the color is rich and pretty. i gave 3 stars because it is not water resistant. i had to buy a more expensive waterproof liner because i am a crybaby.
Koko from Washington, DC
The color was rich and the application was smooth. My biggest complaint is that the liner is NOT smudge proof. It took a long time to dry and smeared when I accidentally swiped it.
Thatonelady from Indiana
It was super smooth, application was flawless and it dries quick!
Yes it's so easy to use
Mari from Dallas Tx
Goes on smoothly, long lasting
I have used this eye liner for years and love it!
Deb from Coeur d Alene
I have been using this since last 10 years. I love it.
Saba from Colorado
I simply love this brand and the products.
Easy to use but errors readily fixable
Elisa the conservative makeup user from Dallas, TX
This is the only drugstore item I buy over and over
MaryJMUA from SoCal
This liner is really a holy grail item for me. Every time I try another brand- there is either something wrong with the formula or the application. This liner has a smooth and precise application and the formula is great. I have been using this over a decade.
if you bring back the brown or brown/ black
Mom Mom from Cherry Hill, NJ
please bring back the brown or brown/black. I am a redhead with green eyes and the black liner is too harsh. I love the brush. It is much easier for me to control that the felt tip.
Maddie from New Haven
I use it everyday and I love the fact that it stays on fresh all day long until I wash it off. Would not change it for any other liquid liner. This is the best one yet!!! Love it!
Amy from New Hudson MI
My favorite eye liner! Been using it for years! Long lasting! Stays on!
TGH from Las Vegas
Every time I try some new "great" liner, I come back to this. Never smudges underneath my eyes and lasts all day. This has been around for many years. Hope L'Oréal never discontinues.
Not the same
Cee from Ct.
I have been using thi Liquid liner for over 10 years.My last 3 I've noticed the brush is shorter,Liner clumps around the top and the liner flakes off fast.
I love this liquid liner!
Robin from Elon, NC
I love my liquid eyeliner and Lineur Intense is amazing! Easy to use, lasts all day. Can be very subtle, natural look or dramatic.
I would buy this item again
Joy from San Mateo
Have been using this product for years. Not many eyeliners have a brush.
Debbie from West Allis. wi
disappointed...as I would like Brown colors
ritafft from michigan
Out performs all the designer liquid on the market!
Artemis4Arrows from Portland, Oregon
I use this eyeliner as a daily staple. Period. The funny part is I used this when I first started wearing makeup as a teenager in the 1990s. (Actually, it was used by a the makeup artist in the professional theater when I began my performance arts career 1989) Over the years, I have tried liquid eyeliners of all design; pens, gels, etc. by every brand. It was just my thing of recent years, I run out, walk into my local Ulta and ask the Sales Associate which black liquid eyeliner to try and I would try it. The last one, Stilla cost around $20 and was great but did not last. No worries, had my daughter home from University and did an Ulta run! This time walking the aisles and reminiscing to her of makeup days of yester year (!) I stumbled on this Loreal liner -bought it- and low and behold! It is still fabulous! Easy to apply and wears all day! for half the price! I am never going to deviate from what I know works.
Happy camper from Heber Springs Arkansas
I could not find an eyeliner that would stay on all day... even until noon... but this far exceeded my expectations! Stays on until evening! I absolutely love it!
buy something else
MakeupJunkieeee from New York
smudge proof? water resistant? this stuff is trash. a puff of wind could make this eyeliner smudge
I have used this for years
Em from Saint Louis Missouri
The only thing I do not like about this eye liner is that over time it gets clumpy
Artistbarb from Lakeland, Florida
There used to be a water proof eye liner but I haven't been able find one now. If my eye tears, the eye liner comes right off. Otherwise it's easy to apply, I just wish there a water proof one.
Looks like Permanent Liner
Cutie from Boca Raton
Been using this L'Oreal eyeliner for years and I love it and it's hard to find it at a lot of places Ultra always has it
Do not buy! Allergic reaction
Rachel from Canton,OH
Hours after applying my eyelids were burnt, red, swollen and very itchy. Took 3 days to heal and then the skin where the eyeliner on my top eyelid was peeled off.
Gordis from Baytown, Tx
I like it, because I wear it all day and it doesn't smear.