Rated 3.92 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The only eyeliner I will ever use again.
I LOVE this product!! I don't have the most steady hand and have a HUGE problem doing winged eyeliner with any other brand because of how flimsy and imprecise their brushes are. THIS is so good for details and people like me who don't have 15 minutes to sit there and work on applying perfect wings every day. It's so easy to apply! It also doesn't smudge or dry on and feel all gunky to where it cracks. I LOVE this product. If Maybelline ever discontinued it I would cry and probably never find anything else this good again.
Most Helpful Critical Review It's great, but not so great!
I was using Urban Decay's 24 hour liquid liner and switched because of cost. I do love this eyeliner, except that it doesn't last 8 hours! I only work 9-5 and by lunch time my cat eye eyeliner is gone! When I mean gone, I mean it's non-existant. However, I do love how this is so much easier to apply than UD's! I can create a think or thin line easier than with the brush UD provides. Also, the color could be a lot bolder or blacker. It almost looks grey. So, If you are trying to learn how to use liquid liner, master the cat eye or any other look, I would recommend this to start out with. Plus, if you don't like it, you've only spent about $6 instead of $30.
Reviewed by 494 customers Meh!
NikkiB from Clearwater, FL
I just really don't care for the way this applies. No matter how meticulous or careful I am it's almost impossible to make a precise line. I feel like I have to dip it in severl times as I'm going along too which just tends to mess me up even more. I think the tip needs to be a little more firm.
Hailey47 from NY
The color is intense and stays, I love it! I only wish the tip was smaller.
vberk from Tennessee
This is the ONLY eyeliner I have ever used (or plan to ever use)!! I love the liquid look, and the tapered felt gives me great control for winged looks! Love love love!
Xana from Everett
Goes on well, even over shadow & glitter. Only complaint is I often have to let it dry, then go back over my wings once or twice. with a thin wing, that shouldn't be am issue.
I always buy this product. It's accurate, waterproof. Great
Amanda from California
I love using the liquid liner. It's easy to apply and wears 24 hours.
Not for me!
CroseMeza from Irving, TX
I am disappointed I didn't like the applicator. I would not repurchase.
Mikayla from Salem
Bought this because my all time fave eyeliner got discontinued. I had this YEARS ago and it was my first eyeliner so I thought I would retry it. Yeah, big mistake. Big nope.
The pigment is so awful. It'll look very subpart and then 5 minutes later it has faded and was awful. So I tried to reapply some over the faded spots. Well, this made it even worse. It was so patchy and not even all that well black.
Lavren from Charlotte
I never leave reviews, but this product I was surprisingly disappointed by. It applies pretty sh*tty and there is barely any liquid in the tube! It's frustrating. The color is ok, even though it's not the "blackest black" I intended to see. I've been doing winged eyeliner for 6+ years and this made it pretty difficult. We'll see how long it lasts today, but overall a so-so product I wouldn't use as your first choice.
Easy and actually lasts
Maggg from Indiana
Been using this for years! Best liquid eyeliner for the price! Will always buy this one over any others
My favorite eyeliner
Bella from corning
It lasts all day & stays dark, I am absolutely obsessed
Definitely buying this again!
V.Zombie from Hidalgo, Texas
Best liquid eyeliner!
blueeyedbeauty from North Carolina
I've used this eyeliner for several years, and it is consistently excellent! The color is longlasting, even after a long day. One trick to using this product is to shake the container before each application. The color and consistency of the liquid will be much better when applying.
Lindsay from Kansas City
I don't wear eyeliner on an everyday basis, and I've got a shaky hand when it comes to liquid eyeliner application. This is perfect for the occasional date night/night out. The liner goes on smoothly and the brush makes it easy to apply! I love the functionality of this liner- you can do a simple line or a dramatic wing. My only con is that it can fade after a few hours (but even that still takes a while, probably 6-8 before I start to notice) and when I do wings, they are prone to smudging. But overall, this product is a great value!
Sheryl from Rancho Cucamonga, CA
I've been intimidated by liquid liners, but this one is so so easy to apply. Love the applicator. It slides on. It's long lasting, while not requiring harsh scrubbing or harsh cleaning to remove it. Definitely recommend it!
Used for Years!
Lauren from Cincinnati, Ohio
This product glides on super easily and comes in a great company case that allows for easy travel and on-the-go use! Love the color. You are able to achieve any look with this eyeliner - thin lines, thick lines, etc.
The only con of this product is that, because the tube is compact, continual use calls for more frequent purchases. Tube does not last long.
Wouldn't buy again
Beck from Wichita, ks
Felt like it didn't have enough on want to actually do anything.
Smudges a LOT
Elizabeth from Denver, co
I used this a lot in high school and college. I don't know if the formula changed or if I just don't remember how it was before. But it's not good. I gently itched my tear duct and like half my eyeliner disappeared!
DO NOT BUY THIS EYELINER
ryask from Springfield
I purchased this instead of my usually Kat Von D eyeliner. The way the eyeliner applies isn't terrible, however, it does not last. About an hour in to wearing the liner, I had black smudging in my inner corner. The worst part is when you go to remove the liner. It breaks up in to tiny small flakes that get stuck in your eye. So painful.
My Go To
A from Tx
Ive gone through so many eye liners, but this one is by far my favorite. Easy to apply and lasts all day
Literally the best I've tried
Maddie < 3 from Sacramento
As a "YouTube beauty guru", I think I'm allowed to say that I've tried a lot of liners. This is my favorite out of all of them :)
Black goes on grey,smudges, bad purchase..
Shelly from Chicago
Waste of money .
This is my new Fave liquid eyeliner!
Blue Eyes Etched in Ur Mind from Dallas, TX
The precision felt tip on this Maybelline Line Stiletto liquid eyeliner works GREAT! I highly recommend this product, especially if you want an eyeliner that easily allows you to define your eyes in fine thin lines. Easy yo use, fast application, and great color are other pluses for this eyeliner!!
It is the best I have found at a terrific and affordable price! I LOVE IT. I have been using this eyeliner for nearly a year, and I still love it as much as I did with my first application!
Works great stays on all day.
Jenn from Las Vegas
Love it bought it several times.. Last all day
Rae from Yucaipa
the applicator could be better but it's a good eyeliner
Best liner ever
Atu17 from Marshall, Michigan
I've been trying to find something that compares to this liner and I just can't ! Even NYX tattoo liner is amazing but doesn't compare to this liner! The price point is there and so is the quality please don't ever stop selling this!