Rated 4.01 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I liked it!
I received this product free for review. I have loved NYX products in the past for their low costs and high quality. Upon opening the box, I noticed how small the bottle was. Now, I realize that it is very narrow to accommodate the thin applicator, but the amount of product still seemed a bit low. I think it will run out sooner than some of my other liquid lipsticks, which isn't a huge issue, but something still worth mentioning.
I absolutely loved the idea behind this product. Applying my lipstick has never been so easy, and with such great results! I've never been great at it, so the fact that I was able to make my lipstick look amazing is saying something. The color I received is GORGEOUS, easily my favorite color I have. I got "Feelin Fine" and I totally recommend that color; it's bold but very elegant. I'm planning on wearing it to a formal banquet.
Okay, now let's talk about the formula. Though I was thoroughly impressed with the applicator and color, the formula was a little less impressive. I did not have problems with it drying too fast as other reviewers have said, but I do agree with many others that it does not stay. It feels very nice on your lips and it also seems to be dry, but after an hour or so, the color already seems to fade a little from the middle of my lips. It's not horrible by any means but it would have been nice to have the product last a bit longer than that. There is some smearing as well, but you can't expect a lipstick to not smear at all. Unlike some reviewers, I did not have major troubles with taking the lipstick off. It does seem to cling a bit more, but after some scrubbing with my Neutrogena makeup remover wipes, it was gone.
In summary, I did like this product. I might be willing to fork over $8 to buy another once this one runs out. It does have its flaws, and if you look for longevity above all in a lipstick, this product is not for you. If you love the ease of application, I definitely recommend.
Most Helpful Critical Review STUNNING color, but so so patchy and impossible to remove!
I got this in "I Got Issues" after swatching a tester on my wrist in store. I have fair skin, dark brown hair, and green eyes so I tend to gravitate towards purples a lot - especially a good plum lip. So while this product definitely "has issues", I'd like to start off with the positives: this is a HIGHLY pigmented product, and this shade was quite possibly my favorite lip shade of all time. I was incredibly excited to go home and actually try it on my lips. Absolutely stunning, and my initial impressions were great. However, upon leaving the store, I noticed that (even though it appeared dry and had been swatched 20+ minutes ago) my swatch had started to smear...everywhere!!! Up and down my arm, my hands, my clothes. I opened up the makeup remover wipes I had bought in the car, and tried to take it off and it just smeared a lighter stain all over me. At this point I was a bit concerned but it was just. So. Pretty. :/
I got home and put it on my lips. The applicator was weird and I struggled just a little to get a totally perfect edge, but I think it could definitely be managed with practice. However it dries down really really fast which leads to an INSANELY patchy finish. I got it a bit better with two coats and a bit of touching up, but I wouldn't consider my final result presentable. And, even after looking dry and matte for 15-20 minutes it still was super easy to smear/transfer.
TLDR: this shade is absolutely hecking gorgeous, but this formula was a hot mess with pretty much no redeeming qualities. Super disappointed. I'll be returning it. It might be better in a more forgiving nude/lighter shade, but I just don't think it's worth the hassle tbh.
Reviewed by 591 customers Pleasantly Surprised
VJG from Palmyra, PA
Matt color that stays out and feels like nothing on your lips. Great product at a great price. Will buy again. True red too.
VJG from Hershey PA
So impressed. I love that it applies so easily, dries matte and stays in place for hours. Going to purchase in more colors.
BargainHuntress from Panorama City, CA
I love lipsticks that have the liner attached to it. The concept of the applicator as a liner also is great! It works just as good as a separate liner. The color is also strongly pigmented and for a bright pink, which I usually stay away from cuz I'm brown skinned Asian ack, this one looks amazing on me! Every color tends to darken on my lips after application so it was a perfect bold pink on me. It also isn't drying on lips which is a major plus.
Rubyymusic from Everett
I actually love this all in one lippie! It's super convenient and they last a really long time! I'm on my 4th one🔥🔥
Well I like it !
Tricia from Chicago
I like the color I got Never listen and to its the perfect nude color you do a lipliner or not now it could be a little drying but that Ok I still love it .
Favorite NYX Color
Brmcknny from Memphis, TN
I love this color. Doesn't look like the same
Color against my skin, but I still love it. Even though it dries matte, it goes on smoothly. My only con is the tube is so small I wish I could get more!
Goldi from Indy
It stays on.
Not what I expected
Maché from Chicago
When I first got this I was excited because I am always looking for new lip products. I saw the nude shade and thought "Wow that color would look cute with a bold eye and some gloss on top". I was wrong. Normally, NYX has some of my staple lip products for performances or looks, but this not only applied splotchy, it stained my lip line this weird yellow toned brown color and it looked like I was sick. The same can be said with the red and the pink, they stained horribly.
Long lasting great coverage
Anne from Miami
I have purchased almost all the colors it's just a great formula
Victoria from Indianapolis, IN
I got this in Feelin Fine. The color is beautiful, and it lasts a long time.
I love this product
halfbloodprincess43 from San Antonio, Tx
Very easy to apply. Looks good with any makeup type.
halestorm from Bethlehem Pa
this was a total flop product for me, from formula to the construction of the applicator. i found it difficult to work with, with barely a pay off
nyfinest006 from ny
I bought these on a try out and im in love i bought more colors
Mireya A from Sparta, WI
Love the color and the texture. It's not difficult to apply and it stays on for a long time. It doesn't feel sticky or dry, but it does have somewhat of a chemical/bitter taste to it though, otherwise I would have given it a 5 star rating.
Love the color!
Mireya A from Wisconsin
I love NYX, especially their lip line and this lippie did not disappoint. It's long lasting, it feels nice on my lips and not dry. The only thing I would "complain" about is the taste. I happened to lick my lips and it has like a bitter "chemical" taste to it. I don't love it, but I can live with it. Other than that, great product and color.
Great wear but needs a moist topcoat
jlynn from mn
I recieved this item as a free gift and honestly forgot about it. After finding a Clinique chubby stick for lips I loved the color of but not the short wear time I remembered the tube I recieved. I decided to pair the two. I line and load first (which I agree with other reviews is VERY DRY) and I top with my chubby stick. The two together are a match made in heaven. All day wear and tons of compliments
Mama Bear from San Diego, CA
I think this product just is not for me. Don't have the extra time that it takes to get it on evenly. Had to keep going over areas to achieve an even absorption of pigment. Had to use a separate lip brush to line and balance out the uneven areas.
I would buy this product again and again!
The tester from San Jose, CA
This is a very useful long lasting lip product that I highly recommend.
It will leave everyone on RED!
Danni from Shreveport, La
I was looking for a great red lippie on the run. I wanted a true red without hues of orange and not too much of a pink undertone. I came across this beauty 😍. Biker Babe, where you can use the applicator as a liner. The applicator is precise to line your lip without having to do some major clean up. I went back and bought another one when I should've bought out the shelf. The only con I have is that they don't give you enough to last if you wear it a lot of times or just because you love it sooo much.
Long wearing great color no smudging
Anne from Miami
Great for dinner or drinks doesn't run 🏃
Better than the 'name' brands!
CasBlessed from Wichita, KS
This works exactly as described. The thin tip allows for precise lining of the lips and the side of the wand provides easy coverage for the rest of the lips. I put on my makeup at 6am and I don't need to touch up until after lunch. This stays on through several cups of coffee, breakfast, and morning conference calls!
Love the quick set to Fri matte
Moi from Cali
Love you can use to line and fill. Wish there were more color options
The perfect red
Jill from Oklahoma
I'm still getting used to using it as a liner, but the color is so intense and gorgeous! It really is the perfect red. The applicator is great and precise as well
Gonzalez from El Paso, TX
Okay so I will explain. I know for this brand the lipsticks tend to be dry which is easily fixed with some chapstick before application but this one I couldn't get my lips to feel not dry. I also ate and it got very very clumpy which is normal for most lipsticks but it was too much clump that it got into my food and I'm pretty sure I ate it. I loved the color and the easy application. Honestly it is a good lipstick I just hated the dry feeling.
Love the color
Lipstick Trace from Birmingham Alabama
I purchased the color Never Listen. I was searching for a nude lip color abs of course a lip liner to match. So I shopped on line and bought a few different ones and hated all of them. Went into the store and saw this one and I only applied it once and it last the whole night. I ate and I didn't have to reapply it.