Product Reviews Rated 3.24 out of 5 stars
139 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review my usage I don't know if this will help anyone, but I used this product on top of another mascara that would basically just separate my eye lashes apart then I applied elf product on top of it, and it would always come out wonderfully giving my lashes lots of volume & length. Hope that of any help.
Most Helpful Critical Review Barely shows up I hate to write a bad review as I am a big fan of elf products but this was just awful. It adds no volume whatsoever. It hardly lengthens my lashes. The only difference I can see before and after is that it darkens my lashes, but lengthwise and volume wise it is completely unnoticable. If you want an extremely natural look so people will think you aren't wearing any mascara, then this is the mascara for you. If you want to make a big flashy statement, not at all.
Reviewed by 139 customers Small Brush But Okay Formula 4
HannahC from undisclosed
Was very excited to try this after hearing some good reviews. Found the brush is a little small which can make first-time application a little difficult, but you soon to get used to it. The formula is okay and leaves lashes looking nice. Could be buildable but a little spidery if too much is applied.
Not good 1
Nichole27 from undisclosed
I was very hopeful for this mascara to work as I love their other products. This mascara does not add length and volume, it apples very light, and it didn't hold my curl so I had to recurl my lashes after they dried. Only positive is that it does dry fast like it says. Very disappointed.
I love this!!!!!! 5
Kylie25 from undisclosed
This was the first mascara I ever bought and I have stuck with it. I love how it makes my eyelashes look. It makes my eyelashes look 10 times longer which I absolutely love. It really has helped my eyelashes grow to. I would definitely recommend this product!
God awful 1
Allie from DC
This is easily the worst mascara I have ever tried, I needed something last minute before an interview so grabbed this. I have naturally pretty long and thick eyelashes so mascara just enhance that. Somehow this mascara made my eyelashes look short and nubby! When I tried to build it up the wand kept getting stuck in my lashes and did nothing. Once it tried it felt like there was absolutely nothing on my lashes. But the worst part of all is how hard it was to remove! I used my most heavy duty cleansing balm and it barely removed it. I had to like pick it off each eyelash and then it wouldn't rinse from my skin. The morning after wearing it my eyes were gunky too. Just truly terrible!
Easy to use, great value! 5
Meg24801 from undisclosed
Love this mascara. I've tried a zillion mascaras and I think I've finally found my go-to. Provides great volume and pretty good length without requiring 1,000 coats. Great for quick application as you're headed out the door. Stays on well, no clumping or shedding, easy to remove. Super affordable. Certified cruelty free which is a wonderful bonus!
I just used this for... 3
qfryd from undisclosed
I just used this for the first time today. The brush was kind of small which made application a bit difficult but overall the mascara was ok.
my lashes have never looked this good 4
Kylie from Naples, FL
the mascara is amazing and it makes my lashes look longer and perkier than they are (they like to stick straight out). however the brush is bulky so i definitely end up with some mascara on my eyelid.
I would but this product again 5
Kassie from Newnan ga
Makes your eyelashes look very full
Just meh 2
Imcastrose from New Jersey
It not horrible but it just doesn't wowed me is but it cost my lashes black nice but I don't like the application. So meh is all.
good for a cheap brand 4
evvvv1 from undisclosed
this mascara is great for such a cheap price! it's sometimes slightly clumpy but mostly has been great in making my lashes look longer!
Great Volume, a Little Clumpy 3
AllyMoore from Nashville, TN
I bought this for my travel bag for when I don't have my full makeup kit. The formula is nice and lengthening, but it take a bit for the formula to dry. Also, the formula gets clumpy because the brush picks up so much product. I scrape most of it off before I apply it to my lashes. Easily buildable.
Great for sensitive eyes 4
ktie20 from undisclosed
This product is great for anyone who's eyes can get easily irritated by mascara. Does not irritate my eyes at all and I barely feel like it is there (ie not heavy at all)
Waste of money 1
Beauty from Old Bridge
Product had to be applied for a good 2 minutes to show up on lashes.not good at all
Good 4
Lindsay84 from Homestead, FL
I think the reason people are giving this mascara not so great reviews is because they're used to mascaras that clump their lashes together, giving the appearance of volume. Is this mascara the best? No. However, it's good. Especially for the price. If you know how to apply it the right way(starting from the outside and working your way to your inner corner, placing the brush at the base of the lash and rolling it upwards), this mascara does exactly what's advertised. It gave me length and NATURAL volume. Not tarantula lashes, which is not a cute look on anybody. I feel like the formula could be improved as it does start to flake off, but it does last for quite some time before it starts doing that. All in all, it is a good mascara!
Did not like 1
KC Burder from TX
I like the small brush, but it's like my lashes can't get between the brushes or something. Hardly any product gets deposited on my lashes even after multiple applications. I usually like everything Elf puts out but I will not be purchasing this again.
I will definitely buy this again 5
Tara from Hopkinsville, KY
This product saved me $30! I have to buy vegan products because of an allergy and they are expensive but not this one and it works great! Just as good as the $30+ ones!!!
I have long and very... 3
Lauren901 from Memphis, TN
I have long and very straight eyelashes. I bought this mascara not really knowing what kind of mascara I should be buying. Overall, I think its a good mascara but its not for me. I have learned by trying many differen mascaras that to old a curl I need to use a waterproof mascara. This mascara is not waterproof and the brush is smaller than I prefer but it works ok if you are not in need of a mascara that holds a curl. It coats lashes evenly and does not clump.
Great coverage and long lasting! 5
Worldpeace32 from Florida
I read the reviews on this mascara before I bought it because I was so skeptical about the price. Not only did it apply smoothly but it really made my eye color stand out. I was pleasantly supprised that it kept up with my
hectic day of wearing it out!
Clumpy 2
R from Usa
Kinda Clumpy, and hard to take off
Awesome and Affordable 4
Cassidy from Florida
I needed a new mascara as mine had expired and decided to check out E.L.F. since I love their products (great for someone on a budget). I picked this one for the smaller applicator and was very satisfied with it. It doesn't clump up and goes on easily. However, it isn't anything extreme. Definitely not for someone who is looking for a crazy lengthening mascara, but for someone who wants just a little extra to their lashes, its perfect.
Not bad! 4
Laur from NJ
Bought this to get free shipping, and honestly happy I did! Not really voluminous but definitely lengthening!!
Not it 2
Butter pecan roll from USA
Clunky mascara. It's soooo hard to tke off too
poor quality 1
Champion420 from Elk Lake
just received my mascara in the mail, it's very clumpy and fluffy looking, doesnt really show at all... was very disappointed.
Worst mascara I've used 1
Cc88 from undisclosed
I bought this as my mascara was running out and I have other elf products that I've loved! This was the worst mascara I've used ever. Barely even puts any product onto the lashes not even with multiple coats. I wouldn't recommend or purchase this again, as it's just as dry as my one that's ran out.
I wanted to like it 1
LeeLeeGagan from Rhode island
I love elf products and really wanted to like it but it was dried out. I added eye drops to it and it just darkened my lashes a bit, nothing else. I also ordered the waterproof one but I don't have high hopes.
