Rated 3.81 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great stuff, lasts all day in most cases!
I've been using this eye liner for years now -- 'Noir' on the upper lids & 'Cafe' for the lower lids -- and can honestly say this stuff is one of the best liners I've tried. The point is not hard at all, rather it has more of a creamy texture so therefore it's easy to apply. Also it never needs sharpening, is waterproof and lasts all day in most cases. The only challenge is it tends to smudge off when worn to the gym (especially the upper lids, but only when I have a hard workout & sweat a lot) however, I must also add that on hot summer days it serves its purpose well & stays in place. Lasty, one Le Stylo pen usually lasts me 5-6 months so it's a great value for the price, too. Just love this stuff & would definitely recommend it!
Most Helpful Critical Review Disappointed
I am extremely displeased with both the pigmentation and texture of this product. I have used Le Crayon Kohl for many years and am quite pleased with that product. I purchased the Prune as i desired a plum shade. Please add a Navy and a Plum shade to the Le Crayon Kohl line to satisfy customers who prefer this product. I have watched the color selection diminish in favor of the waterproof and it is very disappointing. I am exchanging for the Moss as an alternative, but still desire the other shades I have requested. I can't be the only customer with this complaint. The blue shade now offered in Lapis is far too green in pigment when a Navy is desired.
Reviewed by 860 customers Disappointed, not waterproof,
Eliza from Denver
claims are false
I simply love it!!!
Emma from Las Vegas Nv.
It makes brown eyes brighter!
Can't do without!
Bubbe Bubbles from Voorhees, NJ
Everyday eyelid lining - upper & lower!
Grandma6 from Utica ny
I usually love this product
However the first time I used it the tip broke off and there is no product left i
Sophia from WI
First time using the eyeliner I bought it because I loved the color. Is it waterproof yes, did it last yes, I'm not overly impressed and it was pricey
Jjar from Columbus, MS
I really love this eyeliner. My first time trying the turquoise. It brings out my green eyes and I've had compliments from friends and family. Will try other colors
Awesome for allergy eyes!
Jocoro from Alabama
I love this liner!! I have allergies so have a hard time finding liner that I can wear and ones that will stay on due to watering eyes. We will see if it holds up to the summer heat and humidity. This checks both boxes. You do not have to apply several layers to get a good line- it is there the first swipe. If you are going to smudge don't wait too long or it is set and hard to do. At first I was upset- it seemed like others were correct and there was no more product when you tried to advance the tip. It was there just super slow coming out. I would hate to name all the pencils I have- the list includes both high end and drug store brands. This has quickly bubbled to the top. I highly recommend!!
Sandra R from Jacksonville Florida
I'll start by saying it isn't a 'bad' liner. However, it is NOT waterproof and didn't last any longer than much cheaper drug store brands.
I love Lancome products. Their teint foundation is gorgeous. But this eyeliner is not worth the pricetag. It has rich black pigment. And applies smoothly. But it does not last. I've set it with black eyeshadow. I've tried several eye primers. I've tried setting sprays before and after application. And many other tricks to make liner last longer. And don't even bother trying to get it to stay put in the waterline.
I have a wide variety of high end and drug store makeup. I don't mind paying more for a really good product. But my focus is on performance. Not packaging or name brands.
This liner didn't perform as well as I thought it should.
Wish I knew how this product was.
Lulu76 from Massachusetts
I keep getting asked to review this product, which I purchased almost a month ago, and haven't been sent yet. Based on my chat transcript my order was supposed to be processed yesterday, but it wasn't. I have been a loyal Lancome user for almost 30 years, a tradition passed down to me from my beloved aunt and it really breaks my heart that I might have to find a different brand. The last few years of service from Lancome have been disappointing, but this past month really takes the cake.
Coco from Nor cal
It mechanically malfunctions And the tip of the pencil is stuck.
love lancome products
Juju from Florida
this is a great eyeliner ,doesn't smear or smudge ! stays on all day !
I love these eye liners
Cristy725 from Maryland
I love these waterproof eye liners. I have used them for years.
My favorite liner!
JudyL from Rochester NY
I love the coverage. This is my favorite liner. I need it in more colors!
Good waterproof eyeliner!
alemaniababe from Belmont, CA
The Bronze Riche color has a nice coppery shimmer effect. Stays on most of the day but tends to run in the eye creases after 4-6 hours of wear. Not retractable so I just push up enough product for the current use. Pricey but the best I've found out there so far.
RedOH from Ohio
I tried this because I wanted it for vacation so it did not run, well vacation was not great but this liner is my new go to!!! It is great goes on nice and stays well.
What has changed
VIRGIE1 from Saltillo, MS
This product has changed. It used to last all day and and looked fresh. It looks flaky and dull. What and why has this product changed.
It is what it says, just not enough🤗
Just Denda from Durango
I've used this for 3 years, it's awesome, don't get me wrong, but it's expensive to use every day. Other Lancôme eyeliners are great for everyday. I love this for vacations, long flights, beach days and 20 hour work days!
My favorite eyeliner
Melina from Trenton, Michigan
This eyeliner goes on so smooth you can also use a small angle brush to get a sharp wing look. Never have to sharpen, great colors
DoodleMom from Fort Collins,CO
Now that I have discovered this eyeliner, it's the only one I use. Love it.
This product is a reliable staple in my make routine.
Chief from wa
I use this product daily
Best eyeliner I ever used
Adro from Florida
I am a n the auto ship but would like to put it on hold for now. I have called and held on for 1 1/2 hours only to be disconnected. Please help
Lolly85 from Dallas tx
This is a great product. It glides on nicely and stays on all day
Best eye pencil!
Mab10 from Houston
I have blue/gray/green blah eyes and I love the Prune color! No other brand has it- perfect for me!
This is my favorite eyeliner!
Sarah from Mesquite, TX
Love this eyeliner! It's long lasting and doesn't smear.
Love the Waterproof Eyeliner!
MoJoanna from Dallas TX
The Lancôme Waterproof eyeliner pencils are the Bomb! For someone with allergies, you can't ask for better! Love them and highly recommend. And to find they come in so many colors! Yes!