Product Reviews Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars
20 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review One of my new favorites I've only used this twice so far, but I am loving the length and volume I get. One coat is fine for a more natural and separated lashes look. You can add more coats easily for a more glam look. It starts clumping a little bit when adding coats -- which I don't mind, and I like the look. It doesn't flake, stays put all day, and washes off easily with an oil or balm cleanser. The texture/formula reminds me of It Cosmetics Superhero mascara -- there is a lot of product when you first open it, so I scrape off the excess back into the tube before using.
Most Helpful Critical Review A lot of fall out! When I originally purchased this, I received a defected one that was clumpy and impossible to use. I was sent another one, free of charge and I am so disappointed. The brush itself is great but there is SO MUCH fall out. Literally, as soon as you put a coat on, you know there is going to be fall out. After 2 hours of wearing the mascara, I am ready to take it off. It is all under my eyes it's awful!
Reviewed by 20 customers The best! 5
Natalie from Washington
This makes my lashes look super long and with great volume. I bought 2 right after I tried it just to have it! So good. The only problem is that it smears underneath my eyes so I started using a different mascara for my bottom lashes, problem solved.
Wow! 5
Jess from Fresno, CA
This mascara is amazing seriously! You don't even have to keep applying it. Just one time and you get a lot of volume/length you name it. It's my new gift for my friends. I get the mascara and their lip balm or something else and put it together. You really cant go wrong. Everyone I know that tries it, loves it.
Wow!!! 5
Tam-Tam from South Dakota
Wow! This stuff is amazing. I am very picky about my mascara and this mascara makes your lashes so very long that they look fake. It is not clumpy and easy to remove at the end of the day. This mascara is worth every penny!
The Best!!! 5
Bubbles from LA
I LOVE this mascara. I've tried so many different mascaras and so far this does all three things best that I want my mascara to do and they are to give volume, lengthen, and not flake. My lashes look like I have fake ones on when I use this. It's amazing! Definitely recommend!
At first AMAZING & then... 3
Makeup junkie from New York
First few weeks my lashes are Amazing, long and thick. Like ridiculous!! And then The mascara gets very thick and old looking very fast, a little too fast. The mascara starts to flake upon wear. Looks clumpy. Very difficult to remove. For the cost this should last longer ..
A lot of fall out! 1
Eva from Ventura, CA
When I originally purchased this, I received a defected one that was clumpy and impossible to use. I was sent another one, free of charge and I am so disappointed. The brush itself is great but there is SO MUCH fall out. Literally, as soon as you put a coat on, you know there is going to be fall out. After 2 hours of wearing the mascara, I am ready to take it off. It is all under my eyes it's awful!
The Best Mascara so far 5
StacyB from PA
I'm always trying new and old mascara's. This one so far is the best. Works great with Grande Cosmetics Primer.Which i have to wait for the primer to dry alittle and than apply the Elcie, cause of clumping. It makes my lashes long. I went into Ulta one day and the Sale Lady asked what do i use.I told her.She like how my lashes were full, long and define.I was still trying other mascara's (new one that come out) and i keep coming back to this one.It is a wet formula but not to bad like a few others i have tried.
Too much product on brush 2
DR from Chicago
The first time I used it I loved it but then the stopper didn't work and there is way too much product on the brush. I have to wipe the excess product off wasting so much to avoid super clumpy mascara.
Best mascara yet ! 5
Monica from Oregon
I have tried SO many mascaras.. I usually have very short and sparse lashes.. with this my lashes look long and full! It's incredible! A friend asked me if my lashes were real the other day 😍 thanks Elcie cosmetics!
update 3
jdlf from Aurora, IL
loved the mascara but the brush keeps flattening down have to wash it get it back to normal
A huge favorite! 4
B.B. from Sacramento
I love this mascara so much, I think it doesn't provide as much volume as it claims (and I have pretty full lashes on my own) BUT I still think it is worth the money. I'm not someone who likes to wear falsies, so this gives that effect without any of the hassle.
Flakey and clumpy 1
Karen from Minnesota
Reading the reviews, I had very high hopes for this mascara! The stopper does not effectively remove mascara as you pull it out of the tube, so there is a massive amount on the brush, resulting in lots of clumps. A few hours later I had flakes everywhere under my eyes. Very disappointed, lots of inexpensive mascaras perform drastically better than this expensive mess!
So Disappointed! 1
Eve from Oxnard, CA
This mascara (at least the one I got) clumps so much! Can't even wear it because of all the clumps. Attempted to use it a few times by removing all the clumpy mascara but did not work. Was excited to use it and love it but by far the worst mascara I've bought! Maybe I received a defected one? Will have to throw out regardless :/
great full lashes 5
jdlf from Aurora ILLINOIS
love how this lift my lashes. give nice volume and length
One of my new favorites 5
Rachel from OR
I've only used this twice so far, but I am loving the length and volume I get. One coat is fine for a more natural and separated lashes look. You can add more coats easily for a more glam look. It starts clumping a little bit when adding coats -- which I don't mind, and I like the look. It doesn't flake, stays put all day, and washes off easily with an oil or balm cleanser. The texture/formula reminds me of It Cosmetics Superhero mascara -- there is a lot of product when you first open it, so I scrape off the excess back into the tube before using.
Amazing mascara 5
Jen from Ohio
Someone asked me today if my lashes were fake with this on! Best compliment ever! This mascara lengthens like crazy AND adds volume (and my lashes are blonde). I love it!!
Best mascara if you have thick lashes 5
Mrsgmakeup from Napa
I've been using this mascara since it first launched at Elcie.com. This mascara is no joke. I do think it's best for thick lashes. It gives you a full effect without looking clumpy. It never flakes and it's jet black. The brush is amazing.
Best Mascara ever!!!! 5
Susie from Santa María
My favorite mascara of all time.
😍😍😍 5
Anuta from Wisconsin
Best mascara I have ever used. My lashes look so full and long. Love it.
LOVE! 5
Sir from CA
I LOVE this mascara, ever since I bought it I can't stop using it. It really give you the FULL eyelashes and does make it a little length, the color is a good black and the formula is amazing I love how easy it comes off at night because I won't have to rub my eye so hard. It's a great product!
