Rated 3.62 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The best mascara I have ever used
First of all, I will confess I am a make up junkie. I would hate to know how much money I have spent on mascara. I have tried Dior, Lancome, Clinique, Estee Lauder, and the list goes on and on. I have straight eyelashes that are impossible to keep curled, so I have to use a waterproof mascara. This mascara is awesome people, no joke, not exaggerating. This is hands down the BEST mascara I have ever used. It is drier since it is waterproof, but not too dry. The brush picks up just enough product so it coats but doesn't clump. The mascara is a true black color. The brush coats my lashes to the very tips of my lashes, it works fantastic on my bottom lashes as well. My eyelashes stay curled all day, I don't need to reapply it at all. It stays on in the shower, it stays put until I use the blue Neutrogena make up remover wipes (the best for removing waterproof makeup without pulling out your lashes). I am so happy my search for the perfect mascara is over, I recommend everyone try it, you will not be disappointed!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Buyer Beware
I'm not super into makeup, so I was ignorant to the fact that "wateproof" mascara is not an exaggeration. When they say "waterproof," they mean that stuff isn't coming off for DAYS! I tried to use micellar water, but that didn't help either. It's a really great mascara if you know what you're getting ahead of time. But since I was surprised by it, it left a sour taste in my mouth. I will probably still use it for formal events or if I'm going out on the town. But I probably won't buy it again. I did, however, buy the regular one and it would have been great if the brush wasn't twisted.
Reviewed by 45 customers I love this product
Nikki from New York
I'm honestly surprised to see the negative comments for this product. This is my go-to mascara. I personally prefer waterproof over the original one. I don't notice any clumping or flakiness. It makes my lashes look long and thicker! I personally recommend this product!
Long lasting but flakes
Lisa from Lansing MI
I had high hopes for this mascara as I normally use the Lash Sensational Luscious. Figured I'd try something new and the brush looked nice. Well, the formula is just not very good. Within an hour I had flakes beneath my eyes. (And I purchased the waterproof!) I did enjoy the shape of the brush, made it easy to get all my lashes and lift them too. The formula did last, however the flaking was a deal breaker for me.
Ariel from Lynnwood
Dark formula, which I like. The comb holds a lot of product which gets deposited into my lashes and gets clumpy. That's what I don't like about it. I have to scrape the product off but it still gets clumpy. I like the curvitude much better.
Been using this for years
Deb from CA
I have tried other mascaras but keep coming back to Maybelline waterproof. Good value.
A hard no
ati3 from Austin, TX
I was hoping that this would be an affordable substitute for Benefit's roller lash, but it wasn't. I didn't even put very much on and it made my eyelashes into a clumpy mess. I sort of got them combed out with a brush so they looked decent enough for me to go to work. Then it took SO long to get it off at the end of the day. Don't waste your money.
Renee from Simi Valley, CA
Absolutely not for me. This was my Plan B when my usual Waterproof Lash Sensational was out of stock at my Ulta. First time trying, it started flaking on my face after a couple of hours. Gave it another 2-3 chances and same issue.
best bottom lash mascara
me from tx
The shape of this wand makes it incredibly easy to coat the bottom lashes. I also love that it separates my top lashes making it look like my lashes are thicker.
Beat my holy grail mascara!
Jgray from Virginia
I was not I love with this mascara at first. It flakes the first couple times and was just alright. But after a week I absolutely fell in love with it! It has beaten my holy grail Loreal Lash Paradise! Volumizes, lengthens, and holds a curl on my straight as can be lashes! I will definitely be buying again.
great for straight, hard to stay curled lashes
Ariel from Seattle, WA
My sister recommended this mascara to me after I complained about not being able to find a mascara that didn't make my lashes fall back to flat after curling and applying. She spoke very highly of it and I was convinced. This formula is light enough to keep my lashes from falling! The brush is small, perfect for hooded eyes like mine. I always seem to get mascara on my lids. The bristle length is different on one side versus the other, making it easy to apply to the bottom lashes with the shorter bristles. Stays on all day, waterproof formula kind of hard to remove, I use 2 different removers/cleansers now.
How do you not like this?
Biki from San Diego
I'm so confused by the negative reviews. I'm SHOOK! I have very straight and stubborn lashes. I curl my lashes and throw this on and it holds my curl literally all day! I do have to work with it and use a lash comb so that they aren't clumpy but it looks so great! I get the comments on being difficult to take off. I always double cleanse my face by using an oil first to remove eye makeup and the mascara comes right off. I don't mind the extra steps to ensure I have perfect eyelashes. I really don't. Y'all missing out.
Definitely loved except...
Cris from Rialto, CA
I bought this product and used it for a few weeks and was impressed with the effect it had on my lashes. I loved the brush, the application and the wear, but after 3 weeks, the brush literally broke off during use. I had never had this happen before and considering I don't smack my brushes around, I was a bit confused. I bought it again to see if it was a fluke because I loved the wear on it, so far, no issues.
My new favorite mascara!
Alli from CA
I love that this mascara lengthens each lash without clumping! I have naturally long lashes, but they are not very thick. I often struggle finding a mascara that highlights my length and adds a good amount of volume without clumping. This mascara worked wonders.
great for reaching every lash
Jules from San Diego, CA
one swipe with this brush & you reach every lash. i found this formula to be buildable & it didnt flake on me through the day. waterproof & smudge proof, definitely gonna repurchase when i need to
Makes a difference
Win from Snellville,Ga
First time to use product .Realy like
SL from MD
This is mascara is very nice for my straight lashes. Building up volume is so easy with the brush. I find it easy to avoid clump buy applying mascara at different angles using the brish.
The best of all, it's waterproof. I went to a water park with this on, and my face got soaked. I was very unhappy abt my makeup. But when I saw myself in the mirror, my mascara didn't even move. Highly recommend this product.
Returned after 1 use
Deavin from Los Angeles, CA
Stick to the original Lash Sensation. The curvitude version did not give me the volume like the original and it keeps the curl just as well as the original; not better.
Good, but not my favorite
FarmGirl from Gilbert
Good mascara. But this would not be my "go-to".
Great Product! Good Price Point!!
Allie from Gulfport, MS
Really good product! I buy this product all the time and I regularly use it. It does go on thick so it is slightly harder to remove, but it's overall a great mascara!
Mascara lover from Oregon
I wasn't sure about this one at first. Typically WP (waterproof) mascara is very difficult to remove, and this comes off relatively easy using an eye makeup remover. The wand is fantastic for my lashes because of its concave and convex shape, so it is quite versatile. In the photo I curled both if my lashes and applied mascara to only one and as you can see there is a definite difference in length. It finishes as a more natural and whispy look.
I love this mascara!
Maggie Mccraney from Hattiesburg, Mississippi
I love it! It makes me look like I ACTUALLY have eyelashes! There is only one mascara that i loved more than this one, but it was stolen and I did NOT want to pay $30-50 for another one. This maraca is a just as good as Better Than Sex, L'oréal, or any other high in makeup mascaras.
geminibabe from Oregon
This is pretty good mascara. I like the brush and I do feel like it makes my eyelashes look curly and long. I got the waterproof formula and it hasn't run or smudged at all. The only real negative for me is it is kind of clumpy. I have to use another brush to separate my lashes after I use it. I also wouldn't say it's volumizing, mostly just lengthening.
HOLY GRAIL FOR STRAIGHT LASHES!
Anahi Hernandez from Ca
I'm so confused why ppl didn't like this mascara whatttt. I absolutely found my holy grail mascara after searching for so long. I've tried so many from high end to drugstore! And wow just wow I'm VERY impressed with how this mascara actually holds the curl to my super straight lashes. This is defenitely better than benefit's roller lash in my opinion that one didn't hold curl as it claimed. Well least said if your looking for a mascara that gives you length, separates and holds a curl get this I reccomend it!!!!
Ms Renee from Las Vegas, Nevada
Mascara junkie from NC
Goes on thick and sticky, takes a while and a lot of lash separating to get this to look good enough to leave the house
A from Texas
More on the clumpy and sticky side but does what it says. It's voluminous and makes you lashes long.