Rated 3.83 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I love this mascara!
I bought this last week and used it for the first time yesterday. I absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE this mascara! It gives my lashes length and just the right amount of volume. I haven't had any problems with the brush, so I'm not sure what all the other reviews are about... I will definitely be buying this again
Most Helpful Critical Review Y'all what is going on?
The earliest complaint about a defective wand was 8 months ago, and it's still weird now. What happened?? I've only had this mascara for a week and it's bonkers, the wand is at practically a 90 degree angle and impossible to brush conveniently with. In fact, it actually bent and contorted right as I pulled the wand out of the container during my second use. So mangled!!
Reviewed by 775 customers Wow
Kait from TX
The waterproof one keeps my curl and gets every lash. Never stabbed my eye either. My favorite out of all. Never had a problem with the wand bending or whatever the other reviews say. Looks like I have falsies without being clumpy. THE BEST!
One of the few drug store brand products I continue to buy
Miranda from Ohio
I am NOT naturally blessed in the lash department, but I have been using this for years and I've had coworkers compliment and ask what kind of mascara I use. I have tried MANY mascaras from different brands- Lancôme, Clinique, Esteé Lauder, Two Faced, etc. and none work for me as well, and I love how affordable it is! In my experience, it makes my lashes really long, full, lasts all day, and doesn't flake. I have recommended it to all my friends.
Great formula terrible brush
lolee from hayward,ca
Live the formula and the size of the brush. But ergonomically the brush is awful and way too flimsy. It is so flimsy it oddly shapes once you pull it out of the tube and is impossible to get it to angle right onto ones eyelashes. I tried.
DO NOT BUY
Mnadamoose from Hollywood, FL
The first day I opened and used the product was fine. The next day after the wand stayed inside the tube for a while, when I pulled it out the end of the wand with with bristles was completed malformed and unusable.(see pictures) It is clear that the wand doesn't fit in the tube properly and has to bend and unfortunately does not return to normal shape after being in the tube for a while. I'm not sure how this product passed Quality Inspection but it needs to be removed from store shelves.
anner from mckinney, tx
i've used a few different may el line mascaras, and i decided to give this one a try. it goes on very easily and looks great after the first coat. really makes my lashes look longer, spreads them out for more volume, and lasts pretty much all day. the only setback is that it's a bit hard to wash off, but can come off with coconut oil.
Like the way it looks,yet
Green apple from undisclosed
This product is very hard to wash off when it is clearly not the waterproof kind I have lost a few eyelashes so far trying to wash off :(
Meggo from Charlotte, NC
Makes for spider lashes. Looks awful and doesnt apply well. Decent for lower lashes but dries out quickly while applying.
Tayler from Grand Rapids, mi
The applicator bends after being in the tube and made it unusable. When I was using it the mascara smudged so easily. I don't recommend, I'll be switching back to my regular maybelline mascara!
Well this sucks
Kbeauty from Stroudsburg
Does not distribute product well and smudged under my eyes later on in the day! I'm so disappointed because lash sensational is my go to, but this was sooo disappointing
Tina from Pittsburgh
I love the brush and formula. It grabs every hair and really does fan your lashes out like the pic on the packaging. I'm so glad I decided to try this and will continue to use it!!! I didn't even need to curl my lashes!!!
Amylynn1969 from undisclosed
I love lash sensational but have super straight lashes so was excited to try this. I did my Right eye, perfection! Then put the wand in and it came out
Completely bent, unusable!!! What a
can't live without
Lisa1 from undisclosed
it's the best at curling and lifting my lashes and voluminzing them at the same time! i use this everytime i put on masacar and it rarely smudges even in hot summer days! will always purchase this one from maybelline!
I hate this mascara
Blanch from Houston Texas
Use it only when I am not in a hurry, the brush is flimsy and doesn't disperse well at all
Wand bent immediately
Ssm247 from New York
Wand bent from putting into tune for the first time! And I was extra careful!
Brush is awful
Sockrgirl84 from undisclosed
The brush is so flimsy that it gets completely deformed after putting it in the bottle. No matter what I do, the brush isnt sturdy enough to push through the makeup, and always comes out totally useless....
SEM23 from Reading, PA
I was really excited for this product since my eyelashes have zero volume and curl on their own. The wand is too curled and difficult to use. I have also been really careful putting the wand back in, but it has only curled more since my first use. It was a waste of money for me.
A FAVORITE FOR YEARS
Rainie from Medford Oregon
I have tried so many mascaras (high end and drugstore) and I come back to this one every time I love it so much and I always get so many compliments on my eyelashes when I wear this. I have used it for probably 3 years and never have I not love it. Although I do like it best when it's about a week or two old. This mascara is right up there with man eater from tart and my It cosmetics volumizer mascara.
Try this first!
Just my thoughts from Michigan
Have been searching for good mascara for about a year. Got a sample kit with a bunch to try last Xmas season and also kept buying trial sizes to find one that I could apply easily and wouldn't rub off during work or at chiropractor appts. Bonus if it didn't bother my contacts! Got a bonus sample kit with a recent order with this in it and found what I was after. Love that the full size product cost for this was less than the trial size cost for most of the others. Was also pleasantly surprised to see there are both regular and waterproof versions available.
acont1187 from Katy
The formula is pretty terrible... it's hard to build up without your lashes clumping up together. I've tried using it in various ways (one side of the wand vs both) and it just never seems to apply well. I'm not too picky with mascaras since my eyelashes are already curly and long. Wouldn't recommend!
Bent wand and clumpy
Jen05 from undisclosed
The wand is flimsy and started to bend the first time I used it, no matter how carefully I tried to put it in the tube. The 90* angle makes it near impossible to use, and the mascara goes on clumpy. Very disappointed in this product.
Aeiou from USA
It works well, but it doesn't build up or stay on my lashes very long
Natalee from Iowa
Only mascara that works for me! I have downwards lashes and this is the only one that gives lift!!
Mrs. T from NJ
I gave 1 star because I assume it's a decent formula from Maybelline. Who knows. The wand was overly bent. Basically an impossible design. Many said the same thing, that the want bent awkwardly in the tube. I already threw out my receipt and so eventually I just through it out after 2 tries.
Maybeline from Belton
Worst mascara , the wand curves so easily and messes up , doesn't even apply the mascara,
would not recommend at all
I would literally give 0 stars if I could
Carol from Santa Barbara
Literally worst mascara ever, the first time I put the wand into the mascara it bent horribly, the brush is so weak it can barely apply the mascara. The mascara is clumpy and flakey as it applies, and no one should ever buy it.