Rated 3.8 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I will just let the picture speak
This is a beautiful mascara. The picture speaks a thousand words, so they say so, I attached one for you all to see the before and after. It did not smudge on me, although I use a setting spray so maybe that helps a bit, also it did dry up a bit after a couple months of use, however adding one to five drops (depending on how dry it got on you) of an eye drop or contact lense solution, (anything suitable for the eyes that is saline solution-esque) going one drop at a time for desires "runniness"will bring that baby right back to life!! However I only noticed a slight thickening after months which, honestly you should toss eye products fairly regularly anyways.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not dominating anything
I love most Bare Minerals products except this mascara! I had to buy it because I was desperate for mascara while shopping and my Ulta never stocks the other Bare Minerals I use. Desperation is not the way to shop though; this was a bad pick all the way around. It's so hard to get off at night. It's very gooey and sticky going on. My eyelashes are clumped together and it leaves big clumps on the tips of my lashes. I can't use the wand properly because the mascara itself is so sticky and thick it won't run thru my lashes. I never write reviews, but after applying this product for the last time this morning I thought I'd let people know. The only thing the product is dominating is clumpy, stuck together eyelashes that do not look pretty!
Reviewed by 626 customers I wouldn't buy this product again.
Jade from Williamsport PA
I personally wouldn't purchase this again because it doesn't make my eyelashes long I feel like it doesn't work much. Formula is not clumpy nor flakes though!
Absolutely love 😍
BridgieCakes from Essex, MD
My absolutely favorite mascara. Love how it makes my lashes look 👀. Definitely recommend this product
gossip girl from upper east side
This mascara was always at the bottom of my makeup bag, I received it as a gift. I decided to give it a shot and let me tell you, YES. I've used all the recommended mascaras, better than sex, rollerlash, telescopic, milk kush, you name it. I've never used a mascara that volumizes, separates, lengthens and lifts until THIS ONE. I use a curler and then i put this on, its buildable to your desire, the formula is quite wet (in a good way). I'll admit it does flake a bit under your eyes after a long day, but what mascara doesn't? This mascara is so underrated, give it a try.
Lisa from Omaha
I wasn't sure what to expect with this mascara. I certainly was not impressed at all. I have full short lashes and was hoping to elongate my lashes and thicken a little bit. after two coats my lashes weren't any longer and they didn't look any thicker either. I cannot say that I would recommend this brand. Not impressed!
Nyla G. from USA
This mascara makes my lashes full, long, and curly. While it isn't clumpy, it doesn't separate the lashes a lot. Overall I would recommend though.
Love this mascara - been buying for at least 5 yrs.
pj from AZ
It's great. Love the comb applicator as it spreads the lashes and makes them appear longer. The mascara doesn't flake or run.
Love Love It
TC from Rio Rancho, NM
Love this mascara! Doesn't go on globy. Separates, lengthens and thickens my eyelashes. Was a bit worried when the formula was changed from the original I used to buy. Love this one more!
jmarz from rhode island
great application, good brush, and long lasting product. comparable to better than sex
Obsessed & have been for years
San from Kansas City
This is my favorite mascara hands down. I have been using it for years and haven't found anything better than this. I have naturally long eyelashes and this mascara gives the perfect amount of volume. I frequently get asked if I am wearing falsies!
I've bought this mascara 5 or 6 times. Very pleased.
kat from Mobile, AL
Doesn't clump or smear
Wish It Were Waterproof
Aime from Austin, TX
Got this in a sampler kit. Love the way it volumizes and separates my lashes initially when it goes on, however because it is not waterproof, it doesn't tend to help my lashes hold a curl after a few hours & especially in high humidity areas. PLEASE MAKE THIS PRODUCT AVAILABLE IN A WATERPROOF OPTION!
Doesn't work for sensitive eyes
Shanna from Portland
I bought this mascara because it was a healthier option and had a good rating on EWG. Unfortunately, I wouldn't buy it again and plan on returning it because of how my eyes reacted to the product. It was good for about one day of wearing, but by day 2 (and especially when I took it off at night) my eyes became extremely itchy. I have sensitive eyes, so this may be a unique experience for me and others like me. It makes me sad, because I liked the formula—it does a good job of thickening and lengthening the lashes. The wand is more of a silicon style, so some may not be into that either! If it weren't for the allergic reaction, I would keep wearing it.
Only mascara I use
Red from VA
This is the only mascara I use. I really like the applicator brush. It goes on easily and stays put.
Best Mascara for Thin, Short Lashes
Laura from MN
As I age my lashes become less dense. Combined with the fact that they are light, without mascara I have no lashes. This is the best mascara I have found regardless of price. It lasts a long time. It does not clump on my lashes.
JLynn from LANSING, MI
By the looks of the brush I thought I would like this product. It doesn't give my lashes much volume at all and doesn't separate them very well either. I've noticed that it does leave the smudge-y transfer on my under eye not even halfway through the day as well.
It's not awful, just not for me.
lisa from San antonio
I'm a big mascara person and this mascara does nothing for me. def wouldnt buy again
My lashes are falling out
A.M from Virginia
I use this every day despite the fact I don't really like it that much. First time I used it it looked great but then my lashes started to fall out and there is now a gap in my eyelashes. It also smells very strong like rubber kind of.
I love LOVE this mascara. The best I've ever found!
Melissa from Sacramento,CA
This is the best mascara I have ever tried.
I would buy it again, I'd just do it in the physical store.
LoLo from Macomb MI
I think I must have gotten an old batch or something because it's really dry when applying.
did not like it, Lashtopia is much better
scrapylu from Reno, Nevada
its takes a lot of swipes to make it look like you have it on
Caradeethatsme from St. Louis MO
Great water resistant formula. Does not leave a haze under my eyes, run when I cry or get sweaty. No flakes. Great volume and definition. Easy removal. I personally use coconut oil or face wash in the shower. Highly recommend!!
I didn't care for
Love makeup from Hb ca
Nope didn't like. I have good lashes and i felt like they looked shorter
My search for the perfect mascara is over!
Tracer from Ohio
A great mascara can transform a look. This is the first one I have used that does everything I am looking for. I typically never buy the same mascara twice. I have even bought two different types to mix and match to achieve the look that this does.
Love this mascara!
Marlena from Hanford, Ca
I do use a eyelash primer before I put on this but even days that I don't I'm still very please with how my eyelashes look! Not clumpy & spaced out nicely!
I would not recommend or buy again.
Mandi from Atlanta, GA
I am honestly annoyed that I spent this amount of money on such a low quality product. This mascara ran down my eyes in a matter of a couple of hours of sitting at my desk for work. The wand is way over sized in my opinion and hard to even put on your smaller and bottom lashes. Don't spend your money on this if you're looking for a new mascara.