Rated 4.06 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The best!!
Glides on easily. Doesn't smudge or disappear throughout the day. You don't have to hold the pen pointed down in order for the ink to flow out. Even if you hold it upright it still flows out easily. The tip makes it very easy to make a thick or a thin line. It washes off easily at the end of the day without leaving any residue which is weird since it DOESNT BUDGE ALL DAY LONG! I want MORE COLORS!! Bare Minerals please make these in dark brown, plum, and navy!! I would buy them all :-)
Most Helpful Critical Review Worst eyeliner to remove...EVER!!
The eyeliner is not bad, it is just that it is super difficult to remove. I mean I practically look like I've been punched after rubbing it off at the end of the day. I can appreciate an eyeliner that stays on through the day, but when the cleanser from the same company can't remove their own eyeliner, I am moving on. Ridiculous.
Reviewed by 252 customers If this is ever discontinued I will RIOT
Veronica from The Valley
I love the feel and weight of this bad boy, I've been using it for a month as a fill in for my favorite eye liner set by Michelle Phan.
This eyeliner is my everyday hero. LOVE IT.
Kel2 from undisclosed
I loved this product until it started leaking. I would open it to find a blob of ink, which made a mess, several times. I returned my original purchase for a new one & the same thing happened.
Brush is a bit worn out and dries up
glasskinuwu from San Jose, CA
The eyeliner was mostly great and easy to apply, but sometimes the brush would wear out and make the application process difficult. Also the packaging especially the cap makes it hard to close and sometimes I would come back to use my eyeliner to see that it's open. I didn't get to use all of it since my eyeliner dried up because of that.
Great product, but faulty packaging
Mariaen97 from Kansas City, Ks
I have bought this eyeliner multiple times and it always ends up seeping out of one of the seams at the top of the marker near the tip. My most recent purchase I started using less than a month ago and is already running dry, even though I do not use it daily. I love the the actual product, as it normally goes on easily and lasts perfectly the whole day, no matter the weather. I just wish that the packaging would be fixed.
Best eyeliner I've ever used!
Rayray75 from Fresno
I absolutely love this eyeliner... I was a bit skeptical to start using a new product since my dept store started running out of my usual brand/color. This one glides on so easily and it's WATERPROOF! Definitely staying with this particular one
Haley93 from Alaska
I'm very picky when it comes to eyeliner and have tried so many different ones over the last 10+years. This one is amazing! It lasts all day, is easy to apply, doesn't smudge, and makes for a clean line across your eye. Highly recommend!
No ink inside
Mascaraluv from Dallas
I wear almost entirely bare minerals makeup. I bought a few of these eye liners and when I got to the last one there was no ink inside. Will not be buying again.
I would buy again
Ris from Chicago
Although this product was difficult to apply because of the felt tip. I applied this with a wing top liner and got caught in the pouring rain for about an hour. When I looked in the mirror the entire line was not only still there but a perfect wing!
Hannahrj from undisclosed
The only reason I'm giving a 4 star, is whenever I put this in my makeup bag, the lid pops open and then it drys out. I love this eyeliner and it's the best I've ever had, but it's hard to justify a price when it happens 2/3 times i put it in my bag.
Would not buy again
Christine from Michigan
I've bought this product twice now, and each time it ends up leaking/producing too much liquid, resulting in me getting it on my eyelashes and fingers. Sometimes it works just fine and other times it starts leaking randomly. This has happened both times I've purchased it.
Stays on and doesn't smudge or smear!
Lex from Greeley Co
I've never been able to find a good waterproof liquid eyeliner. This one outshines all the many I have ever used. My eyes are naturally watery most of the time so finding this eyeliner has been great! It comes off just fine with my regular makeup remover face wipes. I use Neutrogena.
I would buy again
Sharon from Woodhaven mi
Awesome oil free liner
Not for me
LA_Veronica from LA
The pigment isn't there. I had to go over the same spot multiple times and it still didn't look black enough. I wouldn't get it again.
It leaks and it is messy / the tip loses shape
MJMM from Washington, DC
I like it because it is waterproof, but there are two problems I have found with this, and I have bought it several times every now and then because I think it has potential hope it will be improved, but it hasn't. First, the tip does not keep its shape. After a while of being used, it is more difficult to slide through and it dries out because it leaks on top. It is really messy, and if it leaks into your eye, you will have black liquid floating in your eye until you have to remove your makeup and wash your eyes. It is even worse if you are wearing contact lenses because you pretty much have to throw them away if you cannot remove the stain out of them once it leaks inside, plus is kind of gross and not so hygienic to put your lens back after they have been stained with all that ink.
My new favorite!
LAB628 from Arkansas
I got this eyeliner for FREE in a kit I got when I bought my foundation. Its AMAZING! It's easily my new favorite eyeliner and I will definately purchase it in the future.
Cobra from Boise
I bought this eyeliner about a month ago and I really like the fine lines it creates to give me the expressive effects I desire! I would buy this again!
Kirsten133 from Tacoma, WA
I bought this product a few months ago in the store. I was super excited for a waterproof eyeliner. However, when I tried it at home, the brush was super dry. I thought it was because it was new and the ink hadn't reached the tip. But I was wrong! Everytime I tried to use this, it went on super light. If I tried and go over it, the brush just wiped the ink away. Super bummed that I wasted my time and money on something that just ended up in the trash.
I'm not allergic BUT it needs imrpovement
AKD007 from Michigan
I've found I am VERY allergic to most eye products (including some bare minerals products). However, I can use this without my eyes puffing up and having any kind of reaction. My biggest problem with this is that is does not go on opaque - when you draw a line it is dark in some places and basically clear in others. Once it dries, I've had major problems with it flaking off and getting little black specks on my cheeks and sometimes in my eyes (ouch!). While its great I don't have a reaction, every time I've tried to use this I've had to put a different product over the top of it anyway to get the right cat eye look I'm going for, which defeats the purpose of using this product at all. I really wanted to love this product and have been VERY disappointed with the performance especially given how much I paid for this. I would return it if I could. I'm not sure I would even try another eyeliner product from BareMinerals given my disappointment with this one.
Leaking! terrible, i thought i'll get blind
NEMIA from San Diego CA
It works fine the fine few days of use. Recently, it has been leaking. The first time it leaked, I just let the fluid flow until it drops then wipe the brush a little bit with a tissue. The 2nd time it leaked (just this morning), the liner got into my eye, i was so scared, it would damage my pupils. Had to wash it out with eye drops several times to get the liner out of my eye. For now my eye is ok, hopefully, It wont have a side effect.
Louie 1 from Warrenton Virginia
I used it on my face for a Halloween cat costume. It was easy to use to create great cat whiskers and a nose! It washed off in a flash!!
AZ42 from AZ
I love this eye liner......It is easy to apply and does stay on.
best liquid eye liner!
Pink49 from Council Bluffs
I have purchased this in the past & loved it but thought I could find something cheaper in a store that would work as well, not true. I am back to this & I love it. stays on great!
Liner dried out after one use
Kayla from USA
I really wanted to like this liner but I used it once and it's completely dry. Maybe I got an older one or a defective one but seeing a few other reviews it looks like I'm not the only one. A very close comparison for half the cost of the physicians formula eye booster 2 in 1 liner. Same felt tip almost same packaging and it does not dry out, I was looking for something more intense than the PF product but it still works very well.
Gigi64 from South Carolina
I love this eye liner! Easy to apply and looks great!!!
great pen, for precise lines...when it can be used
Bigbarb from Massachusettts
I bough this about a year ago. Loved it, until I went to use one day and it was leaking all over the places splattering ink. For the price I paid I expected a better quality item. What a waste of money!!!