Rated 3.86 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great for layering and feels wonderful!
Okay so the trick with this I think is to let it dry between coats and then it works beautifully. It layers so well and I get so many comments with this mascara. I do have problems with literally every mascara that isn't waterproof giving me dark rings under my eyes by the end of the day, but it wasn't as bad as a lot of other mascaras I have tried. But if you let it dry between coats, wow the volume is amazing it is so nice to work with and my lashes are SOFT when I wear this. (If you don't let it dry I find that it sort of wipes it off back onto the wand). Lashes feel so great when I wear this
Most Helpful Critical Review Not What I Had Hoped
This mascara was disappointing on several levels. It did not add any length to my lashes and it took 2-3 coats to see any noticeable volume, but even then it was minimal. It also did not curl my lashes as may be inferred by the name of this product. The brush has short, sharp bristles that scratched/poked my skin several times during the application. About 20 minutes after I applied it, my eyes began to water badly and they felt like they had sand in them. Very uncomfortable. I've never had any type of reaction to PF products or their mascara so this was a surprise. I returned it for a refund. On performance alone I do not recommend this mascara.
Reviewed by 43 customers Long lashes? YES MA'AM!
Kay from None of your business
I got this in a small size from a gift set I bought and absolutely fell in love with it! It makes my lashes super long and it lasts all day long. Way better than other high-end mascaras I've tried in the past.
Discontinued in store but ordered off your websit!
Traci from Goldsboro, MD
Love this mascara! I'm so happy to see it can still be ordered on line. Physicians Formula is the best mascara for my lashes. My lashes are a little sparse and this mascara thickens them up beautifully. Very affordable great product definitely going to be reordering from their website!!
Non from Florida
LOVE this product. Hopefully it's not discontinued
Not worth the price
Leena from undisclosed
I really wanted to love this based on all of the reviews but it fell short of my expectations. The heavy formula took all of the natural curl out of my lashes. Even using an eyelash curler did not help for they fell after a few seconds of putting the mascara on. I had to recurl after applying. And after less than two weeks the plastic top of the tube snapped, oozing mascara all down the tube. This is definitely not worth the price and I won't be buying again.
Rose from Nashville any
Doesn't take much and it makes my lashes look like falsies hard core ! People think I have eyelash extensions!
Rose from Nashville Tn
Feels very high end. No smudging and the brush is very nice I feel like it applies a good amount of product all over the lashes in 2 coats of course let it dry for a sec and apply the second layer but you can build this up very quickly to look like falsies ! Love love love this ! Try it you won't regret it!
I don't think I would buy this product again
VetteS from Dallas,Tx
It was my first time trying this product. I read the reviews and they had good reviews so I decide to try it. I was super excited to try it and it was not was I expected. I have long eyelashes and I love to have them longer without wearing fake eyelashes. I like when people put a picture of their eyelashes to show other girl if this product works.
My drugstore Go-To
Tejiendita from Texas
I'm a huge fan of the Benefit Rollerlash & this mascara is pretty close! Not super watery & not clumpy. My eyelashes are pretty average & they look like spiders after I put this on
Brooke from Undisclosed
It's okay, definitely not a fan of it. The bristles are sharp and are uncomfortable if you get them close to your lash line. The formula is dry, it lenthens but does nothing to volumize.
Gabs26 from United States
I have naturally long lashes, but this mascara makes it look like I have falsies on in the best possible way!! It gives amazing volume AND length. I can wear it natural or build it up to intense length and volume
Ar from San jose
Use most days
Chris from Winnipeg, MB, Canada
I did not receive this mascara! For some reason, I received my order and this mascara wasn't included.
Ash from Reno, NV
It delivers a more natural look while still delivering volume, length, and lifting the lashes.
Fluttery, voluminous lashes!
CaraM80 from NYC
This mascara was included as a free gift in a recent Physicians Formula order and I love it! It definitely has a drier formula, which I prefer, and gives separated, fluttery lashes with lots of volume and no clumps. It's not waterproof but didn't smudge under my eyes. It does give a bit of length but as I have naturally long lashes, I'm more impressed with the volume. If you hate clumpy, spidery, wet, heavy lashes, definitely check this out!!
Underrated amazing mascara!!!
Lady Regulus from Ohio
I absolutely love this mascara! I grabbed it because I wanted to try something with better ingredients. It's honestly a great dupe for better than sex which is what I switched from. Love the price and the performance!!!
Brush broke off inside tube
sam from arlington, Wa
Brush broke off inside tube after second use, never had this happen before
Good, but not as expected.
kycoffeequeen from KY
The formula isn't bad. I'd say pretty average. I love that it's a more natural product as compared to most mascaras on the market, though, it doesn't seem to have any kind of curling effect for me. I would repurchase this product but I would not do so under any kind of impression that it would affect the curl of my lashes.
Carol from Largo, FL
Terrible, dry mascara. Wanted a hypoallergenic line but not this one.
Best mascara in the world!!!
Claire from Chapel Hill NC
I use the mascara everyday and it makes my lashes so curled up and voluminous!!! I don't ever want to be without it!!! The ingredients are do good for your lashes too, helps them to grow and be nourished and strong!!! Also, there's no aluminum, thank goodness, and it doesn't irritate my very sensitive eyes!!!
Lauren h from Fort Myers, Fl
great dupe for the roller lash by benifit
A new fave of mine
Leanne from Lafayette, LA
I've been wearing this mascara for about 2 weeks now and I have been LOVING IT. My new go-to and I haven't found an AMAZING mascara in YEARS. I highly recommend this.
duvf63 from Montreal
My favorite, honestly the best thing I have in my purse !! ❤️
Meg from Maryland
I use a lot of cosmetics from Physicians Formula so I was disturbed to find out this mascara contains PTFE, which is Teflon. I threw it away when I found out and wanted to warn others.
One of the best mascaras! 💘
Maddie from Home lmao
This mascaras make my not so long or thick eyelashes so think and long! You can even see them from a pretty far distance. I will definitely buy again 100% 💋💄
Recommend for sensitivities
Bre from Pennsylvania
Great lengthening, not very thickening. It looks very natural. I bought hypoallergenic because others make my eyelashes fall out 😳 This has been great with no irritation