Product Reviews Rated 2.09 out of 5 stars
394 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Blue Mascara I love this blue mascara. It absolutely adds a subtle pop to the eyes. Be warned, darker lashes will make the product appear less blue. This is not a 1980s neon mascara, even though that's what it looks like. It is hard to remove (the package says "removes easily with soap and water") but came off in very warm water and a washcloth. This product does not add very much volume but does lengthen. It stays all day and doesn't flake or run even when crying.
Most Helpful Critical Review No no no I was so excited to try this out. I'm more of a cover girl clump crusher and I thought I would expand.... Uhhh so mad at myself. It didn't apply evenly at all. My lashes were so clumped
together and spidery leg like. Horribleness all around.
Reviewed by 394 customers Good mascara, not so good brush 4
Mafer from Guayaquil, Ecuador
Overall I think is a very good mascara considering the price, it gave me volume and length to my eyelashes and didn't get and clumps, I do recommend to remove the excess of mascara from the brush before applying so you don't get the clumps or thickness. However I do think the brush is not good. The shape is really awkward and hard to deal with it. But I would buy it again
Too thick and clumpy 1
Crystal from Cocoa Beach, FL
I was really excited about this mascara, but as soon as I opened it I knew it wasn't going to work well. It's so thick and clumpy and looks awful on. Smells really bad also. Waste of money.
Never again 1
Luhhndynn from Utah
• Horrible product
• So clumpy
• Way too thick
• Gets everywhere
• Immediate waste of money
• Do not buy this
It does the job... 3
Bree from Nashville Tennessee
I bought this mainly cause i'm a huge Katy Perry fan and i'm sad to say i'm disappointed I understand it was marketing's and she didn't use it but i wanted to try it. It's a great product and I would buy again IF the brush was different it's hard to apply because the brush just clumps all of the mascara to it so when you apply it's just a wad of mascara on your eyelashes.
What the clump 1
Bmcarn from Georgia
Clumps. Wand is weird. Smears so bad. I could go onnnn and on! Don't waste your time nor money.
The worst mascara ever 1
Ng from NC
The worst mascara I've ever used. Don't waste your money
Absolutely the best!! 5
Sunnysue from Florence, KY
This is probably the best mascara I've ever used. I first tried it about a year ago and have used nothing else since I found it. My only fear is that one day I won't be able to find it at the store!!
can't get it off !! 2
Taylour from ny
i have literally tried everything to get this mascara off...i have used, makeup remover, wipes, baby oil everything. it jusy will not come off
Defective Brush? 1
Defective Product from Wisconsin
This mascara seems impossible to apply. I'm not sure if I have a defective brush but there is no way to even put this mascara on without clumping. I've tried cleaning the brush and the mascara still just clumps to the brush. I'm very disappointed and unhappy with this product.
Worst mascara ever! 1
Regi from Cleveland oh
It is absolutely the worst mascara ever. It has this huge brush that makes a blob of mascara that leaves massive clumps. It has the consistency of clay and looks awful! I so wish I bought this at Ulta so I could return it!
pretty bad 2
laura from Massachusetts
this is a pretty bad mascara and it's pretty clumpy. the only pro is that it lengthens well
Love the BLUE 5
Jjsbaby8 from Morristown, Tn
I have purchased this mascara in the blue several times! It makes my lashes so full and gives them lots of volume! I just love it!
Awful 1
KitKat229 from Anderson, Indiana
I bought this mascara a last week and seriously the worst mascara I have ever had. I'm not sure I'd it's the wand or the mascara itself but its impossible to put on without ending up with globs everywhere. As soon as you pull out the wand you can tell it's not going to work. Don't even bother.
Possibly The Worst Mascara Ever 1
CakerBaker from Upper Midwest
This is by far the worst mascara in both formula and design of the wand. The twisted barber pole design makes application almost impossible to get an even coat or without massive clumps of mascara. Had I known about the spiral bristles I would not have purchased this. The formula is a thick, gloppy mess with a texture similar to pudding and comes out heavily caked on the wand. Even twirling the wand during application doesn't help. How did this mascara make it through product testing before being released to stores??
It's so beautiful 5
phiecut from San Jose , CA
I bought it today and I'm so happy with the quality of this product.
Not good! 1
Sylk781 from Michigan
This has to be the absolute worst mascara I've ever tried!! The brush comes out with so much product between the bristles and wiping it against the sides doesn't help much because you still end up with too much on your lashes. It adds no length nor volume just clumping looking lashes and it isn't even a dark enough black...almost grayish in color. Total fail
It's Horrible! 1
Nik18 from Washington
We all know Katy Perry doesn't even wear this garbage! I've ended up being stuck with many tubes of "No Clump" mascara in my lifetime, but none have even come close to the globs that come out on the wand of this stuff! An eyelash comb with pointed metal spikes doesn't even plow through this sludge! I tried! The best use I found for this brand new tube of mascara is as garbage can filler. Thanks Covergirl!
I don't want to even give 1 star. 1
KellyisMad from West Jefferson, NC
This is the WORST mascara I have ever bought and I'm not picky at all about my mascaras. The wand is HORRIBLE, it goes on SUPER clumpy, it dries hard and crusty, and I can't get it off to save my life. DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY. Really was just hoping that if a celeb was incorporated with it that it would be good but I was VERY disappointed.
Worst 1
Katherine1965 from Tx
Not sure if the brush is horrible or the product itself is, maybe both.
Awful! 1
Lisa from Geneva oh
The worst mascara I've over used in my entire life. I've tried my fair share of mascara over the years pretty much trying a different brand everytime I'm out and this is by far the worst. Brush was horrible, mascara was clumpy save your time and money and don't ever purchase this item.
Worst Mascara I've ever come across 1
LSassano from Rhode Island
I bought this mascara in a set, it cake with a lipstick and a perfume. I ran out of my favorite mascara and figured I'd give this a try. BIG MISYAKE. The consistency is way too runny, and takes forever to dry. Makes lashes look clumpy and spider like. Will never buy again.
Allergic reaction? 1
RebeccaFay from Pequot Lakes, MN
I actually really liked what this mascara did with my lashes and used it for a couple weeks almost every day. At first I thought I had just gotten a sunburn under my eyes, so I quit using any mascara until it cleared up. Then the first day I started using this again after buying a new tube, it came back. I don't know what ingredient is in here that irritated my eyes so badly, but I've never had this happen before with any mascara! Now I'm scared of it happening again with other brands :-/
GREAT for very fine lashes 4
Ali Barron from Southeast US
A lot of you are commenting about this mascara going on in clumps which you don't like. Here's another perspective: it's true that it goes on in giant globs BUT if you have very fine eyelashes like I do, it's hard to get mascara to get on lashes at all. Here's the solution, put the mascara on, globs and all, then use an eyelash comb. You'll get great volume and length when the comb evens out the globs. It washes off well. It took me a while to figure out (even though I've always used an eyelash comb). Also, I use the blue and since blue mascara is very hard to find that actually gets on my baby fine lashes, I value this product.
Don't even want to give it a 1 rating 1
NoWayJose from undisclosed
I bought it and all I did was pull the mascara wand out of the tube and the wand was broken with the brush part still in the tube! I didn't even get a chance to try the mascara! What a waste of money.
CLUMPS 1
cchprescott from prescott,az
First time buyer ( and last) I have never used CoverGirl mascara before as I see they make Katy Kat. Worst mascara ever. New tube opened it and it is clumpy and looks old. Applies in globs....................NEVER again. Threw it out
