Rated 2.65 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Awesome Product
I can't believe that the description of this product is totally accurate!! It is bright and bold, lasts all day long, looks like it was just applied and I've been to the gym today. You have got to try it!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Terrible Product
Had to return this eyeliner. It is so hard and harsh. Does not glide, pulled and never put any eyeliner on my eye. I thought I had left on a cap or something so I tried it on my hand. Still dragged and had to apply vast amounts of pressure.
Reviewed by 300 customers Empty?
Bethany from Lancaster, pa
I just bought this eyeliner and it is empty! Or maybe broken?
Waste of money
Kam from Cincinnati
it's supposed to be a gel liner but it applies, looks, and feels like a regular liner.
spfairie from South Jersey
I have been using it for over a year now. I work in a hot, sweaty, dirty warehouse on 10.5 hour shifts. It lasts the entire shift. I never have to re-apply although it does smudge if I get really sweaty and I have to wait about a half hour after moisturizer for it to glide on smoothly.
High end quality for low end price
Karen from Niagara falls, ny
This went on and stayed on just as well as the high end eyeliners that ive used.
The eyeliner doesn't work
Vikki286 from Florida
Doesn't work at all!!!!!!!!!! What more do I have to say!! Tried even using on paper!!! Nothing
Used to love it.. now irritates my eyes
Mimi from NJ
I've been reading more people having same issues. I used this pencil for over 5 years. But for the past 6 months I started to realize my eyes were always getting irritated... I then associated it with the eye liner and I am pretty sure it is the cause. I could still love it if it was not for the new formula...
Eleanore from Henderson, NV
Second purchase of this product as I was very pleased with it. It goes on smoothly, doesn't smudge and is long lasting. I especially like the soft tip. Better than liners for 2 or 3 times the price. Very good product at great value.
Leaves my eyes stinging
Rebecca802 from undisclosed
I've used this eyeliner in the past and never had a problem with it, however within half an hour of applying it today my eyes were red, watering and stinging so bad I rushed to remove it. Hours later my eyes still sting. So disappointed!
This actually stays put!
Heather G from Vicksburg Ms
I had given up wearing eyeliner because I always has racoon eyes within an hour but this really does set and not budge.
Aimster from Leeds AL
Precise eye liner
Couldn't even get it to come out
Trissidaae from San antonio
Opened wrapping, twisted the top and nothing. It just clicks and no eyeliner tip comes out
Makes my eyes water.
Beth33 from undisclosed
I have been using this product for a while and all of a sudden it has started to irritate my eyes. I will have to find a different product and my money is wasted.
Susan from IL
I am an eyeliner junkie. I have replaced all my expensive department store eyeliners with this one. It is easy to apply to both upper and lower lids and it does not run. The point stays sharp enough to draw a thin line. I am surprised at what a good product it is.
Babbetz from Minmesota
I can't get anything from the ink it liner in my lid. Color does not transfer at all. Very dry not smooth it gliding.
I love Ulta from Phoenix, AZ
Love this product...
mlaw84 from ND
Ink It! Charcoal is by far my favorite eye liner of all time. I am scooping it up wherever I can locally because it seems to be discontinued. I am devastated! Please bring back CHARCOAL!!!! :)
This pencil is a joke.
orchick from Oregon
It came out of the tube and I can't retract it. Then part of it broke off so I threw it away. What a bummer, I can't even see how lame it is on my eyes. It was a nice purple color but I can't even try it.
Marie from El Paso, TX
For the price, this is the best eyeliner I have found. It's great and does not smudge.
Works only for 1 day
cdon from undisclosed
I bought this last week and it worked for one use and then immediately dried out. After that it basically was useless.
PLEASE BRING BACK the ORIGINAL Ink It!!!!
Robin24 from Coral Springs, Florida
Just tried the new GEL formula Ink It, and it smeared off in 2 seconds!!!! SOOOO DISAPPOINTED!!!!! Your ORIGINAL formula was the BEST, and bought it everywhere I saw it, but I ran out and can't find it any more ....
PLEASE BRING IT BACK!!!! This NEW version is HORRIBLE!!!!!
Used to love
Kay92 from Caribou, Maine
I have very sensitive eyes and used to love this product. However the last few times I've gotten this pencil it's been dry. It breaks and crumbles. Also my eyes hurt like it's scratching them!
Prefer original formula
Beauti from undisclosed
New formula clumps under eyes once applied and makes my eyes water
Change in formula?
JennB from Fort Lauderdale, FL
I've been a long-time user of covergirl and love the accuracy with your eyeliner options. Used to be a big fan of ink it! But the last 3-4 times it's been horrible. The pens seem to be dried out and it's very hard to apply. The tip is constantly breaking off. It's not cheap - and I barely get to use half of it because it's constantly breaking. Did you guys change something with the recipe? Switching to another eyeliner until product is improved
New Version Disappointing
saheenay from Paducah, ky
I've been wearing this eye liner for YEARS! The new version has a different tip and I can't apply it as thinly as I like. It used to have the same tip as the perfect point plus. I've tried the perfect point plus but it smears terribly so I'm constantly looking in the mirror to wipe away the smeared eye liner. As soon as I found out there was a new version of the ink it I went around town buying up every older version I could find. My stock is gone!!!! Now I'm desperately searching for a new eyeliner. Please bring back the old version!!!!!
Where Has It Been All My Life?
Sha from NY
I have finally found an eyeliner that doesn't run in my waterline! Love this!