Rated 3.64 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Ridiculously good
I love a few colors from the regular line of these lipsticks, one of them (angora) is my most worn lipstick of all time and my go to dependable long wear lip color... so when I found out about these, I was extremely excited. Safe to say, these go above and beyond my expectations. The scent is like brownie batter and chocolate pudding, the formula is fantastic and the colors are gorgeous. Best part? The longevity. I swatched this on the back of my hand. 4 hours later, hadn't budged. Took a shower. Still bulletproof. This would probably last through the apocalypse still looking freshly applied. Doesn't even come off easily with oily makeup wipes, had to use an oil balm, an oily scrub and prayer to remove this entirely. It does have a stick to it for the first half hour or so, but it goes away while the color stays entirely intact.
Most Helpful Critical Review Worst liquid lip ever!
The color looked totally different than it did on the model so I was upset when I thought I was getting a nice nude and ended up with a concealer color. After about 3 minutes my lips felt sticky and uncomfortable.I tried taking it off and it would NOT budge. I also didn't care for the wand. The only good thing about the product was the smell but that wasn't enough for me so I quickly returned it.
Reviewed by 177 customers I love Box O Chocolates 🍫
Puliswifey from East San Diego, CA
This product is a total experience. Scented like the most decadent chocolate cake(or brownie), you're going to think about your favorite dessert during every application. What I like most about this product is the wear time, it lasts hours and is perfect for a long day. However, removal is a huge challenge so if you're not about that, beware. The texture is sticky and thick at first but dries down. Box O Chocolates is my favorite shade from the collection, especially for fall and winter.
I love this product
P from Altamonte Springs Fl
Great for wearing under mask
I will never buy this again. It is nasty and sticky.
Rachel Rabbit from Sherman, TX
The only good thing about this product is the smell. It is so sticky and thick on my lips, it all cakes up in certain places. I will never recommend this product.
Jenna from New York
Every single color of these pulls way different from what it looks like in the tube. Bittersweet looks GRAY. In fact, a lot of them look gray. Don't waste your money here, go get a colourpop lipstick. These look absolutely awful and cakey.
couldve been good
nova from ?
The formula felt comfortable until it dried down or I guess lack there of. Its sticky and it doesn't stop being sticky. If it wasn't for that problem I would love this product!
Texture like glue
HoopSkirt from USA
Nothing like the original Infallible lipsticks. This one is so sticky after it dries. Uncomfortable and it settles into lines on lips. Biggest lipstick fail this year.
Box o chocolate
Ashley from Michigan
Horrible. Color looks like dried clay, looks caked on after one swipe across lips. Honestly this would be good for a Halloween costume is you're trying to look dead 😳
Yes these are my favorite lipsticks.
Anne the Lipstick girl. from FL
I love these lipsticks. They're usually the only thing I buy.
Love this tone!!!!
Hope from Los Angeles ca
I am obsessed with this particular tone. I get great compliments on the shade. I just love this lipstick.
MrsG from Really
I love these, they smell amazing and have they have great staying power, lasts all day even after eating and drinking, have repurchased a few times
Nice and cheap
Saralizg from St. Louis
I really like this lipstick. It smells amazing and lasts all day.
Carolyn from Chicago
Box o chocolate is the perfect sexy natural brown I've yet to find! once it dries down it does not budge, one night I didn't wash my makeup off after a night of drinking and this lipstick was still perfect in the morning. I agree that some of the other shades were weird and too light, but box o chocolate is perfect for my light skintone, I've already repurchased twice now.
Kaylee from Ohio
Loved the color I bought, candy man but it seemed like it never dried down and was sticky.
Smells like a box's of chocolate
Kim from Decatur, GA
I am pleased and it really does smell like chocolate
Smells like a box's of chocolate
Kim from Decatur, GA
I am somewhat pleased the only thing that I was disappointed was the color other than that I like it
Best for a Nude Lip
JannetteBee from Houston, TX
I finally found a perfect nude combo for my skin tone and it's this L'Oreal Matte Lipstick in the color 'Sweet Tooth' and the NYX Lip Liner in color 'Brown'. Overall it's easy to apply but it is a quick dry formula so you have to work fast with it. It was super long lasting like it claims it is. Only con is that it does set a little tacky (easily fixed it you powder a bit with a setting powder).
love the smell, color is strange and very thick formula
Nanyxo__ from Bayonne, NJ
this lippie is so yummy. I love the way it smells. that being said I am a huge chocolate lover so they had me at CHOCOLATE. everything else however... the formula on this is kind of thick. it is a very thick consistency so I don't know how many people enjoy that. also it takes a while to fully set being that you have to apply so much just to get decent color pay off. I mean it is a workable lipstick and I do like it. however, I have definitely had better. plus the color is way off. I had to use a lip liner, another lippie over top just to make this color work. I bought the shade bittersweet
beautiful colors and scent
Traci from Saginaw, MI
I own dose of cocoa, box o chocolates, and bittersweet. It smells great! Like yummy milk chocolate, but doesn't have any taste (which is good for me). It does go on pretty sticky with a heavier coat and stays tacky for awhile. It's long lasting, but does take off a bit in the center of your lips when I eat. Can be touched up with a light hand of additional application. Box o chocolates is my fav; sort of a medium brown-ish with a hint of grey-ish/mauve, if that makes sense. Bittersweet is like that, but darker. Dose of cocoa is that, but much lighter. You can put a top clear coat on if it feels too dry. I wish they could expand the line!
Dont waist your money
Nidia from Pomona
This is the worst lipstick ever. Super drying and cracks on your lips. Love the color but just not worth buying.
Don't waste your cash.
Chibicakes from Rancho Cordova
I bought Candyman and Dose of Cocoa. The shades are pretty, and they smell just like chocolate, but the formula is terrible. It starts crumbling off my lips within an hour, and it stays sticky so it pulls everytime I open my mouth and creates a crusty ring around the inside of my lips. The only way I can salvage it is to apply a gloss on top.
Jes from NM
Love the color and it lasted for hours, even thru lunch. About 5 minutes after applying, my lips started sticking together. Had to apply gloss to make it stop. Changed the look from matte to glossy but it was still pretty.
The ONLY Matte Liquid Lipsticks that have ever worked for me
Alex from San Jose, CA
I bought this just because I wanted to try a scented product. So, YES, the scent is amazing. But the formula is fantastic. You only need a little, it's easily spreadable, it feels like a satin lipstick, and it lasts me through everything EVEN WHEN I EAT -- IT DOES NOT COME OFF! IT DOES NOT BUDGE! And I'm a messy eater! "Dose of Cocoa" is a must-have if you want a pinky-brown nude natural lip color.
Worst lipstick I've used
Kate from Cleavland
I'd consider myself a high end buyer when it comes to makeup but I've always liked L'Oréal. When I saw this lipstick I had to buy it. I simply loved the color and scent. I brought the shade dose of coco. It was interesting to say the least. At the store I swatched it on my arm not my lips. It looked pretty on my arm but grey on my lips. It was dry, sticky and left a horrible line between the inside and outside of my mouth. To make it look somewhat decent I had to really work with it and add 2 other glosses on top of it. I don't want to have to struggle that much for a half decent lipstick. Never buying again.
Too drying for my lips
PsychO_ChaikO from NY
I love a long lasting lip color - this is not it. It did not feel good on my lips. Very rough and drying. Would not buy again.
Not for light skin
Jenn from Texas
This lipstick is beautiful - on my sister who has olive toned skin. Not for light-fairly light skin tone. It made me look like I had the purple lips I aimed to have in the 90s