Rated 2.75 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Too each her own liner
Some like it some don't. Not saying its the best drugstore liner (I'm still experimenting) but it has been a definite repurchase. The fact that it's mechanical, you get a good amount of product and sets matte to the point that when I tightline its a little extra effort to remove at the end of the day is good enough for me. I will say that the black one is a bit creamier than the brown but tends to smudge to the lower lashline more (I still like it but need to be careful of racoon eyes). The brown stays put but is a little stiffer so might be necessary to warm it up with your fingertips before applying otherwise it'll break off. If u have sensitive eyes and I'd say stick to a creamier formula. They're just good for every day, my UD ones are too high maintenance with the sharpening and sometimes too creamy for what I'm going for.
Most Helpful Critical Review Hurts my eyelids
I bought this 3 weeks ago knowing how great L'Oréal products are. I didn't read all the reviews regarding this item. At first the eyeliner does go on smoothly, but as you keep lining your eye it starts to hurt. The eyeliner goes on very dry and it tugs your skin. I have tryed using the eyeliner several times and it just won't work for me. It hurts and tugs your skin as you try to line your eyes. Such a waste of money. I love L'Oréal products but I can't recommend this product.
Reviewed by 195 customers Worst eyeliner
Casey91 from undisclosed
This eyeliner is dry and crumbles. I just purchased it last week and decided to try it this morning. It barely deposited any color and as I was attempting to line my lower lash it broke. I thought maybe the tip was dry so I tried again, it broke. I'm so mad I wasted money on this garbage product.
so disappointed by this product
Amy Leon from DORAL, FL
I have used LOREAL products faithfully for over 30 years-this eyeliner is so very disappointing. It is so dry and pulls skin on lids to apply it and the crayon falls out of the pen-! I suggest you do not buy this one-
madi from manteca
works for simple stuff. you can get better tho
Jflinn from Akron
This eyeliner dries out way too quickly. I cannot use it without first slid it across chapstick. It just will not put color on my eyelid. Constantly breaking. I like the idea of a sharpener at the end of pencil but does no good when pencil is broken. Too much of a hassel. Spend a little extra money of something that actually works.
Tamra P from undisclosed
I cannot get this to deposit color on my eyes/lids! It absolutely will not line my eyes. I've tried with different types of shadows and it just doesn't work. Wish I would have read reviews before buying this one
Black is nice but avoid the brown
Laura from Chicago
The black version is nice, it goes on very smooth and creamy and very dark. However it definitely smudges on my oil lids. The brown version is worthless even drawing on my hand as hard as I can I can barely get any pigment.
Really nice eyeliner
Perkey Girl from East Lansing Mi
This product works very well for me and comes in several great colors. Got a dark brown but am going to try dark gray.
sawdust from bethpage ny
Matte magic ... it is impossible to use on my eyes, it just doesn't go on.
Used to love, not so much now!
Sparkle87 from Cincinnati,ohio
I have always used this liner. Bought some about two months ago and it dried out within a week of using. Went and bought another one about two weeks ago and it broke off as soon as I tried using it. I went through the whole tube in a week! Of course because this is my favorite , I bought yet another one (should not have needed to yet). Same thing happened! Broke off every single time I went to use it. Now its over half way home and I need yet another one. Not sure if the formula was changed recently but please fix before I switch to a different brand.
Poor & breaks off every time when applying
Tyra1 from Indiana
Poor quality and waste of hard earned $$
Every attempt to apply this causes the eyeliner to break off as if it were fragile chalk.
Totally disappointed in the quality of this.
great for tight lining
Velociraptor from Myrtle Beach SC
Lasted all day and didn't cause any eye watering or discomfort. Good pigmentation as well
j from l wi
This does not go on well, the tip breaks off
If I could, I wouldn't even give it a star ....
Ifyy from Ulta Beauty Elkridge
I'm known for my perfect wings and I ran out of liner so I went to an Ulta in Elkridge, MD. I purchased the liner and tried it on the next day. I was literally tugging my lids because the color wasn't showing as much. If you want a perfect black liner on a budget, stick to the old faithful Maybelline Lasting Drama by Eyestudio Gel Liner. You're welcome 🙏🏾
Disappointed101 from Chicago
Does not glide on, actually, its more like 'invisible'. Requires a great deal of pressure and still nothing. If I had the receipt I would have returned it. An overpriced poor product. A disappointment.
Mare from Roseville,MICHIGAN
This was hard to find in other stores, but ultra had it, love that it's retractable, needs no sharpening. Goes on real smooth under eye or above eyelid.
Roddy from HI
Bought 2 pencils because I had previously used L'Oreal's 'old fashioned' eyeliner pencils that could be sharpened. First, the eyeliner would not come out when the case was swiveled; same thing happened with the second pencil. The store where purchased replaced the pencils. After several uses, the liner would not apply to the eyelid. The liner lead tip had to be wiped or cleaned before it could be used. The lead cannot be sharpened. Finally, the eyeliner lead falls out of the pencil case! It's a poorly made pencil.
Will buy again
Asdf from VA
Very good quality but it would be better if we could get this at a lower price
The Bee from Riverside, Ca
So disappointed with the pencil aspect of this product. No way to sharpen because the outside casing is like trying to sharpen a wood log. The actual liner product is so soft it falls apart when trying to sharpen. Works great when first purchased because it comes already sharpen. A total waste of money afterwards☹️
GigiLead from California
I got the deep brown color from an Ulta store. It did not leave any color when I tried to put it on, and even when I used it on a paper towel, it was having a hard time leaving any trace. Not to mention the cap cracked when I first opened the package. The eyeliner stick actually broke when I tried to apply it with a bit more pressure. 100% bad experience.
Smudges, but impossible to remove!
Olya from York, PA
It looks good when you first apply it, but mid-day it gets all smudgy. When it's time to actually remove the make IT DOES NOT COME OFF!!! I tried soap, cleaners and multiple makeup removers. It just impossible to get rid off. Takes me 3 washes before it actually clears off my eyes.
racheljames620 from Monsey, NY
I love that it gives me confidence everytime i wear it!
KartinaDaniels from Rome, NY
I got a sample of this and it exceeded my expectations
username4breeze from Byron, GA
This intensely is the best by far and is simply wonderful.
olliegrant1212 from MALONE, NY
This is a great product that works really really well.
Matte-Matic - terrible
kittycat19 from undisclosed
I have been searching for the perfect Navy eyeliner. I thought this was it, NOPE! Breaks off every time you try to use it!! Big disappointment! And waste of money.