Rated 1.78 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Would buy again
I love the color and how it goes on. It is like taking an ink pen and drawing lines. Very easy to put on after I practiced with it a couple of times.
I would like a different color. I have very black color and it is very black. I would like a soft black or brown.
Most Helpful Critical Review Happened Again
I haven't worn liner in years but thought I would give this brand a try. Honestly, the fault is on both sides. I have never been practiced at applying liner and this product didn't help. The ball on the tip just makes no sense to me. It drug on my skin and made for a big mess. Then I noticed that it transferred onto my lid after I opened my eyes. My fault there for not realizing the line was still wet. The color is deep but I could not get this liner applied without first making a big mess and then getting frustrated and just giving up. Into the useless make-up drawer it goes.
Reviewed by 63 customers Terrible eyeliner - liner tip is a hugh mess if it comes out
tb from victor ny
terrible it is a mess to get on, when it actually comes out of the pen.
Syd from Ca
When I originally bought this I thought I had grabbed a fine tip. The ball threw me off, but once I tried it, it was very easy to apply. Believe it or not I think it's good for sharp edges. The only drawback is that it isn't great for thin lines. Great if you like your liner thick!
Brittany from AR
Save your coin! This is awful!
Alice from Florida
I was very disappointed, the ball at the tip made the line very thick, and I had to go over and over the pigment was very very weak, this one is going back I like the Infallible Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner from L'ORÉAL much better, the pigment is very rich and it goes on smooth and it doesn't smear or bleeds to the eye lines and even thou it is water proof it comes off easy with makeup remover. This was a no star product for me... don't waist your money
Terrible product for me
Oma from Phila Pa
I was very disappointed in this product. It did not go on smoothly. I did not care for the ball applicator. Makes no sense to me. I looked in the mirror hours later and my eyeliner was nothing but smudges. I never had that happen to me since I have worn eyeliner and that is over 50 years ago!
Particular from Winterville
I hated this eyeliner! Smudged up on crease and the lightest touch it would smudge
I hate it,waste of money
Nolaflower from New Orleans
The liquid won't come out when you press it against your eyes. It's completely dry. It only comes out when pressed against a hard surface.
Save your money
Rocio from Tyler, Texas
The applicator tip is a ball and it makes it difficult to make a straight line over my lash line.
Laura from Buffalo, NY
The ball on the tip makes the pen skip as you apply, not glide. I had to shake or press down on the applicator to get the product onto the ball, then go over the line multiple times to get bold/not streaky color. I ended up cutting the ball off the end just to get some use out of it...
Terrible. It was quickly returned!
Danielle from Akron, OH
Application was difficult to apply due to the tip is a giant ball. It was dry as well.
Pretty when I can get it to work.
Chey from Portland
Balltip makes it super difficult to get eyeliner to look even, and hard to get into the inner corner of your eye. I feel like when I use this I need to use two pens to achieve a look. Super uneven. Not a smooth application. Good concept if you're using it for more *creative* looks, not so much for every day.
Emily from Michigan
I did not enjoy this eyeliner. I didn't realize that the applicator had a little ball on the end when I bought it. This feature made it difficult to apple and the product did not go on evenly. I had to shake the product into the felt applicator many times during application. Overall, nothing is good about it.
Not worth the effort
None from Florida
It doesn't go on as the package shows. It doesn't glide at all. You have to apply dot by dot. Smudges and smears as the day goes on. Sorry I wasted my money.
I would never buy again. Does not go on
Lynnie from Mckinney, Tx
This product was a waste of money
rae1093 from North Augusta, SC
I haven't been able to find the normal eyeliner I wear so I bought this. So disappointed. I applied it and absolutely no pigmentation, at least in one layer. The round tip is not a great design.
Nickname from Kansas
I think the round tip is awkward to apply and I don't get a bold line. It also fades very quickly.
Don't waste your money
Alicia from Albuquerque
It's an awful product, in terms of design and quality. The brush's odd shapes hinder the ways the product can be used (ie: virtually impossible to get a smooth sharp line). The liner itself bleeds into fine lines and is not very reliable in the first place.
Love this new product - finally have a cat eye
canuks00 from Chico, ca
Finally have a cat eye and no longer a beauty drop out !!! I have older droopy eye lids but this product made it so easy to just glide on
GG from Bozeman MT
Seemed dried up. If I pushed down hard it seems like it will work better but I can't push that hard down in my eyelids. Do not recommend.
Kimberly from Lake Havasu City
Seriously? A ball tip? Why?? I didn't do my research before buying this. Had heard L'Oréal's Infallibe line is great so picked this up and swatched it on my hand. Beautiful! But was confused about the ball at the tip. Tried it on my eyes and there was no way I could press hard enough to get that same beautiful dark black color on my lids like I did the back of my hand. And trying to get a precise line with that ball is impossible! Fail all around.
I hate it
Fanny from Fairfax, va
Didn't work for me
D from NC
Bought this by mistake actually and it sucks I don't understand what the ball tip is good for.
Nici1 from St Louis, MO
Thought I would try this based on reviews and price. There's nothing good I can say about it. At first I thought it had to be defective, but apparently that's the design. It's awkward and applies too thick of a line. I'll stick with my Stila liner. You get what you pay for.
Didn't like this product.
Robin from Pascagoula,MS
This ran so badly. I would not recommend this product to anyone with watery eyes.
Not as good as it looks
Kohls from New York