Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Shadow in Suede
I bought this shadow in the color Suede. I cannot tell you how long I have been looking for a matte transition color. This is it. Amazing. The perfect color for my skin tone. Every single other color that I have found has always been too orange, or too warm or too cool. This one is perfect. I would like to have every neutral shade that NYX makes. This goes on so smooth, with absolutely no fall-out and no shimmer at all. Matte like it describes. Goes on super-buttery smooth, and color payoff is exactly what I wanted.
Great Job NYX!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not nearly as good as the old formula singles
I used to LOVE the old singles that came in the square container,& was hoping beyond hope that this would be the same, but unfortunately it isn't. It isn't as pigmented as the old formula, & doesn't blend as nicely and just isn't as good. I was especially heartbroken because the old formula matte black (ES01 Black) was IMO the blackest, most pigmented & opaque black on the market, even more so than Urban Decay's Blackout, & now they stopped making it. And the new version matte black, Raven, just doesn't even compare to ES01. And the other colors I've tried just aren't nearly as good as the old ones.
Reviewed by 1122 customers Not what I was looking for
Nettle from Nebraska
I ordered this in Pixie which I thought would be a nice light sandy shimmer shade. It is a bit too light for my fair complexion and does not apply well with finger or brush, even when wet. Its a powdery formula that got everywhere and also smeared shimmer all over when I removed it.
Great eyeshadow for a great price
Virginia Beach Girl from Fort Worth, TX
This eye shadow is affordable and my favorite color.
Unique shades, minimal pigment
Jill098 from CA
I was looking for a yellow (not gold) eyeshadow single. I wanted to blend some bright colors for summer. I checked the high-end brands and not one had a yellow available. I have had good luck with some NYX products in the past, so I tried this one in yellow. Unfortunately the color is minimally pigmented and even after multiple layers the color was washed out and understated. It would be fine if you were looking for an everyday hint of unique colors, but not if you are looking for a true-shade bold pop.
I'll continue to look for a bold yellow.
Some shades better than others
Haley from Georgia
Inconsistent performance in this line. Some are wonderful and blend great and some
fall flat and are chalky.
Great Eye Shadow
LM from NY
Great shade to cover entire lid. No shimmer or glitter. Great for everyday wear.
My eyes are too sensitive.
Christina from MO
I was hoping this would be good because Nyx isn't as expensive as some brands, but pain isn't a good trade off.
Hannah from Old Hickory, TN
The formula of the shadow is lovely, and perfectly pigmented as well.
I would buy this again
Becky from Elsmere, KY
Product goes on smoothly
Wendy from Anchorage Alaska
I can't use the product because it is broken and spilled on all the other contents in the package
Sweetnlow from Milford, PA
Pretty good. Love the color! I have to use several coats for total lid saturation but it's ok. There's little fallout also. Not as good as MAC but f you're looking for an affordable good eyeshadow, this ones pretty good.
CUPCAKE is the light pink eye shadow I've been searching for
Jenna (: from Chico, CA
I am pretty fair, and I always have found that the light pink shades in palettes have looked a little too neon on my skin. I have been dying for a super light pink shade to use as a natural transition for a while now, and I am SO, SO happy that I picked this up!
yeetasauruswrecks from WI
grabbed this as a base to set my eye primer - works pretty well on my cool-toned skin. it's a bit dusty, but hard packed enough it'll last plenty long to be well worth the price.
AL from Burbank, CA
Well worth the price.
AL from Burbank, CA
Well worth the price.
Love the Color and Decent Coverage
realtorlady07 from Austin TX
I really like this color as a base then I apply my other eye shadow. It blends well with my skin and keeps the "white" at a minimum on my eyelids so if I choose not to apply other shadow this one at least helps my skin look more even. I tend to use more of it because the pigment isn't as great but for the price and my liking of the color itself, it's worth it to me.
Natural look eye shadow
Cher from AZ
Very natural look for daytime wear
Pixie shimmer is the worst!
Sherry from Kansas
This particular color "pixie" is a shimmer that doesn't pick up on a brush, balls up, and doesn't apply well on the lid. I had to use setting spray on my brush to even get a little application. I have tried one of the matte shades and did not have this problem.
Second purchase of this eye shadow
Sandy from Michigan
I like this better than the expensive brands I have purchased.
Jassss from Chicago
Terrible kept trying to build on it and it wouldn't build
Swatches nicely but pigment disappears on the eye
Sam from Dallas, GA
The pigment completely disappears when you apply it on the lid!
Hard to de-pot
Kkddf from California
These shadows are nice quality for the price and i like the selection offered. BUT, if you're going to de pot them into your own custom palette the packaging makes it very hard. Literally had to YouTube a safe way to do it. The glue is very stubborn even when burning it off using a lighter and the fitting is so tight around the pan in the plastic there's almost a guarantee to mangling the shadow or pan or both... be warned.
Not very pigmented
Pacibaby from Steele, MO
I thought it would be more of a red but it came out pink. Not very pigmented.
LOVE THE PIGMENT
Leh from Wisconsin
I LOVE the Whipped cream shade. It's a matte white. I use it for a clean line above my eyeliner. Gives me this fresh eyes look. This is the ONLY pod that I will EVER buy. It is worth the price! I hope they NEVER discontinue this product! Highly reccomend!
Great color - slightly dry
Lauren from TN
This is a great dupe for color of the Naked 3 base color but is not near as creamy. However, it doesn't get all oily and weird like the Naked 3 base color. Stiletto is a perfect dupe for the color and though it's dry it still gets the job done. It's not too terribly dry but a little dry.
Princess from Charlotte, NC
This is a great shade of blue.