Product Reviews Rated 4.13 out of 5 stars
164 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review LOVE IT SO MUCH! I usually use the urban decay perversion eyeliner but everytime I want to buy it, it is sold out at my ulta. I wanted to try this because the swatches were amazing and the free sharpener intrigued me. I use this daily now and it's is my new favorite. It is very comparable to the urban decay one and instead of having to line with two separate eyeliners (liquid and a stick), I can just use this and resharpen easily. It is cheaper and more affordable than buying my two eyeliners also.
Most Helpful Critical Review Would not buy this product again I love Buxom but this eyeliner does not last on the waterline. I specifically asked the sales associate for a good eyeliner for the waterline because it fades or runs and was recommended this.
Reviewed by 164 customers Where have you been all my life? 5
ChickFeed from TN
I. Love. This. Eyeliner. It is a little smudgeable when you put it on but not too much since it stays where you put it. I don't have to worry about it coming off until I take it off. The best thing about this eyeliner? The color. It is sooo difficult to find a black-brown. Black is just too harsh and the browns are usually too light and/or too reddish. Call me Goldilocks because this one is just right! Will buy this again and again!
Love it 5
Lin from Livermore CA
Love how it goes on and stays on
It Holds The Line 5
MusicMelanie from Pittsburgh, PA
This is long-wearing liner, lasting all day & late into the evening. And it is smudgeable for that smokey eye. The only drawback is that the pencil isn't retractable. Sharpening (with the enclosed sharpener) can be a little messy.
My favorite eyeliner 5
Pink Panda from Indianapolis, Indiana
Love this liner. Goes on smooth. Stays on all day. Just a hint of sparkle. The color is perfect - less severe than a black or dark brown.
They quit carrying it at the Keystone Crossing store - which is a bummer. Thankfully I can still get it at the Hamilton Town location.
Would not buy again 2
snochic34 from Colorado
I love the color but have the hardest time getting this to stay on. It might be better if used with eye shadow, but I often just swipe on with mascara and a few hours later, I find it on top of my eye lid. I try to let it set in in the morning but has not been successful. I have not tested it in water but if it smudges wearing to work, I cannot image how it would not come off in the pool. I love Buxom's lip glosses so thought I would enjoy this product, but this definitely falls flat for me.
I will continue to buy this product. 5
KAK from Sagamore Hills. ohiot
All day wear without touch up. I really like this product.
Purchased several times 5
KAK from Sagamore Hills, Ohio
All day wear without touch up. I really like this product.
I love this eyeliner! 5
8KC from Columbus OH
My hairdresser told me about this liner about a year ago and I absolutely love it. No need to reapply ever all day long.
Glides well 5
Big from Atlanta, GA
I use this for tight lining my eyes. It glides well which helps with my eyes watering. Don't forget to set your liner with a powder, maybe black or brown.
Great eyeliner 5
Lindo from Modesto
I was using a different brand and ran out. The sales staff helped me find this product and I love it.
Love the color, but... 2
Happymom from NY
I bought this eyeliner to wear in the waterline. The color "Door's Open" is gorgeous, but it did not work well for me. It deposited very little color, and when I went over it, it deposited clumps along my lashes. Disappointed.
Love it! 5
Michelle from Manasquan, NJ
Lasts almost the whole day.
This liner is a gem 5
Mar from Raleigh
I've tried lots of liners in search of one that stays on and does not smudge. Goes on easy.
No transferring or smudging! 5
Heather from Utah
I love to tight-line and I've tried countless gel liners trying to find ones that are truly smudge and transfer-proof. I got this in the shade Here's My Number which is a super dark, almost-black brown. It applies very smoothly and does NOT transfer nor smudge AT ALL even if my eyes get watery. It stays looking great all day. I'll definitely repurchase the next time I need another liner!
Amazing! 5
Darbar from Napa, Ca
Best eyeliner I've ever used! It glides on and feels creamy, the color is intensely pigmented, and once it sets it stays put! I bought this on a whim looking for a particular color. I had no idea it came with a sharpener, (and I needed one), 🙏🏻 I also didn't know it would be my favorite eyeliner in the world. Will be purchasing all the colors I like. Thank you Buxom❤️❤️❤️ Some reviews compared this to Urban decay. I've used both and the urban decay isn't even in the same league. This one is way better
Love, love love 5
Nanna from Hartwell
Only thing I have to complain about was the Anderson store didn't have the color I wanted so I settled for second best which is not the product's fault. The product was great!!!
LOVE IT SO MUCH! 5
Joell from Seattle Washington
I usually use the urban decay perversion eyeliner but everytime I want to buy it, it is sold out at my ulta. I wanted to try this because the swatches were amazing and the free sharpener intrigued me. I use this daily now and it's is my new favorite. It is very comparable to the urban decay one and instead of having to line with two separate eyeliners (liquid and a stick), I can just use this and resharpen easily. It is cheaper and more affordable than buying my two eyeliners also.
Wide Line, Excellent Waterproof Eyeliner! 4
Jessidoll1417 from Florida
This is probably the best waterproof eyeliner I've ever purchased! Stays on eternally without using some good remover. I bought Call Me (Matte Black) and am very happy. As some have mentioned, this is a crayon-type eyeliner, and not fine point without diligent sharpening, but if that's not the only thing you're looking for, I highly recommend this product!
Love These!! 5
Kelsey from Mi
Long lasting, very creamy, stays on for my 18 hour shift through copious amounts of sweating. I highly recommend!
descent 3
Shawna from Pico Rivera, ca
I bought this eyeliner because a friend of mine recommended it. I've been searching for an eyeliner that stays in the water line and doesn't transfer down to the outside of my eye. I was mildly happy with this product because I enjoyed the pigmentation but the longevity is not as impressive as I thought it would be.
Repurchased Knock Twice 5
Sandra from Virginia
I think this is the only eyeliner I've repurchased. I don't like a heavy liner on the lower eye and this color adds just the right amount of definition. Stays put all day.
I usually love this product line, but this eyeliner is bad 1
k from seattle
This eyeliner doesn't apply to the lash line. Even after sharpening it a few times, to see if the beginning of the pencil was the issue. But no.....I even tried heating it up with my hair dryer. very disappointed.
It sparkles! 5
Sarah from Chattanooga
My favorite eye liner!
Yes I am going to! 4
Connie from Fresno
I wear it everyday! Its doesn't leave a mark on my upper lid.
I'd buy again 4
Amanda from Blytheville, Ar.
I'd buy again