Rated 4.37 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner ever.
I've only tried the black one. This liner can make any kind of line you want, down the the absolute thinnest. It goes on smoothly and it's a fine brush tip. I have hooded eyes and this stuff wears all day without transfer. The tube also lasted for a very very long time. Comparing this against the KVD tattoo liner and the Stila one, I prefer this one.
For me, the trick is to let the line dry fully, preferably with eyes closed for about 20 seconds before moving onto the next eye. If it dries intact, then afterwards it's set until I want to remove it.
Most Helpful Critical Review Disappointing formula
You have no idea how badly I wanted to love this product! It has such high ratings and good reviews from YouTube MUAs. First of all, the color is not matte, or very bold. It glides on somewhat easily but it is much more sheer than you'd expect from a name brand eyeliner. Anyway, my chief complaint is that I've had it for less than 24 hours and it is applying as if it's drying out or all gone. I ordered online, and I sincerely hope I did not receive a returned product. When I called the store to ask about a replacement, she suggested I store it upside down. I'm sorry but I don't think I should have to treat it as an old dried out sharpie marker! It is literally brand new. This is very disappointing.
Reviewed by 1362 customers Best liner out there
All girl from Portland
I am buying at least my fourth tube of this liner! It lasts a long time and I've tried them all and I keep coming back. Love the matt finish that doesn't look cakey !
On my 8th liner!!
Marsha from NYC
I've been a loyal lover of this liner since 2012. It's a true black, dries in seconds of application and lasts all day for me. I have oily eyelids and don't have any issues with it smudging on me after a few hours. The tip is super pointy allowing me to get the sharp and crisp line.
Not for Watery Eyes
A.Naka from San Jose, CA
I purchased this eyeliner with high hopes after seeing so many good reviews, but am sad to say I will never purchase it again. It may work very well for some people- it just wasn't for me.
I personally have very watery eyes (particularly my left eye for some reason. I am always on the hunt for a good, truly water-proof liquid eyeliner. This one definitely did not live up to the test. I don't feel like it is waterproof OR smudge resistant. Even when I was very careful not to accidentally touch my eye area, I'd find that the liner often disappeared within a few hours.
The one pro is that the tip is so fantastically fine. You can really get a thin line and precise wing. That's why I'm all the more disappointed that the formula doesn't work for me.
I would buy this product again
BA from Texas
I have been searching for an eyeliner that doesn't smear. So far this is the one.
This was disappointing
JellyA from California
The reviews made this seems amazing and it wasn't at all. I can draw a line and wipe it off with my fingers. This can be wiped off so easily and sometimes is difficult to apply as it is very light. The tip of the eyeliner is fine and I've had no issue with that. However, the eyeliner itself is just poor quality and I will often get through one eye with lots of struggling and am unable to do the other eye because it just refuses to apply anything. Or if it does, it's extremely light.
The city girl from Los Angeles
Literally nothing is showing on my eyes. The ink is so faint and I don't even know I put on eyeliners already. Waste of money.
Love the snap-on cap
Kayla from Michigan
This eyeliner is one of the best liquid eyeliners I've tried. It's got smooth application and great pigmentation, but my favorite part is that the cap actually snaps on. I've had several eyeliners dry out because the cap fell off in my makeup bag or wasn't sealed all the way, but Lorac's snap-on cap prevents that from happening.
Sheer and patchy
sarah from CA
This review is for the brown shade. I had high hopes because of the reviews, but the brown shade is so sheer and patchy-- its very difficult to get it opaque. The only good thing about this product is the brush applicator; its very easy to use. However, I would not repurchase this.
I buy this eyeliner over and over
Patty from IN
These are the only liquid eyeliners I use regularly. I use either the brown or gray everyday. They are perfect for me; not too stiff, not too soft, not too thin, not too thick. They last a long time for me. I've been using the ones I have now for at least 5 months, and they are just now starting to run out. I store them standing upside down to help them keep from drying out. Please don't get rid of them!!
THE SNEHA ALI from Sugarland
This eyeliner is not too thin and not too thick, lasts throughout the day, and now my eyeliner application is much faster and easier! Btw perfect for a winged look! This beats the urban decay perversion liner & kat von d's tattoo liner!
Itsiebitsie from CO
I've use it for years then I started trying some less expensive brands. I buy it when it's on sale or with a coupon. I have found less expensive brands that do just as well thought.
The only eye liner that I ever use!
Kmock from Western MD
I'm not a huge eyeliner fan, but when I'm in the mood this is my go to! Precise, bold, and last forever.
Mya from new york
My product came in a little dry so it's really hard to apply and takes numerous tries in order to work.
T from Pittsburgh
I've used Stila liquid liner for probably the past 4 years and love it but decided to give this a try because I'd been having some eye issues. My dr. said it was not from my makeup but I still decided to replace all of my go to products just to see. This Lorac eye liner didn't stand a chance against my Stila. It isn't as black and it's almost like translucent grey. It just seemed watered down, if that makes sense. If this wasn't the era of Covid, I would have taken it back to the store. Hugely disappointed.
Sakura from Maryland
This eyeliner has the best precision out of all brands of eyeliner I've ever tried. I got this in Black, but the color is more of a faded black. That's the only disappointment. Even if you go over it multiple times its still not dark enough. But I would buy it again.
Jenna from Peoria, IL
I've tried so many liquid eyeliners, I can't stand the felt tip bc they snag and I like potted eyeliner but its time consuming, I can use this for a dramatic wing or a natural wing SO quickly. less than a minute per eye. the brittle are well controlled and never fray or get gunky, EVER! I love this and they discontinued caring Lora at the peoria Illinois location and im SO SAD!
Naidy from NY
I'm not sure how this has high reviews. The pigment is atrocious, it doesnt stay, and it doesn't layer well. You have to wait for it to dry completely then hope it doesn't flake off once you layer it. Rarely does it not. I finally got a good line and it didn't even last 4 hours. Waste of money...
Love This Liner
Mel from Sacramento
I am a redhead and I swear by the brown liner. Yes, as some of the other reviewers mention, it is not particularly dark. I avoid other brown liners because they are so dark. If I want dark liner, I will wear black. However, it does show up and it shows up nicely. I get so many compliments on this liner when I wear it, which I do all the time, especially for daywear. The brush allows for a lovely sweep across the lid and a nice wing. As long as I've been doing a cat eye, I still struggle due to eye shape. This liner makes it as easy as any ever has. I've never found a brown liner I love as much as Lorac.
Don't waste your money
Paula from Medford nj
I never write reviews ,but l don't want people wasting there money on this . You have to go over it several times to see it
Great staying power
Rue from Oregon
It's not as pigmented as I would have liked. I have to go over my lines a couple of times to get the color I like
best liquid eyeliner pen
LaLa from IL
I have been using this for years and do not stray from this product. They used to have more colors (wish they would bring them back), but this is my go to product.
Noor from California
I love it
js from Louisiana
Best liquid eyeliner out there. Will always repurchase
Not a bad liner, but not best
AnotherReviewer from LA
This liner is easy to use and is suitable for beginners because the brush is easy to work with. It's not for those who want the blackest black matte line though. For that reason, the price is too much for a so-so performing liner.
Not sure why this has high reviews
Marie from North Carolina
I got this because it had such great reviews and I was looking for a cheaper all purpose liner. The tip was great, seems more waterproof than most that claim it and the packaging looks great. That's about it. This stuff is RUNNY!!! It bleeds and this is very lacking in pigmentation (and I got black). Even on the back of my hand, it's super watery looking and even letting a layer dry and going back over it doesn't help one bit. This was a huge disappointment.