Product Reviews Rated 4.53 out of 5 stars
128 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Team Fluidline!!!!!! Fluidline has impressed me again ladies. OMG. Please ladies if you have not gotten your hands on this product or simply just don't know where to start with it . You got to race to the nearest MAC counter before these little prizes are gone. If its hot as cow hair outside, your brows will be the least of your worries. I have light golden blonde hair with blonde highlights all over my head. I am a NW45 in Studio Fix Powder Plus Foundation and Dark Deep in Beauty Balm. I got this brow gelcreme in Deep Dark Brunette. Now if your hair is light like mine. Take your 266 brush lightly dip in this product and tap on the back of your hand before filling your brows. Then grab the prolongwear brow set in red chestnut and follow your brows with it to soften the gelcreme even more. The Deep Dark Brunette is great for medium and dark haired ladies too. Also, your brows does not get oily like when you fill your brows in with pencil or eyeshadow. My corduroy shadow can take a hike for a while. Its a new sheriff in town. Mr Fluidline. Anyway, thank you once again to all my ladies prior to myself that did reviews on this product. It had a huge impact on my purchase and drove me to the counter for a brow demo. I hope this helps and Stay Faceful Ladies!!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Neanderthal review The product itself is great. Easy to apply and works as promised. Doesn't smudge. But unless your hair is super black don't get this shade. It looks dark brown in the pot but goes on very black. My hair is black but not jet black and this was way too dark. Will try brunette.
Reviewed by 128 customers Waste of money! 1
MelW from Dallas, TX
I usually love MAC products and I hate, having to give a bad review. However, this brow gel is very disappointing. I was really excited to try it, after reading many great reviews. I have sparse, thin eyebrows and have used brow gel, my entire adult life. I've used Merle Norman's brow gel, since my twenties and more recently, I tried gimme brow. I like my eyebrows to look natural and darker, since I have dark brown hair. So, when I got Mac's brow gel in, I tried it immediately. I used Mac's clear brow set, over the brow gel, to set it. I was very optimistic and hopeful, that this would be a great product. However, within 2 hours, it was already coming off and I wasn't sweating or doing anything to cause it to do this. Definitely NOT, "Long wearing". If I hadn't used other great brow gels before, I might have been satisfied. However, Merle Norman's brow gel is far better, it goes on with a brush, so it sticks to your brow hair and actually does last all day. Gimme brow is also better than this. So this was a waste of money. Very disappointing.
So many better options . . . 1
Former MAC user from Kansas
I tried this product after MAC discontinued their highly-rated brow liquid product last year.Very disappointed.Very limited color choices.Doesn't do anything to enhance brow hairs.Simply colors the skin underneath.I wore it all summer and every time I went outside, it literally ran down my face. When fall rolled around, I only had to deal with smudging. That is, until the product dried up and became flaky.I've used MAC cosmetics for years. But finding the quality isn't there anymore. For the price, there are so many better options.
Best brow product I've ever tried 5
Sexy but sweet from America
I used this with the Mac angled brush that I've used for other cake and gel brow makeup. I'm so done with brow pencil because they always smear away on me, have to keep sharpening, and I have poor control.
Other brow gels are either too gooey or dry up. Brow cakes either have to have liquid added or they're powdery, which saves me time, but they also rub off too easily.
This one was easy and fast enough to apply with the correct brush, stayed put and looked natural on me, not waxy or flaky or smudgy. The color was versatile too.
I am missing the shade variety! 5
Izzy from Grand Rapids, MI
This formula is fantastic and my go to brow product as a makeup artist. I utilized most of the shades that were previously available as well as the current ones; and I will miss them so dearly! Dirty Blonde was great for natural-toned blondes, brunettes who just want a wash of color, or bright blondes that enjoy a darker brow. Ash Blonde was my go to for my mature clients, or light blonde brows. The formula goes on like butter, is great for crisp definition, but also diffuses wonderfully. I'm not sure what I will do when I run out :(
Redhead 4
Teri from WA
Hey MAC! I'm so disappointed that you discontinued the Redhead color. I know it's all about money for you. Only 1 to 2 percent of the human population has red hair (Wikipedia)so why bother to make products for us when its not profitable for you. Please bring it back. Redheads are important too! I have been buying MAC products for I think about 20 years. I hope you are listening. Thanks!
Dirty Blonde 5
BecsFL from Florida
I have been using this eyebrow gel for a number of years. Color used was Dirty Blonde but dont seem to find that color any more. LOVE this FLUIDLINE BROW GELCREME. HIGHLY Recommended. It goes on really nice and stays on too.
PLEASE BRING REDHEAD BACK!!! 5
Redhead!!! from Dayton
Redhead was the only color that ever matched my hair perfectly. Ever since my brows have looked so dark because nothing is light enough! Please please please bring it back!!!!!!!!
REDHEAD 5
Kay from California
Please please please bring the redhead back! It's the only thing that's ever matched PERFECTLY. Show some love to your ginger friends, MAC ❤️
Red Head Back 5
Please Bring Red head back!!! from Philadelphia
Please for the love of god, bring red head back. Nothing compares. Only color that is perfect! Why was it discontinued???
you need to bring back for all us loyal mac lovers.PLEASE!
Red Head Back 5
Please Bring Red head back!!! from Philadelphia
Please for the love of god, bring red head back. Nothing compares. Only color that is perfect! Why was it discontinued???
you need to bring back for all us loyal mac lovers.PLEASE!
More shades please! 4
Debra from USA
I love this product, but it is a little too warm for my hair/skin! I'm a blonde with dark brows and this can end up looking red if I'm not careful! That said, it stays put through the entire day including very sweaty workouts.
easy application 4
Irit from Nowrich, VT
Easy and smooth application. A bit dark, but I use a lash brush to spread it and thin it out. Stays put.
Please bring back redhead!!!! :'( 5
Sian from Glasgow
This is the only colour I've ever had that matches my hair perfectly and it's gone! I've recommended it to every ginger person i know! Help!
Why did you discontinue redhead??? 5
Jen from NC
It is ONLY product that matched my strawberry blonde hair😫 please bring it back!!!
Please bring back Redhead! 5
Anne from United States
Why is redhead discontinued?? This is my favorite brow product for my red hair. Please bring this back when I run out I don't know what im gonna use i've tried so many brow prodcuts that claim to be "redhead" shades but they're usually too dark but this shade is perfect bring this back please!
Discontinued? 5
purpldy from Los Angeles, CA
PLEASE, PLEASE bring back RedHead. Only decent eyebrow cream for Strawberry Blonds!
Too dark 1
Dalo from Maywood, NJ
The color the sales associate recommended and I thought it also match my complexion was to dark. I'm going back to exchange.
Easy to Apply & Long-lasting 5
1ProductJunkie from Houston, TX
I love this Gelcreme! It's easy to apply (whether you're a makeup novice or a pro), goes on smooth, and lasts all day without smudging or fading. A little goes a long way, and one pot lasts me several months and never dries out. I use the M.A.C Cosmetics 266 Small Angle Brush to apply. I've been using this Gelcreme since 2015.
Love the brow gelcreme 5
LOVE this brow gelcreme from Florida
I LOVE this gel browcreme. I have been using it for a few years now and many people comment on how beautiful my eyebrows look. This is because the gelcreme goes on very nicely and smoothly with no lumps or clumps like other brands I have used. Keep up the great product Mac. I used the dirty blonde. For me it looks more natural even though my hair is dark brown. I have olive skin tone.
I want to love it 4
alliebadallie from 86022
I want to love this product, but I can't. I do like it, but no product I have tried comes close to the Anastasia dip brow. i like the color and I like how long it lasts, but for me it's hard to blend to look the way I want it to.
Perfect 5
Phoenix from Phoenix
Long wearing, good texture, great color. Natural looking.
Nope 3
kher from guam
The product dries up after having it for about a month. I have repurchased the product over 3 times, and they all have done the same. I do however think the color is amazing, but maybe the formula needs a little bit of help for it to last longer in it's case
Returning 1
Johnnie from Grants Pass, OR
I've used Mac for years. Great products. This one not for me. The color is light in the jar but applies too dark even though I try to apply sparingly. Will return this one.
Love this ! 4
Charlene from Ohio
I love this brow gel! My only issue is it's not water proof! MAC make it waterproof and don't discontinue it and it's a wrap !!
smudges a little 3
Molls from Guayaquil, Ecuador
i like this a lot but it smudges, it is very humid where i live so maybe that as something to do with it.