Product Reviews Rated 4.1 out of 5 stars
60 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love this palette! I love boxycharm because it pushes me out of my comfort zone. Had I seen this palette in the store, I probably would've passed this one by, but because I got it in the box I made it a point to really give it a go. Some items in the boxes are duds, but guys, this one really gets used!
I'm a beginner when it comes to eyeshadow, and sometimes I struggle, but for whatever reason I find it really easy to make a great neutral look with the shadows around the border. I haven't used the 2 glitters as much (note: I think they're too chunky to be safe to wear on your eyes. Put them on your body instead), but the rest of the shades are stunning. Now, personally I'm not at all sure how to incorporate the pinks and purples into a look with the rest of the shades so I don't wear them together, but as individual shades, they're stunning.
I have hooded eyes, so like to go really dark in the outer V and crease and the dark brown is just perfect. I reach for it a lot even when I'm using other palettes. For example, the naked cherry palette doesn't have a shade dark enough. I will definitely hit pan on the dark brown. The shimmer shades all look absolutely stunning on the lid. And the other orangey/brown shades are gorgeous, easy to use, and each to create a great neutral look with.
Most Helpful Critical Review Got mine in boxy as well.... I collect pallettes, and have three from PUR. They are very hit and miss. Quality just isn't there. I've tried drug store brands that are better them this, and cost less too. I just dont see how the company justified the price of this. The colors look amazing in the pans. But the two glitters are more gel like consistency and is more on the wet/goopy side that makes it hard to work with, and makes it LOOK even worse after an hour or so with it sliding around everywhere. You can use the best primers, glitter glues, and even other eyeshadows and use them as a topper and it's still just awful.
The Mattes and shimmers just dont pack enough punch or staying power and lean toward the chalky side and are not buttery or easy to blend and work with. Even if you manage to get it looking okay, after twenty minutes or so the colors seem to fade away. Once again it dont matter what primer you use, even glitter glue, mac paint pots, even foundation, or a "naked" easy eyeball just dont work.
It's sad because in the pan these colora look so very pretty and vibrant and good, but when you start working with them, even if you only use just one wash of color on your lid, this stuff is still not good. I dont know how it's got all these good reviews. I wish this brand would go back to the drawing board and reformulate their eyeshadows, because what they are using now just dont work, and I'm truly shocked at the price point they put on this vs what the quality is and what you get. Way to many other brands out here that have a better formula and price point then this.
Reviewed by 60 customers Very bad quality 1
maqqa from new york
I bought it turned out badly, I do not advise, and you will regret your money to buy something else from this site. Very baaddd
LOVE THIS! 5
Jo from Manitowoc Wisconsin
Love this palette,I bought it at a steep discount and it works wonderfully.I don't understand the negative reviews.These shadows are smooth and pigmented for me and I can create great daytime and nighttime looks.The glitters are ok but I don't really use them, those could be replaced with two more shades instead.
talk about some pink pigment 3
JC989 from Idaho
i adore this item i finally tried the pink and purple tonight and dang that pink had some pigment i usually have a hard time getting pink to even show up on my skin but dang this one good...this item is good if you like to stay in your comfort zone but also good if you like to jazz it up a bit!! i also love the glitter colors they are sickening!
Glad it was in a beauty box 4
Broke_beauty_ from MetroDetroit
If I had bought this myself I would give it 3 stars. The pigment is good but I would love it not to have the glitters and have a blue and red to go with the pink and purple. I know presses glitters are a thing right now but less is more.
good 5
hi from CA
amazing colors
Beginner 3
Mads from Brigham City
Decent pallete for beginners, but it's one of my more boring palletes
Longevity is awful 2
Meg from Saint Petersburg, FL
The pigment in most of shades is great (at first) but it fades pretty fast. I work this to a festival and the colors were so bright and vibrant at first but the orange transition shade faded almost immediately. So I was out there in the world with a pink crease and no transition. The purple was the next to fade. Also, you have to really pack the purple on to get good pigment and there was a lot of fallout. But even with 17 layers of the purple, it still faded. The pink did eventually fade as well. I guess this is a good palette if you want a colorful look for a few hours. But I needed it to last all day. I'd say this is a good palette for practice, but even then, not really. There's so many other cheaper, more colorful, good quality palettes out there. In 2019, brands really need to step it up on their quality.
Horrible! 1
Mrs. S. from Michigan
The red glitter "Fireworks" gave me a stye. I will never be using this again. The other shadows in the palette aren't good at all.
Pretty 4
PandaShawna from North Carolina
I love this pallette. You can make bright and fun looks for neutral looks. I don't use the glitters though.
Middle of the road 3
Chelsy from Ohio
Has almost a drug store quality and the glitter shade is awful.
Bad Quality 1
sonnie from Hanover, PA
I have bought over twenty palettes this year and this is the only one I've returned. Pür palettes are usually nice but the pigmentation in this was horrible. I was very disappointed with this product.
I love this palette!! 5
Liz from Evansville, IN
I've created some beautiful looks with this palette. It's great for everyday looks or a bold look.
Alright 3
Nzzzz from LA
Got the job done but This palette isn't worth 36 nor 20 bucks. I wouldn't buy it .there are other great and way affordable shadows.
My FAVORITE 5
pdub from Atlanta
This palette is GORGEOUS! It's super pigmented and you can create so many beautiful looks
not too bad 4
waste_my_money_on_makeup from south Carolina
it's a good pallette, I love how all the mattes are warm toned because I have warm undertones with light tan skin. but I found the pink and purple shades a bit patchy. honestly not the best for the price
NOT WORTH THE PRICE 2
Sarah from New York
I borrowed this from a friend to try it, and thought it was an OKAY/AVERAGE palette. Nothing to write home about. Now seeing the price, I am stunned because you can find shadows that perform SO MUCH better for so much less. It's a rip off. Don't do it.
Gorgeous Palette! 5
MJ from Vegas
This is a pressed pigment palette. Not only can you use the shades as eyeshadow but you can use as blush, bronzer and highlight. It smells delicious and goes on buttery. The glitter shades are creamy and fun. I love it!
no 3
stuffncover from Appleton
got this in boxy and hate it. all the mattes are waaaayyyy orangey and I'm sorry but not everyone likes orange eyeshadow.. like me for instance and it's bad enough that its everywhere lately. then the shimmers are also too warm toned and boring and not that sparkley. I wld never be caught dead wearing glitter on my eyes but if I did it wldnt be this glitter it's exactly like chunky craft glitter. cant speak to the wear of that since I never tried it but its awfully gaudy.
Love this palette! 5
Kristen from Indianapolis, IN
I love boxycharm because it pushes me out of my comfort zone. Had I seen this palette in the store, I probably would've passed this one by, but because I got it in the box I made it a point to really give it a go. Some items in the boxes are duds, but guys, this one really gets used!
I'm a beginner when it comes to eyeshadow, and sometimes I struggle, but for whatever reason I find it really easy to make a great neutral look with the shadows around the border. I haven't used the 2 glitters as much (note: I think they're too chunky to be safe to wear on your eyes. Put them on your body instead), but the rest of the shades are stunning. Now, personally I'm not at all sure how to incorporate the pinks and purples into a look with the rest of the shades so I don't wear them together, but as individual shades, they're stunning.
I have hooded eyes, so like to go really dark in the outer V and crease and the dark brown is just perfect. I reach for it a lot even when I'm using other palettes. For example, the naked cherry palette doesn't have a shade dark enough. I will definitely hit pan on the dark brown. The shimmer shades all look absolutely stunning on the lid. And the other orangey/brown shades are gorgeous, easy to use, and each to create a great neutral look with.
The green sparkles are so fun 5
Pale snow queen from Mn
The purple. Pink. And glitters are unique and fun!!
Glitter Everywhere :( 2
just.gretchen from Rock Island
The mattes in this palette are very pretty, as are the shimmers.
BUT
the GLITTER!!!!!
UGLY on the lids, like chunky craft glitter.
FALLOUT worse than anything I have EVER used!! It is literally all over my house.
Dont these companies test their products?
The glitter😻😻😻😻 4
Elenaarmdz from Houston, Texas
The glitter is amazing they feel so nice there not greasy like other, the hot pink is also great there is a semi good smell to the palette it smells like a bakery
Pretty good 4
Ash from IN
I like this pallet for the most part. The only thing I had an issue with is some of the shadows are better than others, a few of them you have to build up. I really appreciated it actually having some color in it. I'm getting so tired of pallets being just nudes! I have hooded eyes and the glitter stayed in place as good as it could. (Better than a lot of others) I can get some good looks from this palette.
Wouldn't Recommend 2
Michaela from Kansas
It was okay, but I don't ever reach for this palette. i loved the glitters and thought they were amazing, but I was extremely disappointed with the purple shade in this palette. I could not get any pigmentation out of the purple shade whatsoever that I stopped trying to use it. The other colors are alright but you can find them in many other palettes.
pigment heaven 5
Lindzee from Virginia
I LOVE this palette. Especially the mattes
