Rated 3.91 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Such a cool product.
I was very curious about these when I first saw them at my local NYX store early this year. I first purchased the color Baby Powder because I have blue eyes and I thought it would be the perfect waterline color to make them pop - and boy was I right. Today I decided to go and purchase the color Honeydew as well... I am very excited to try it as an inner corner highlight and/or brow bone highlight. These pencils are SO creamy and super pigmented, and I love the fact that they still show up even on my ultra pale skin tone. I can only imagine how beautiful these look on darker skin tones. I would DEFINITELY recommend this product, especially for the price. NYX, you amaze me once again.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not the hype I was led to believe
Will not last in the tear ducts, or under eye. Works pretty well as a second line in winged eyeliner. Gives a better 3d effect on upper lid. If you have an excess oil gland, or are oily in general, it's not the best. I bought 3 colors; linen, lavender blush, and honeydew. The colors really does not show through on these white ones nor did they make any little difference overall. It will just always look off-white. Sometimes a little too bold of white. You're better off buying the NYX Wonder pencil. It's cheaper, last longer and looks more natural, not to mention it's multiple uses. 😉 save yourself the money.
Reviewed by 249 customers Love it
Kayla from Pennsylvania
I used to use a simple white eyeliner pencil. Nothing fancy. But they are so hard to find now, just s simple..colored pencil for your eye. I saw in a makeup video it's better to use flash colored pencils. So I tried this one and I love it the color is great. It matches great with the eye shadow l like to put under my bottom lashes to brighten up, because I like the natural look. Sharpening is awkward, the wood type material seems to want to splinter and theres some slight space between the wood and the color so it's not a smooth sharpening.
Exactly what I wanted
MUAcosmo from Wichita
I bought the color linen to line my water line to give my eye a more awake look. It glides on easily and I absolutely love the look. It makes my eyes look bigger and just better. I don't do my eye makeup without it now.
I've bought every single color!
A from Ny
I love these liners! They don't last all day, but they fade nicely throughout the day, but not completely where you can't see it anymore. They do sharpen and I guess some people just can't figure it out. You just have to press hard. Overall these are my favorite for tightlining!
Wish there were more product, but it's worth the $
Beauty Gal that Loves You from Tacoma, Washington
I use on under eye corner, or waterline, doesn't irritate, not enough product to color lids to make eye shadow really pop!
Dezzy from Oregon
I got the green and lavender-toned ones since my eyes are green, and they compliment them so nicely. The formulation is super creamy and dries down, so it's easy to use and pretty trusty. This is my go-to waterline brightener!
I will continue to buy this
Marcy from Port Chester NY
I use this as under eye liner
Amy from NYC
DOESNT even look pink it just looks white
MC from Darien, IL
The pencil tip was broken off when I unsealed and opened it. The tip was stuck in the cap! I thought it rolled up but I guess it can be sharpened. Took it back cause I lost most of it and I don't have a sharpener that works on plastic. Too bad cause it looked like a nice color.
Rach1029 from Ca
I got this in the shade Linen and it is a perfect neutral brightener. Although other reviews claim it's chalky and applies unevenly, I've had nothing but perfect application on my waterline. Very smooth and completely opaque. A great deal overall!
Haz from Miami Florida
Not for me I didn't like application
Chalky, streaky, unusable
Annastasia 6 from California
I got this product for my waterline. It is impossible to get opaque coverage, always streaky, always gets in your lashes and chunks up, with no lasting power. I feel personally wronged by this liner, save your self.
Love it 💜
Jenny from Florida
I love all the faux whites. I have this one,the pink
Do you like looking awake?
Maia from Boston
This is my favorite pencil to use in my water line to look less like a zombie no matter how badly I slept. The price is nice too!
No was not a god buy at all
Reddd from Jackson, TN
Was not a good product at all
Love the color, hate that it can't be sharpened!
ErinJ from PA
I love the color but it's not retractable or able to be sharpened. So I used it less than 5 times and it needs sharpened but it can't be because of the plastic tip! Any suggestions? I really want to like it but it doesn't work!
Great colors and stays in place
IndieEnthusiast2020 from Milwaukee, WI
Beautiful, creamy colors that go on smoothly and have serious lasting power.
Al from Arkansas
I love the linen, though it's more like a pale pink than a true linen. I'll be purchasing other colors nonetheless. It has respectable lasting power for a waterline pencil. While the softeness can be annoying when sharpening, it makes it easier to apply, so I don't mind.
Tracey from Vermont
colors are fine for the waterline but I'm constantly sharpening them because the tips break everytime I use them.
I will look for vanilla everytime
Cherry from Birmingham, AL
Dressing up my eyes w/ my mask
Linen shade is perfection
Rach1029 from Ca
I LOVE this product. It really brightens your eye (use it on waterline) and has great staying power and goes on smoothly with no tagging. Not too bright at all, Linen is the perfect neutral shade and looks amazing with a gold shadow.
Caitlin from USA
Good quality--creamy and pigmented.
Performs well on the waterline
Saff from Chicago
I have the lavender shade, and I wear it on my waterline on my lighter eye look days. I have very sensitive/watery eyes, but this holds up pretty decently.
Great for brightening
Audrey G from Boston, MA
I love this eye pencil! I've been looking for a pencil for my waterline to make my eyes brighter and look a little bigger and this is it. The Linen shade is great and way better than a stark white pencil, which can look pretty harsh. I literally balled my eyes out the other day while wearing this is my waterline and it didn't budge. Overall I really like it and definitely want to buy some of the other shades!
Love these eyeliners will purchase again
Exotic Lioness from Atlanta
Slides on beautifully and long wear want all shades
Best light liners
Tonias84 from Sacramento
I have a lot of liners but these are the best whites. love that they come in a lot of color. They have plenty of staying power. Best long wear whites.