Rated 4.02 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Oxblood
Oxblood is a nice brick/dark red. It doesn't get very intense pigment wise, it stays kind of patchy unless set with a corresponding powder. Once I set it, though, it was hard to smear or even get off without remover! I'm pretty happy and it'll be a wonderful addition to my color collection.
Most Helpful Critical Review Color swatches are way off
I just purchased Blackberry, thinking it was going to be a deep mauve because of the photo that shows it, and it's completely not. The name is way more accurate than the photo because when I got my order, I thought I purchased the wrong shade. It's soooo much darker in person and it's more of a deep plum. It glides nicely and it seems it would work in my waterline pretty well but they need to step their search game up, because I'm disappointed that it looks nothing like the photo.
Reviewed by 251 customers Burnt Sienna
CatSeamus from New York City
The Burnt Sienna color is literally the most gorgeous brown/burgundy eyeliner I've ever tried. This is the only color eyeliner I buy "back ups" of as I'm afraid to run out. I have brown eyes and this particular color looks better than others.
4MinFL from FL
I was looking for a little more purple-black color. This is black-blue. It's nice even though not exactly what I wanted. Surprised with the price being so affordable it acts like a higher end brand name I usually use.
Great colors and stays in place
IndieEnthusiast2020 from Milwaukee, WI
Beautiful, rich colors that go on creamy and have serious lasting power. Great alternatives to black liner!
nice at first
Beli from NJ
I love the burnt sienna, however, once it needs sharpening, it keeps breaking so you keep sharpening, and then you realized it chewed up most of the liner. :(
I would not buy again because I asked a sales associate
Chipmunk from Snellville ga
No do not like
Great Formula, Color was... Unexpected.
Elle from Granger, IN
So I bought Burnt Sienna, I ordered online and was looking specifically for a really dark burgundy. Unfortunately, Burnt Sienna doesn't quite show up that color on my skintone. Granted, my skin tone is extremely pale, and colors show up on me differently. With that being said, its closer to a red brown in the light of my mirror (neutral or white&yellow lights) and in the sunlight it's a really pretty rust-brown/rust-orange color. I think for what I was looking for, I would have gotten closer to the desired color with Oxblood or Blackberry, or mixing the two together, which I plan on doing because I really like the formula, really smooth, really soft on the waterline, not insanely pigmented on the first swipe, but I prefer that because I can control the intensity of the color. It also holds on for dear life, I put it on and was immediately disappointed and when I went to wipe it off it didn't even move a little bit, so either have makeup remover close by for mistakes or be prepared to keep it all day. I will still use this shade, as a brown or I will sanitize it and give it to family.
LOVE it except the color SLIPS OUT OF ITS CASING
melt774 from Hanford, CA
I bought two of these pencils and love the colors and how they stay on but aren't impossible to review. I'm giving it two stars because I can't use it when the eyeliner color slips out of the wood "pencil" casing. It happened to one and I exchanged it and that one has been fine, then it happened to the other one. It happens when it's very new.
I love this eyeliner! It's perfect!
Cindi from Lebanon, OH
I use this eyeliner daily on my eyes. It's very smooth and lasts a long time. This line has great colors too. I have been using this brand for several years now.
Smooth & staying!
WiLin from Eau Claire WI
Extremely pleased with both olive & sienna liners. They apply very beautifully. Haven't worn black liner for years, too harsh for my fair skin & white hair. Normally apply an eyeshadow w/angled brush for my liner. These blend very well on both upper & water line. For reference, fair/light skin, white hair. Like I can add some "interest" to my eyes without being too harsh. Color has staying power. Will order again.
Step from TX
I got oxblood and the color itself is beautiful but is a bright red that doesn't really suit me
Fantastic value for the money!
Celia from Carlsbad, CA
I love the color called midnight, a dark navy blue. Fabulous. Highly pigmented and long lasting and goes with everything.
Drama Rose from Los Angeles CA
Works for me! I put this midnight eyeliner over my bright blue to give it a darker blue look. I love the matte texture.
Knenah from Alaska
Looked like a nice colour, however. There was no tip once I opened the plastic seal. I returned it to the store.
I Love this Pencil!
Darcie from Utah
I love this pencil! The color is beautiful and rich. It goes on like a dream, and the price is fantastic. A super great value!
Heather from Columbus, GA
I love this eyeliner! It enhances my green eyes, goes on smooth and doesn't run or smear during my 16 hour day.
Transfer and fade too soon
RK from Kahului
Transfer and fade too soon
LOVE THIS EYELINER
Pink Girl from FLORIDA
So many greats shades to chose from - NYX is the only makeup that I use. Love it!!!!
product is okay ... wish they had testers
suzyq from AZ
product stays on; although the pencil is not as thin as I would like
Steph89E from undisclosed
Got the dark red, really love it for making rosy pink or copper eyes look more dramatic. My skin is pale with a Very pink undertone and this doesn't make me look sick. Glides on very easily too.
found some gems
STke from hungary
these pencils are a bit too soft in texture, so it is not easy to get a sharp line, and to have a pointed end is almost impossible w/o erasing it back. but hear me out! this is not what this is for. because it is soft, it is really easy to work with in the waterline and the lower lashline (or even in a smokey liner way on the lid), and after it sets, the staying power is really strong. and the colors what i have are really something else. i love reddish tones, but those are hard to find. so i know i'm gonna be repurchasing these again and again.
Lacy from us
Creamy, easy to use, highly pigmented and stays put! No crumble, flake or smear.
Love the color for my hazel eyes
Deliam from New Jersey
This eyeliner has a really nice deep plum shade
Breaks off easily
Marti from Paso Robles
Such a great color
melguil from Lafayette, La
I wanted a darker color than my copper eyeliner that I wear during the day but am so tired of the boring, old black or brown. This is perfect! I have it in the olive color and the sienna color and absolutely love them both. They go so well with every eyeshadow palette I have (mostly peaches, reds and browns.) They bring out my bluish green eyes and look great during the day while running errands or at night while on a date. They go on smoothly and last a while. They aren't the best that I've tried but are the best drugstore liners that I have tried.
NYX Eye Pencils are the BEST!
Teri from Scottsdale AZ
I love the faux blacks. They go on soft, blend able and work well for soft smokey looks