Rated 4.04 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great for Everyday lashes
I would like to start by saying I recieved this product free for testing purposes, but all opinions are my own. First off, I have short stubby lashes but I this mascara helped me out with my struggle. I like the formula of this mascara and it is very good for a store brand. My favorite part of it is the brush, It's great for stretching out those short stubby lashes and making them feel luxurious. This has become my everyday mascara.
Most Helpful Critical Review Meh
First of all, I love this brush. It's perfect for the lengthening effect I always want and is even better when you layer mascaras to get out clumps. However, I'm hesitant to use this mascara because it smears beneath my eyes. Usually in the under eye area throughout the day while wearing this, I'll see dark smudges. They're not opaque or anything, which actually kinda makes it worse because it doesn't even look like mascara, it just looks like undereye darkness.
Also, that waterproof claim. It's just a straight up lie. It's not any more water proof than any other non-waterproof mascara I own.
Love the wand. Just wish the formula was better :(
Reviewed by 75 customers Perfect
Karina from NY
I only used one coat and I saw the difference!
I would purchased this item again.
Shelly from Folsom
I love how the brush works on my lashes.
Best mascara for stubborn eyelashes
MVL from Southern California
I have the hardest time finding a mascara that will keep my eyelashes curled and that won't flake off BUT this one does an amazing job at keeping my eyelashes curled & separated and won't flake off.
AT04 from Minneapolis, MN
I usually invest in higher-end mascara. But, I like to have a drugstore one on hand, as well. This is my new cheap option! I love the curved comb brush and I'm so impressed at how well it separates my short Asian lashes. I use the Lancôme primer first and then a heated lash curler before applying this mascara. It really fans out my lashes and lifts them to keep the curl. For a drugstore brand, this is definitely a winner.
My Ride or Die
Lula from California
This is definitely my favorite mascara. The wand allows me to darken my eyelashes without forming any spider legs which was really difficult with thickly bristled wands. When it comes to curl, It doesn't make much of a difference on it's own, so I I would suggest using it after using a lash curler. I don't think I would call it waterproof, but if it's for all day wear and you know you won't be sweating, it will be fine. I think my only complaint is that after a while the formula clumps a bit, and warming up the tube wasn't able to get rid of those clumps. That only happened with my first bottle though. I am a college student (for age reference) and I only apply makeup maybe a total of 7 days out of a month (for after effect reference).
Mel from Michigan
Been buying these since 2016. The only mascara that actually holds a curl and separates my lashes. I need to use this mascara as a base before I put on my other mascara because I have really long straight lashes that don't hold a curl unless I use waterproof mascara as a base.
TeresaM from Colorado
Daily use, love the wand which seems to be the best applicator for length and fullness without clumps!
CatAttack from California
I used to love this mascara. It separates my lashes beautifully and makes them look so much longer! Unfortunately, it smudges on me like crazy! After just an hour, I'll have raccoon eyes, which is something I wouldn't expect from a waterproof mascara... What a deal breaker. :(
Holy Grail Mascara for Asian Lashes!
cz from Chicago
I have short, straight Asian eyelashes and this is the best mascara for fanning them out and adding length. I always use waterproof mascara so I'm used the removal process. This one keeps my curl all day and only barely smudges on my super oily skin (everything smudges on me). The comb shaped brush is GENIUS and way better for my short lashes than a traditional bristled brush bc it grabs every single lash, even the tiny inner corner ones.
Lost in the Sauce from Owings Mills, Maryland
I bought this product because it was very highly reviewed, but honestly this is the WORST mascara I've ever tried. The brush, if you can call it that, is useless and does nothing to help add volume to my lashes. The formula clumps and is sticky. It is also extremely difficult to remove. I feel like I actually lost lashes from using this product... save your lashes!
Coolpnut from Tulsa,OK
Use all the time
A must have!
Kellykells234 from Manchester Connecticut
I usually use this for my bottom lashes because it's the least messy mascara I have. I've bought this 3 times already!
I might buy it again
kylee from not saying
I love this product since it makes my eyelashes look longer. The only thing I wish from this product is that it would make my eyelashes thicker. I probably won't get the waterproof again since its very hard to take off. But if you want waterproof its very long lasting.
Absolutely love it!
Jess from Seattle
This mascara goes on so smooth and really actually lifts my lashes and made them so long and sexy with out clumping! This is my new favorite, seriously.....
A magic uplifting mascara! Love this product!
Italian Princess from Hanover, PA
This product offers excellent lift of lashes and buildable coverage.
As good as high end
Goodview from Los angeles
I have been looking for water prove mascara this not only works but I can use it as tight liner
I love it
BadB from Glendale, Az
I love the handle. It never clumps or runs
great curl and hold!!!
reddy from Los angels
A lot of mascara does not give me the curl I want. A lot of them also make my lashes hit my under eye area and transfer. BUT this one is a miracle, it does not transfer at all. It's not very voluminous but I'm not that greedy.
The brush alone makes this worth the money.
Aya from Holloman AFB, NM
I love using this for simple days, because while waterproof it is not voluminous. But! I also love going over my Superhero mascara from It Cosmetics with this because this is the best wand ever! And it helps add protection to the other mascara. Will purchase again.
the best thing ever invented
kiersten from San Antonio, TX
This mascara is honestly amazing. On it's own, it's good, but it's best as a layer on top of other mascaras. If you have super straight lashes that won't hold a curl, this is the answer to all of your problems. It thickens my lashes at the roots, then lengthens the tips. I usually use it layered over maybelline lash sensational, and it's the best mascara combo of life. I'll never use anything else. My only qualm with it is that removal is a bit of a struggle, but it is possible. 10/10 recommend this underrated mascara.
Something Im Getting Used To
Chanel from Bronx, NY
I like this product only thing is that the brush isn't what I would really use I like a fuller brush when i am putting on mascara but it is really nice
For length on thin, straight lashes
Pookie from St. Paul, MN
The BEST mascara for those with little to no lashes. The comb is able to get in all corners and holds curl very well. This is more for lengthening. You can build it up to create volume. Best part is it will NEVER clump! My holy grail!
Not for me
Terri from Canton, New York
I bought this because it had pretty good reviews. With a name like "falsies" I expected some pretty good volume or length and got neither. The brush is very unique, I was excited to try it, but it ended up being nothing special.
Best Mascara- EVER
Sierra from West Virginia
I'm definitely a lash type of person, my makeup isn't complete without two to three layers of mascara. With this, I only need the first initial coat. My only issue is getting it off. I have to use special waterproof eye makeup remover by Almay (they're like little oil pads) which means this mascara is a little troublesome for my routine- but totally worth it. My lashes have never been so defined and lengthened
Looks like false lashes
Abbie from North Carolina
This mascara is amazing I love the way it makes my lashes look almost like they're fake (but not in a bad way : ) the only kinda bad thing is it does clump