Product Reviews Rated 3.55 out of 5 stars
51 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review very unique eyeliner shades I have to say some of these shades are very unique and I can't find shades like these. I got teddy which is a dusty mauve type color and I got cloud wine which is a really pretty burgundy color. these are very smooth and easily glide on. They are very pigmented and don't take alot to show up on the lid. I've used it both on my waterline and top lid. I wear alot of pinks, browns, mauves, champagnes and golds (some of the eyeshadow palettes I use regularly are natasha denona gold palette, dose of colors friendication palette, Laura lee los Angeles nudie patootie palette, Charlotte tilbury pillowtalk luxury palette, huda beauty new nudes palettes and tartes toasted tartlet, in bloom, and face play palettes, and Dominique cosmetics berries and cream palette and these eyeliners go so nicely with all of them. I need to get more shades like the blue shade and the liquid gel liners to go with them but the two I have (teddy and cloud wine) have really matched well with the palettes I have. I love wearing teddy on my waterline , it reminds me of a darker nude type color. I'm not sure about how much product is in these but I would repurchase them as soon as they ran out because I can't live without them.
Most Helpful Critical Review Just didn't work out for me... I wanted to give this a fair chance, this is the first Dose of Colors product I've bought. I have oily lids and most eyeliners smudges & transfers on me, this wasn't any different. I appreciate the concept, has the little sharpener on the end. I got the dark brown shade, the formula was too stiff for me & for the price you pay, there's not a lot of product. So having to sharpen it, you're wasting even more product. Just not for me.
Reviewed by 51 customers Dose of Color should be ASHAMED OF THEMSELVES! 1
Dreamy from Atlanta ga
Tiny tiny tiny liner stick that breaks the second it touches your eye. You might get a weeks worth out of it but it will be a struggle. I'm so aggravated if not angered that I spent money on all colors excited about the very thin line it would make. Total waste and money down the tubes!
Will keep repurchasing 5
beauty lover from Fresno, CA
This is the best eyeliner I've used! I've been through highs & lows searching for an eyeliner that doesn't smudge, pigmented, & doesn't have to use a lot of effort to put on- & this one is IT. I tried all the ones beauty gurus recommended (NARS, MAC, Clinique, Milani, Revlon, etc.. )but nothing works as well as this one for my oily skin. I keep coming back to this one. This is my second purchase & will continue repurchasing.
Glides on like butter! 5
Beth M from Dallas, TX
Smooth application. Doesn't "stutter" like other eye pencil liners. Dark pigment so fills in nicely around lashes.
Best eyeliner I've found 5
Jenn from California
I've bought this eye liner a few times, and keep going back to it. It lasts a long time, and once you put it on you don't have to reapply.
good color; too dry for eyelids 3
LTen from Knoxville, TN
This was exactly the color I wanted, but it is so dry and hard it's difficult to get a good line on eyelids. A shame!
Dry and crumbly 2
NJSteph from New Jersey
This liner was not even great at the start. The tip broke off after one week. And after a few weeks I had to throw it away it was so dry it hurt my eye lid.
If you can get it on, it does have staying power.
I won't buy this again 2
Deborah from Mission Viejo, CA
This was touted as a "long lasting", "transfer resistant" liner. It stayed put on my eyelid, however it was gone and smudged under my eye in a matter of hours.
Not worth it 2
A... from LA
It's very dry right out of the package and because of this it breaks off in pieces and is not a smooth application. It doesn't stay put and has a tendency to smudge. Can't use on the waterline. Wouldn't buy again.
SOC of color eyeliner, color - LUCKY 2
beach lover from Colorado
Very little product in tube, not GOOD!!
breaks off in pieces 3
Jenny from Augusta
Great color, stays in place a long time, but when I very gently placed the sharpener on the tip, it broke off a good bit of it. I love Dose of Colors, especially the foundation, but this one didn't do it for me.
Breaks off every time I try to use it 1
None from NY
This eyeliner is horrible! I have to press so hard to get the color, and then the tip falls off 😡
Will keep buying 4
KW from Chino, CA
Love how it goes on- thin/smooth nice color. Runs out faster than I would like...
Great Eyeliner 5
Kay from California
I am in love with these eyeliners! The colors are bold and they last all day. I have been searching for quality eyeliners for awhile and I'm so happy I found the ones from Dose of Colors. I purchased one of every color.
Not worth it 3
Katherine from NJ
I used it once, the second time I used it (a week later) it kept crumbling off. 75% of the product broke off in pieces in front of me. it dries off way too quick which causes it to break. i don't think its worth it
Ran out almost immediately 1
Holly design from Orange County, California
In all the years of buying eyeliner, I have never had a pencil run out as fast as this one.
Total ripoff.
Great at first... 3
Angel from Philadelphia
I had been looking for a good red eyeliner to smudge out and this worked great for the first month or so...!!! But as other reviews said it does dry out to the point of cracking which is so disappointing because the color really great... sadly won't be repurchasing...
Dries out within a few months 3
Pamela from Fort Worth
Colors and original formula are good but I spent a lot of money when these came out for these as well as a few lipliners and they are all so dried and hard they do not work anymore. Ive never had this problem with any other pencils. Def dont waste your money unless you can go through it in a month.
Great find 5
Christine from Lansing, Michigan
Love this color and staying power. Thankful to find this aisle. Wish the products were in a better location for discovery. 💗
I have bought this product again 5
Niagirl007 from Coastal Virginia
I don't feel dressed without eyeliner, mascara and earrings. This is the best eyeliner I have tried in years and the price is right too. I have spent almost double the price for inferior eyeliners. Good pigment, easy to create a smooth line and stays put, doesn't smear or run.
A little sad about this.. 3
Thelma from WA
I LOVE LOVE LOVE dose of colors BUT disappointed in their eyeliners. I gave it three stars because it glides on smoothly and the color is beautiful when applied but it absolutely has no staying power. In an hour, my bottom lash application disappears. Then about 5 hours-ish, it looks like I slept in it al night and didn't clean off my makeup before I left the house.
Nice Color; No Staying Power 2
Ayatlaw from New York
I wanted to give this eyeliner a shot since the colors are so unique. For reference I do not have oily eyelids and my skin leans more combo dry. This eyeliner glided on no problem but had no staying power in the waterline. 4 hours later it had smudged underneath my eye, disappeared from my entire waterline and ruined my whole makeup look. I would avoid this product.
I would buy liner again in other colors 5
None from San Jose CA
Goes on smoothly. Easy to sharpen liner.
Love! 5
Lovejones from NJ
This is a great eyeliner. I use eyeliner on my waterline and it saturated the color well, and it lasts all day on my waterline with no irritation. I used to love another brand, Sumita which changed its formula/hard to find and nothing has replaced it for me until I found this. Loveeee
I would buy this product again 4
Kim the fashinista from Birdsboro pa
This liner stays on for a long time but still comes off easy when u take it off
I wasted my money 1
Glamourmom from Ohio
I loved dose of colors eyeshadow palettes but the eyeliners totally fails me. They dry not creamy and they kept breaking off. I will not recommend dose of colors eyeliners.
