Product Reviews Rated 3.52 out of 5 stars
364 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner pen i've ever tried! I was searching for that one perfect liner for a while, tried different brands and forms (pencil, gel, and liquid). Was really surprised when i came to this perfect buddy in ULTA, when i tried it, i fell in love right away with it. What's not to love? It's smudgeproof(stays on the whole day!), goes really smooth. Only cons i can think about is that it's not waterproof..
Most Helpful Critical Review Not impressed. I'm just glad I have lots of experience with stubborn eye liner products. There is not enough product being released by the pen. It dries up midapplication. The color isn't very bold. It gets clumpy when you try to get a defined line therefore you need to keep building and wiping to get a good line and it's only going to be a thick one.
Only benefit
It's cheap
Save your $ for another product
Reviewed by 364 customers I wouldn't buy this again 1
Bella from Westminster, Co
This isn't a good eyeliner, I wanted to find a new great eyeliner I could stick with and this one is not it at all. I also bought the waterproof one and I was disappointed in both of them. If I could return them I would. I wouldn't recommend to anyone.
Hands down a Good product but not Great 3
Angie from Houston TX
I personally love this product, not very pigmented but it does the job for shaping your eyeliner how you want. Recommend for people barely starting out winged eyeliner.
Let me help a gal out - BUY IT 5
Alex from California
I love this eyeliner so much. I used to use the Stila eyeliner but it wasn't the cheapest. For someone who does makeup for social media, I am constantly getting new products and staples like black eyeliner isn't worth spending so much money on. It goes on smoothly and the tip is GREAT for wings
Don't recommend 1
Mali from USA
I don't recommend I ordered deep black and it's sooo bad it's like water paint and gray liquidy
Good liner pen! 5
Coconut from Euless, tx
This is quick and easy to use. It stays on until I take it off. It's more of a soft black, which is what I like, not harsh or bold. Good for everyday look and great price!
Must have! 5
Mandy from Painesville, Ohio
when choosing eyeliner I favor the felt tip but with those you tend to strike out due to lack of pigment when applied, or lasting quality when wearing. I can honestly say I've tried dozens of felt tip eyeliners and have only had luck with a few at $25-$30 a pop. Thought I'd give this a try because of the price point and let me tell you this is better than even some of the $25 brands I've bought! I couldn't believe it! Glide on smooth and the pigment is so rich! I have had zero problems with smudging or fading! BUY THIS EYELINER!
You get what you pay for 1
Neina from Los Angeles
Bought this eyeliner because it was cheap but i should've just spent a couple more bucks for a better eyeliner. It dries out so quickly and there's really no way to get more product out. Definitely a waste of money.
You get what you pay for 1
Marisa from Lansing MI
Very little coverage; I had to reapply over the top of my line about three times. Gets patchy/wears off within a couple hours, even with an eyelid primer. I did like the applicator tip but I wouldn't repurchase. The Elf eyeliner pen is better in this price range.
Meh 2
KD from Reno, NV
Considering how much I love this brand's mascaras, I thought I'd really like this eyeliner. But I don't. The coverage just isn't there; I can still see my skin underneath where I just applied the product. The pigment is grey rather than black, and if I try to darken it, it becomes a smeared mess. So I let it dry for a bit and go back and fill in the goofy spots with the side of the pen...kind of blotting it along the lash line. It's pretty dumb. lol I'd be really annoyed if I had spend a lot of money on this product. The waterproof version of this is better, but not by much. Won't purchase again.
Not bold / Watery 1
Fadedheart89 from Los Angeles
I do not recommend this Eyeliner, it is a very dull black I had to go over it with another Eyeliner.
I love this eye liner! 5
A Has from NM
The fine tip makes the liver versatile because you can build it up to your desired thickness
Perfect 5
ataylor26 from CA
Works great, color is very deep a d lasts.
Awesome 5
Diana from La Puente, CA
It's so easy to use
Wow 5
Christine from Leesburg Florida
This eyeliner is great. It applies nicely and looks great all day.
ehh 1
gina from bucks
it was a washed out black color
Leave this one in the store 1
Make-up user from Fresno, Ca
As I said, not good for more than 1 hour. Then it goes bad
Not very good 1
Debbie from Omaha, NE
You get what you pay for, the tip is very rigid, not easy to use. Going back to Smashbox Maneater liquid liner.
Horrible 3
X from PA
I got this product as part of a buy one get one half off deal. I used it the first two times, no problem. The formula is long lasting, doesn't really smudge however after the second time using it, it began to get HORRIBLY streaky. Everytime I wear it now it does not apply evenly, you can see the streaks. I end up having to wipe it off and redo it multiple times. You cannot go back in and touch up a spot because the felt tip ends up rubbing off the rest of the eyeliner already on your eyelid and makes it even more frustrating. I would not buy this ever again.
I would buy this product again. 5
Maxine from Albuquerque, NM
Loved this eyeliner.
Love Essence, but not this eyeliner 1
Em from Pennsylvania
Was not impressed. Stopped working after just one use. Bought another just in case the one I had was bad but the other was equally useless. Would not recommend
Go-To Eyeliner 5
JavaLover from Georgetown, Texas
This has become my go-to eyeliner when I don't want to use a liquid eyeliner.
It lasts all day (10+ hr shift) and rarely needs a touch up if I'm going out after.
Glides on smoothly, bold color (no need for a 2nd coat if you will), and the tip is perfect for a precise cat eye, which is my favorite look.
Definitely buying again :)
I would but this product again and again 5
Fancy Nancy from Austin TX
Great price and great product
It's sticky! 3
pnknghtmr from Huntington Park, CA
The price is very reasonable. I like how it applies to the eyelid; once it dries, it sticks to the top of my eyelid. So to avoid that to happen I have to apply powder. Sometimes the pen dries out too so I have more than one pen to alternate. Other than that, I love how black it is. Other liners turn gray.
Wasted money 1
Brenda from San Antonio tx
Waste money
Can't believe this is this good! 5
It's all Peachy from Atlanta, GA
Wow, finding a decent black eyeliner is tough. It's dark enough to show up on my melanin skin and it doesn't feather out once I apply. So works so well that I may replace my Stila Stay In Place eyeliner. It is not smudge proof though so if you touch your eyes a lot, you may not be impressed.
