Rated 3.2 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review very satisfied
hm... I am surprised to see that this product has such a low rating as it works just perfect for me. Which just proves that we all are very individual. I have a very oily skin and hooded eyes and usually any eyeliner would smudge and transfer but it totally doesn`t happen with this one which feels like a miracle. Yet it`s light and not cakey, it`s line is smth between being totally matte and wet-shiny which is also perfect to me. Not super pigmented which also is just like I wanted as heavy dark wings look not good on hooded eyes like mine. And it`s so easy to apply even for somebody who knows nothing about applying wings — like me. It`s definitely not waterproof, but somehow stays the whole day on my oily eyelids which I highly appreciate. I will definitely keep buying it, especially for this price. And it seems to last long as I have been using this one tube for month now. Very satisfied, thank you for this product!
Most Helpful Critical Review I would buy this again if it didn't stop working
I loved this eyeliner so much! I used it to make hair strokes in the front of my brows and it worked perfectly! It lasted all day and never wore off! The second time I tried to use it the tip of the liner was dried out and wouldn't work unless you used the side of it... I kept the cap on so it's not like it dried out or anything... really wish this lasted me more than one use because I really enjoyed this product...
Reviewed by 50 customers okay eyeliner, but i use it for faux freckles
em from florida
i have beauty marks and freckles that i love but get covered by foundation, so i use this to put them back without it looking to instense. i tap it out but it always looks natural. the eyeliner itself has not a lot of staying power on my oily, hooded eyes, but i knew that from the start
Blue liner, price is right!
Nichole from San Diego, CA
I bought this during Covid quarantine and the age of having to wear masks! I bought a ton of colored eyeliner's since eyes are all we have right now! This one was my favorite because I liked the applicator tip, I prefer felt personally. Nicely pigmented for the price, recommend if you're looking for something fun and different right now at a good price point!
Great as a brow filler!
Adri from VA
hear me out... as a deep/dark-skinned woman, because this has a more watery consistency, it didn't show up as well I liked for an eyeliner. however I tried it as a brow outliner and filler and I love how it looks and feels. the colour fills the brows and is buildable, to make it as dark as you want without a waxy buildup. if you want it to be darker, store the pencil tip down, if you want it to be lighter on the brows (or eyes) store tip up.
Its brown and looks softer on eyes. Wish it was in waterproo
Bo from Frisco Tx
Susie from Aubrn
I would prefer something a little less liquidy.
Not as Big a fan as I thought
Cait from Indiana
Honestly i like the price of the product, but overall use and product quality is kinda a miss. You get what ya pay for I guess. Overall, for me personally I wouldn't buy this again.
Kyfan from Jensen Beach Florida
I LOVE Essence products. They are so reasonably priced. This eyeliner goes on smoothly & is very easy to apply.
I love this type of liner
Melissa from Ardmore, OK
I feel like I have been in the stone ages using other liners
Good quality - browns looks black
Melissa from NJ from Vineland, NJ
This pen went on super smooth and was so easy to apply. For the price, it is great. However, the brown looks almost like a matte black instead of an actual brown.
Don't Buy It!
Bella from Louisville Ky
The pencil was dried up and was of no use. A waste of money
kc from Norman, Oklahoma
Doesn't show up well on fair skin, but the main issue is streakiness and lack of pigmentation. Pen tip is also flimsy.
Raynebeaux from Harrisonburg
goes on thin. picks itself up if you go over it again. Very streaky
I will continue to buy...
MerryD from Denham Springs, LA
This eyeliner is the best I've tried. I haven't had any luck in the past with the liquid felt tips. It last all day for me. Not one negative thing I can think of. Please don't stop making it!
I would LOVE to see this in a dark navy blue.
Perfect for my cosplay
Kay the Cosplayer from Charlotte, NC
This is perfect for my Waluigi cosplay! I bought 5 eyeliners and this was most perfect. The others are all similar so they're gonna be used for other things. It's light enough and due to it being liquid, didn't smudge for me
Best Liner Ever
akuykendall1971 from Midlothian, TX
I love this eyeliner
I loved the price
Malawian Queen from Indiana
I loved the price point and since I love their mascara I thought I would try this. Well you get what you pay for. I loved the product for the first few times I used it, the color is amazing. After a few uses it does not go on with ease as the color is not even so you have to continue to go over the line multiple times. It would be great for traveling.
Long lasting and very precise!
Roni from Michigan
Love this but I bought the wrong color. Wish I could return for lighter tone.
Mumof5 from Dallas, TX
Essence are usually great products. When I swatched this in the store the payoff seemed great. Not so much on the eye though. Not as bright nor as pigmented as it first looked.
Thank You, Essence!
PinkToxicity from Chicago, IL
Thank You Essence for this color! I wish it also came in an even Lighter Brown. Such a great eyeliner. Such smooth application. It's lasts & lasts, I just wish it was Waterproof.
not so great
goofygator from lancaster sc
it is very hard to put on. too much pressure
This is my daily driver!
Adam from Wisconsin
I found this product through a beauty influencer about a year ago and have been very happy with it. This is a repurchase.
i would buy this product again, i love it.
nellie from santa Maria
i use this for everyday use in the morning last all day, or even an evening look.
JK from Hoover, Al
Way better than I thought it would be. I have hooded eyelids and it doesn't transfer or smudge. It stays put and is beautiful. I will be returning to buy it in every color.
Mickey The Budget Makeup Queen from Oceanside, CA
I've been wanting a liquid brown eyeliner and I thought this looked great with the felt pointed tip. However the liquid dries out after only lining one eye. I literally have to lick the tip to try and get some sort of flow going again. This is a purchase were you get what you pay for I guess. Cheap price. Cheap quality.
doesnt show up on my face but it does on my hand?
miranda shae from salem, or
never worked, ran out before i got to use it