Product Reviews Rated 4.15 out of 5 stars
480 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great product but colors need work I originally bought this in Auburn because, being a redhead, I'm usually Auburn on most brow products. I got home and the Auburn was pumpkin orange! Definitely not the color I was expecting. I knew I would like the product if I had the right color so I exchanged it for soft brown. That color definitely works for me better. I think they need to add more variety in color selection but the product works really well and the price is great!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great pencil but unable to sharpen it The color is just what I was looking for. The application was easy and the line held up well throughout the day. However, when I tried to sharpen the pencil the crayon part broke repeatedly. Help!
Reviewed by 480 customers Yes this product does the job 3
Bree from Sterling Heights ,Michigan
Soft easy to apply
natural color
I liked this so much I bought another in a different color. 5
Glam Gran from TX
Really like the creamy texture, color, coverage and the quality for a great price.
I love it! 5
Donna from Oklahoma
This pencil is the perfect shade for my hair, and has good staying power
Ash Brown is Rusty Brown 1
KaitM from Redwood City CA
I was happy to find this online and available at Ulta. It's so hard to find an Ash Brown pencil. Unfortunately, this is NOT Ash Brown. It's a Rust color and unflattering.
Not Ash Brown, Reddish Brown 1
KaitM from San Francisco, CA
I really wanted a pencil, not a twist-up or a gel. Was thrilled to find this online. Unfortunately, it's nowhere near Ash Brown. It's got a rust tone to it.
My favorite pencil 5
Francine from The Great Northwest
This is my favorite because I can sharpen it myself and it lasts for several months as opposed to the twist ups that break off and last for less than a month for $28.
Absolute favorite 5
Em from Herriman, UT
I've tried so many different things for my brows. This is my absolute favorite. Looks natural and long lasting.
Did not like the color or the brush 1
Shar from Pittsburgh
I have red hair and chose the color that should have worked; but the color was terrible
LOVEEEEE 5
Bianka from Statesboro, Ga
Made doing eyebrows super easy and fast!!!! And love the color and how blend-able it is!
I will buy this again 5
KC from Berea KY
Goes on smooth and Great product
Brow boost 5
Dconroy from Pennsylvania
No talc
My new go-to eyebrow pencil 5
Audrianne from Dallas/Fort Worth
I had used a high-end brow pencil for years and was not happy when it was discontinued. After trying several, I really like this one - it creates a natural brow (powder vs waxy consistency) and it's a great value.
Love it! 5
Donna Liberatore from OK
It matches very well with my hair. I've had a hard time finding an eyebrow pencil that would be a good match, but this is the one!
Only giving 3 stars because ... 3
Lyric from Sacramento
I love these eyebrow pencils ! They are awesome but a little hard to sharpen :/ the reason i gave three stars was because they sent me two different colors I ordered two blonde pencils and got one blonde and one taupe it was weird but okay.
My fav 5
D.deRuiter from Detroit, MI
Great light neutral color. No red
Quick and easy brow touch up 4
Mischa NU from NY state
This is very easy to use! I thought I would try it because I love the powder brow kit, and I thought a powder pencil might be great for travel— if we ever get to do that again, lol. Anyway, it has a lovely texture and perfect taupe color, and is easy to use. Like it a lot.
Love the brush 5
Kimberly from KANSAS City, Missouri
The brush on the end is a great bonus feature. Love that you are able to sharpen the pencil. Easy to apply.
BEST BROW PENCIL EVER! 5
NAWNSTAR from undisclosed
Perfect color, lasts long and the brush helps one stop application
The best eyebrow pencil I have ever used. 4
Fran L from Ronkonkoma, NY
Love it except for one problem. When I get about 2/3 down there isn't any more "lead"in the pencil. Granted this doesn't happen all the time, but enough times to really annoy me and kind of makes me feel a little cheated.
Great Shading!!! 3
Seante from Orlando, Fl
I love the way it blends perfectly with my eyebrows
The best eyebrow pencil I've ever used 5
Dyan from Maine
Since pencils became twist-up I've found it harder to find trad (longer-lasting) eyebow pencils. I found NYX recently and this velvety powder pencil is the best I've ever used. The taupe is perfect for my dirty blonde hair and pale-ish complexion, my brows looking softly drawn and natural.
The only brow product I use 5
Joi from Phoenix
Ive been using this eyebrow pencil for yearsssss. Its really easy to use, pigmented its not waxy. And its very affordable. You can either use a light hand and make your brows look more natural or go into a little more intensely for a more bold look and its stay all day
I always buy this pencil. Love it 5
Pami from Illinois
Goes on my eyebrows very smooth and natural looking
Powdery pencil 4
Asian sensation from Wauwatosa, Wi
I have found this product works well in filling in my sparse eyebrows. I like the powderlike application and quick ease of using a pencil liner, no mess like liquid ones. I only wish it lasted as long as liquid based applications do.
Great Brow Pencil 5
The Cosmetic Ninja from Chicago
I was looking for a pencil brow product that was easy to use, and had some staying power. Check and check. Several years ago a pro makeup brand sold a powder pencil, but I think they discontinued it. My brow length bangs + hair product like to rub off my brows , and surprisingly this stayed pretty well! You may find a longer wearing product, but it's pretty fabulous!
