Product Reviews Rated 2.46 out of 5 stars
156 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Professional Results With the New Formulation I also was disappointed with the "new & improved" brow formulation...which was too greasy, woudn't go on or stay on...So I screamed my head off like everyone else and Laura listened...the new brow pencil is just as good as the original formula one...I love the ash blonde...it is a camilleon color...unless the client has very dark brown or black brown...it goes on everyone! It is in all my makeup cases...it is my "Go To"! Thank you for listening and reinstating the original formula!
Most Helpful Critical Review PLEASE!!!!! Bring Back The Triangular Pencil Formula! I, like many others, do not care for this pencil the way it is now. I lovedddddddddd the other one and used it for years....was my fave product......now.......not at all. I cannot say enough good things about the other one. This new one is terribly inferior. Shade is off, it does not apply easily, and wears off in time. Please bring back the old version....do you read these comments or not? Why ask us for feedback if there is no response???? Still waiting......
Reviewed by 156 customers Perfect! 5
TX Frenchie from Dallas
Blends in flawlessly with my own eyebrows and fills in the the sparse areas. The color is perfect, stays all day. I cannot live without this product!
I love this pencil!!! 5
Lisa from New Jersey
I have been using the IT Cosmetics gel brow pencil for years. As I have gotten older, my brows have lost a lot of volume in the brow tails. The It cosmetics gel pencil was the ONLY one that would stay on all day - and they discontinued it!! I was sure I would never find another good pencil that would stay on. I went to Ulta and an associate directed me to the Laura Mercier brow pencil. I love it! I like it even better than the IT pencil that was discontinued.
Long lasting and great color 5
anonymous from Clearwater, FL
The pencil does not pull on the skin and the color is perfect for me. I have gray hair and this is very natural looking.
AWESOME PENCIL 5
anonymous from WHITING NJ
THIS PENCIL GLIDES ON AND DOES NOT FEEL CAKEY OR WAXY. I LOVE IT AND WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND IT. I BOUGHT THIS ON THE RECOMMENDATION OF A FRIEND AND WILL DEFINITELY BUY IT AGAIN.
I Have BROWS again! 5
anonymous from Ocean County New Jersey
Love this brown pencil. Goes on. Stays on. Fills the sparse parts well.
Ash Blonde eye brow pencil 5
anonymous from Boynton Beach, Florida
this particular eye brow pencil is priced well for a long lasting one. It is versatyle as a color that is not only perfect for blondes but can be applied to many different colored brows and still look natural
Best eyebrow pencil! 5
anonymous from undisclosed
Best eyebrow pencil! Not too hard or too soft. Good colors! Tried them all.
Would purchase again 5
Tay from Apple Valley, CA
This brow pencil shows up easily and I love that it comes with a brow brush on the other end.
Perfect brow pencil 5
Dirty blond hair from United States
Love this pencil. It matches my dirty blond hair color perfectly. Goes on well and stays put.
Finally, the perfect color 4
Flaxen from Seattle
This is the perfect color for me...my hair is ash blonde with a little grey and my eyebrows are ashy with some dark grey. Most blonde pencils have too much orange or are too dark. This one is the perfect color match. I took off one star because it is soooo soft it requires sharpening almost every 2nd day to keep it very sharp and therefore I'll go through it quite quickly and it is an expensive product. However I highly recommend it and will purchase again.
Ash Brown eyebrow pencil 5
Janet Ft. Myers from undisclosed
I have been using this eyebrow pencil for many years. Easy to apply, natural looking color, and best of all stays on all day, even pretty much through a sweaty workout. I hope they never discontinue it. But I keep backups just in case!
Perfect eye blow pencil 5
Kawai from Long Beach Ca
I tried many eye blows pencils, all kind cheapest to most expensive.
This one is best for me very easy to use..
Only eyebrow pencil I trust! 5
anna37 from San Francisco, CA
I've been using this product for 5 years or so now and it is the only eyebrow pencil I've found that works for my strawberry blond hair. Every other reddish brown pencil comes out orange or way too dark, but this one is not orange and still works with my hair color. It comes on smooth and is easy to adjust for the proper darkness with the brush. Patiently waiting for a restock so I can replace mine!
Great product! 5
Tennis Gal from Dallas,TX
On my eyebrows
Eyeliner too 4
cindy from Illinois
I use this as eyeliner because it gives me a softer look like the old days. Not a heavy crayon look that everything is today.
Love this eyebrow pencil! 5
Cherami from Louisiana
I've used this brow pencil in Auburn for years and it's the best brow pencil on the market
Great shade! 5
AshersMom from Georgia
Goes on smoothly and when runs low, will definitely replace.
This is my absolute favourite eyebrow pencil! 5
Mummy Kat from Kent
I have tried numerous eye brow products but hands down this is me go-to. A traditional pencil but soft and blendable. Excellent brush on other end to blur to obvious lines.
Best eyebrow pencil ever 5
Jess38 from Kansas
Been using this product for over 10 years and it's hands down the best eyebrow pencil if you are wanting a very natural brow look. I use this pencil to fill in spots on my brows that are a little thin so they look more define. I'm a blonde and the blonde color pencil matches my brows perfectly! This products lasts all day and night.
Works for me! 5
AnninDC from DC
I'm surprised at the negative reviews on this pencil - I love it. One of the only dark blonde eyebrow pencils (I get the shade 'Blonde') that doesn't have orange in it! Hurray! It's best used when really sharp - but I haven't had problems with it breaking off. This will be my 4th one!
Bring back the old brow pencil!! 1
BrowlessinSanAntonio from San Antonio, TX
I don?t know what else can be said about how terrible the ?new and improved? pencil is! I reiterate: waxy, wrong color, top keeps falling off...all around horrible. I only have a nub of the old blond LM pencil and don?t know what I?ll do when it is used up?probably go browless. I only wish I had thought of returning the new pencil after I bought it like many of my fellow reviewers did. Laura Mercier?PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD BROW PENCIL!! It was perfection!
Bring back the old brow pencil!! 1
BrowlessinSanAntonio from San Antonio, TX
I don't know what else can be said about how terrible the "new and improved" pencil is! I reiterate: waxy, wrong color, top keeps falling off...all around horrible. I only have a nub of the old blond LM pencil and don't know what I'll do when it is used up—probably go browless. I only wish I had thought of returning the new pencil after I bought it like many of my fellow reviewers did. Laura Mercier—PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD BROW PENCIL!! It was perfection!
perfect 5
eyeb from Seattle
love this eyebrow pencil and its built in brush, I have sparse eyebrows and use this product every day. easier to travel with than the eyebrow powders that needs a separate brush. Long lasting and great color selection
Best eyebrow pencil! 5
Greenygirl from Los Angeles, ca
No other brow product compares. There is nothing like a good old fashioned brow pencil that lasts you more than a month, natural shades and perfect texture. Really adds some ummmf to your brows. Push up bra for your brows. Ha! I hope they never discontinue this pencil. Soft brunette is so perfect for anyones hair color, there is no red, not too dark, no weird green or yellow tones but just a lovely color that you'd actually want on your brows. Great job Laura mercier! And yes its waterproof, stays on all day, creamy but firm.
I love this product 5
anonymous from PA
I'm guessing they changed this formula, because the newer reviews are a lot better than the old ones. This is my go to eyebrow pencil. it stays on all day and it's easy to apply, very even.