Rated 3.17 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner
Favorite eyeliner by far! I have tried kat von d, stila, urban decay, and many more. This is the only one that I've repurchased. I love that its not too black like kat von d yet still very pigmented. I have had this liner for about 3 months and it still has color although it is close to needing a new one. The tip hasn't frayed like most either making a precise line so much easier and less frustrating. I feel like the tip is the perfect size as I don't like a thick line and this is buildable. It doesn't transfer to my water line which every other liner has done. Although I don't find it waterproof it stays on all day and is non-irritating to my very sensitive watery eyes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not for all day wear
I saw this in a "best of drugstore eyeliner" list and decided to buy it.
It applies really well and the ink is really pigmented. I really liked it at first.
I typically apply makeup around 8am. During work it performs fine but if I continue wearing it after 5pm (so 9 hours in) it starts to bleed and smear along my lid and brow bone.
I use a pretty heavy duty eye primer (lorac behind the scenes) so this really shouldn't happen.
This is a really beautiful and pigmented eyeliner that is easy to apply but I'm returning it because it does not last. It's a little embarrassing to go out after work only to notice blotchines all over my lids.
Reviewed by 63 customers Good eyeliner
Adri from Denver, Colorado
I love this eyeliner I've used it for years and just needed a new one. I was very excited to use it but I ended up dissatisfied because the eyeliner was just water. I had to go out and buy a new one.
not worth it
megan from pdx
full disclosure : i thought i was buying waterproof.
that said, I look like a panda in under 5 hours. and it dried out after 6 months where i used it bout 20 times.
Not So Waterproof!
Layla from Washington State
This has a thicker consistency in comparison to non-waterproof eyeliners. However. if I spray my face with finishing spray, this liner breaks up, and melts! I have to re-apply anytime I spray my face even mildly. Disappointed, and I won't repurchase.
One true love
Nikki from Bsl
I've bought Ulta brand, physicians formula, cover girl, maybeline, revlon, amongst many others. This is the one. I will never buy another brand.
Makeupnay from Fresno, CA
I'm very picky when it comes to eyeliner and this one doesn't disappoint. I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 because it isn't 24hrs like it claims but it does stay for me till the end of the day. I love how black it is and it's easy to make a wing because of the fine tip point. Will be re-purchasing.
Bri from Chicago
This used to be my go to eyeliner bc it stayed all day and I have oily lids and water eyes.
It was great but the formula must have changed bc it definitely does not stay all day and a simple swipe could smudge this... Very disappointing.
I also feel like they changed the tip, its now slightly rounded at the end so I don't get that sharp line like I used to.
I gotta find a new one I guess....
NOT VERY BLACK
Amber from Minnesota
Was very watery
SAVE YOUR MONEY, POOR QUALITY
Half and half from Bloomington, IN
Please save your money. The "ink" doesn't go all the way down through the tip so I can't get a good line. It is not long lasting due to having very little pigment. Normally enjoy Milani products but this eyeliner was disappointing.
Coco from Flagler beach
Not a makeup artist. Great tool!
Where is the old eye tech liquid liner with the shake ball?
KawaiiKara from Scottsdale AZ
I have been using Milani liquid eyeliner for years. It started with the Eye Tech that you shook with the ball that was in the "gold" casing, then it was just a black casing. Now it's completely gone??? That version was PERFECT! It didn't move or smear even after a 15 hour work day. I don't need an ergonomic handle- just bring back the original. This skinny long eye tech smudges and becomes a greasy mess on my monolid and on my outer bottom lid.
Laurel from Undisclosed
I like the color. It's not too shiny. It is not very waterproof/tearproof however. Easy to apply the brush hasn't frayed yet.
Dulce from Chicago
Easy glide. Super black. Easy to apply.
This product is terrible
Christig83 from San Diego
First couple uses, I liked this product. Went on easy and seemed to stay on pretty well. However, I started to notice i was having to go over multiple times as it began to streak. As I went over to reline, it would just flake off. I purposely saved the packaging and receipt for the first couple days to make sure I liked the product. Had i known a week later it would begin to be problematic, I would have taken it back. Do not recommend. Do not waste your money.
Waste of money
Busy mom of 4 from CA
Hoping it's just defective, but out of the package and it won't apply without a hard press on the back of my hand. Can't get it on my eye at all.
My new favorite eyeliner
Mia from San Diego, Ca
I love this eyeliner. It stays super nice and is VEGAN !! I really love this.
my go to
sara from colorado
love this eyeliner and it's priced great.
I'd buy this again
Kathryn from Undisclosed
It has good color and lasts mostly throughout the day, but it doesn't stay put if you were to rub your eye accidentally. For the price, it's amazing.
so buying this again
Nygerra from Undisclosed
Love this !!! Makes doing wings super easy , it last all day and is easy to remove
I definitely would buy this product again and again!
FRANCINE from Undisclosed
I use this eyeliner every day. It is easy to apply and gives me the look I want. Ordering on the website is super easy and the product arrived quickly.
Definitely getting used to
Bri from ohio
I'm used to suuuper fast drying eyeliners, so when this got on my top lid I was thoroughly shocked. It takes about 20 seconds to dry.
No weird smells or anything, which is good, though the tip is very thin. Makes very nice wings. Overall would buy again— good dupe.
Not at all waterproof
CB from SW High Desert
I bought this on a whim. I have been looking for an eyeliner that is easy to use and won't budge. The eyeliner is easy to apply and I love that. The problem is it does not last and transfers to my upper lid. I live in the SW high desert and it gets hot especially in the summer and late summer. I will continue to look for a inexpensive yet waterproof eyeliner.
laylact20 from Chicago, IL
I love it!
nikki from atlanta, ga
Love this eyeliner!
Iluveyeliner from USA
This smudged onto my upper eyelid! Did not stay put whatsoever. Maybe I received a bad one? I had heard this was "the" dupe for Kat Von D and I was very disappointed!
emmyp from United States
It's worn well when I've worn it but it's not a truly black liner. it also came off when I cried, but it doesn't claim to be waterproof as far as I'm aware. i just thought I should mention it.