Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review My new favorite eyeliner
I love this eyeliner! I received it as a sample through my birchbox subscription and it is my new go to eyeliner. It is like using a crayola marker to draw on eyeliner, it goes on very smoothly and is easy to get the line exactly how I want it. I'm definitely not a makeup expert so the fact that I can make a thick line and thin line perfectly with this one product is awesome. I only wish it came in other colors
Most Helpful Critical Review Good but not great
On first use, I was very satisfied. Jet black pigmentation that doesn't dry shiny and a tip that allows you to reach inbetween lashes.
But I've been using it for a few months and I'm not as satisfied. 1) Felt tip is inflexible which makes it difficult to create the wing on hooded lids. 2) Other brands have softer quality felt. 3) Product transfers onto upper lid area even after dry. 4) Product feathers along fine lines along inner corner and easily smudges by end of day. 5) If you're applying over eyeshadow, the wet tip absorbs the shadow and becomes dry. Barely any product comes out after. It's pretty handy that you can remove and flip the nib and it'll go back to a saturated application but who wants to get eyeliner all over their fingers that often?
If you think you have fixes for / can work with the abovementioned, go ahead and try it, it might work for you.
I'm not even halfway finished with it but I've already bought two new brands to try instead. I'll only use this for when I just need to run a quick errand.
Reviewed by 398 customers dry
LL from mokena, IL
this item was dry after opening, used 3 times them dried out
Momica from Cali
I received this in my boxycharm and ran out. Ordered another on here cause i loved it but doesn't work like the first one I got. I only swiped it one time and the applicator was dry.
StrangeFish from Indiana
I bought this recently and not even a full use it of it and the eyeliner has dried out. Should not be happening on a new line. Definitely will not buy again.
Do not buy
JD from San Marcos, CA
I received this dry. Had to run under water to get it started. Helped a lil but, long enough to get some on. Not waterproof at all and smears easy.
aly from USA
great eyeliner! i got it in a sample size a while ago and it doesn't smudge, color is solid, lasts a while and is one of my go-to eyeliners
Glides on easily
Kate Yesahappy from Ferndale, MI
This eyeliner is my absolute favorite liner. It glides on easily without the tip running dry. It is the perfect thickness for me as well.
When still wet, it is easy to clean up if you accidentally put it on too thick or you draw that cat eye a little differently than the other side.
When it dries, it stays put and looks great. I have oily skin, so it is really important to me to have a liner that stays put, and this one does the trick.
Taylor from South San Francisco
This product will not give you a cat eye. The applicator is big like a marker making it hard to control and impossible to reach the inner corner of the eye. The formula is streaky and not pigmented
Mandi from Hurst, Tx
Got this in my Ipsy and it's the best eyeliner I think I have ever had, I am about to buy them all! So easy to apply and such a dark rich black. I get a perfect line every time. No issues with smearing or fading.
Don't waste your money
Em from Youngstown, Ohio
Have nothing good to say. Smudged and faded almost instantly. Tried to reapply, wouldn't deposit any pigment. Moved everywhere.
Hannah from Albany, NY
I've never had a liquid liner work for me before. This one is beautiful. It goes on lovely, the packaging is great. The only con I have is as several other people said, it is NOT waterproof. I work in an office and this stuff will still melt down my face within 4 hours. Then you're left with dark rings and smudges. With that said, I still love this product and am going to try to retouch during the day to help combat the smudging. I do recommend this for sure. In fact, I gave my friend the trial size one I had from my Ipsy.
Hpost from Michigan
I received a sample and fell in love!! So naturally I went to go and buy a full size. It was horrible, dry, flakey!! Nothing at all compared to the sample.
Not super dark but good!
lindsay from philadelphia
I originally got an Eyeko liner in a Birchbox and immediately bought the full size - TWICE. I switched to the Eye Do to give it a shot and I just felt like it wasn't as pigmented as the skinny was but I'm still happy it with it so far. The BEST part for me is what others don't like - the tip is SOLID. I hate when the tips get too limp and it's impossible to get pigmentation and a straight wing. That's what this eyeliner does best.
Jen from Pittsburgh, PA
I received this through a subscription box. I was initially excited because this eyeliner applies beautifully with decent precision impressive pigmentation. Sadly, I wore it to work today and it has already smudged badly after 6 hours of wear. To make matters worse, I touched the corner of my eye and OMG THE MESS. I would seriously pass on this one. Go for Fenty or Kat Von D if you want a budge-proof product, or even Essence if you want a great eyeliner on a budget.
Not Worth it
Kate from Aurora, IL
I got this eyeliner in my Fab Fit Fun box. I'm not sure how this eyeliner has any good reviews. It claims to be waterproof and not to smudge, but it isn't waterproof and it totally smudges.
Glad I didn't pay for it.
Sarah from Atlanta, Ga
Got this in my FabFitFun box and I'm not a huge fan. The pigment is great. I don't like the tip because it isn't flexible and makes application a but tricky. And it gets EVERYWHERE. This stuff smudges like crazy. I thought maybe I didn't let it dry long enough so I tried again and waited longer. NOPE. I'm sad. I was hoping to find a new liner I love.
Not really waterproof
Hehe from Portland Oregon
I liked this eyeliner at first, it goes on easily and looks good but it smears if you get it wet. I wanted something more waterproof.
If I could give less stars I would.
Maia from Albuquerque NM
This product advertised as waterproof. I swatched a line on my hand, it feathered out on the lines. I dropped a bit of water and it rubbed completely off. Thought maybe I didn't let it dry enough so I tried again on a different part of my arm, let it sit a couple minutes. Still feathered out in the lines of my skin and still rubbed completely off. Highly disappointed.
Hannah S. from Denver
I've used this eyeliner in the past and it was great so I purchased again. This time it is absolutely terrible. It doesn't go on black, more like a very light grey, no matter if I push harder or shake it before use. It was a complete waste of money. I'll stick with Stila stay all day from now on.
Itsjustlinds from Florida
I def have mixed feelings about this product. I absolutely LOVE how smooth it goes on and how dark it is but don't care for the fact that it doesn't stay and takes some time to dry.
dried out too quick
BabyBlue from Houston, TX
I bought the full size after getting the travel size in Ipsy. It dried out in a week. I was sad because I loved the travel sized one.
Best eyeliner I've used!
Jamie from Chandler, AZ
I have gone through several eyeliners - drug store and high end: Smashbox, Stila, NYX, Maybelline, etc. Still, this is my absolute favorite of them all! I love the tip, it glides on smoothly, and stays all day! I keep getting them in my Ipsy bags and I am not disappointed at all.
Ellie from Arizona
I got this eyeliner from a Birch Box Subscription Box. I still have it and so far I was far more impressed with this product than other name brand equally priced products.
Smudges and runs terribly!!
Lindz from Alexandria, VA
Used this product twice and on both occasions it smudged and ran all over my face within an hour of putting it on. This was not waterproof on me. I would never purchase this product again. I promptly returned it, and got the brand I usually use.
Ulta sent me a dried out eyeliner
jessica from NJ, USA
I bought this when the purchase of a full sized eyeliner came with a mini eyeliner for free. my mini eyeliner is completely dried out and barely works. i didn't open the eyeliner before use and i had it for about one month prior to using it. i regret purchasing this eyeliner and am worried to start using the full sized liner.
Saasssssssyy from Phoenix, Arizona
as far as application, i love it. its easy for me to get the cat eye i want. HOWEVER. the wearability, sucks. it smudges and runs and gets EVERYWHERE. i shouldnt have to set my eyeliner when there are SO MANY other eyeliners on the market. so disappointed:(