Rated 2.75 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review natural looking
I grabbed this the second I saw it release. I had gotten one in my boxycharm a few months back. same formula, just no spooly. this is the same just a little bigger tip which is still ok. lasts all day, looks natural. i use spiked and I have very dark brown hair with medium toned skin.
Most Helpful Critical Review I am beyond disappointed with this new pencil
I have been using MAC spiked for over 10 years. It's my go to product. I was told they added the brush and I was immediately concerned and now I know for good reason. It retracts on it's own and the pencil is flimsy. The day I used it for the first time, it completely fell out of the tube and I had to put it back. MAC needs to go back to the basics on this or either make the pencil more sturdy like the ABH product or I rather not have the brush at all. I tried ABH once but preferred the regular MAC pencil without the brush. I hate this new product. I hope someone who makes decision is listening. I will not purchase it again with the brush! I will spend the extra money for the ABH product or find something else comparable. This is an EPIC Fail for MAC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reviewed by 373 customers Great pencil!
Jennifer from Michigan
I can shape my brows very easy. Great pencil. I will buy this again!
My favorite eyebrow pencil. Use this daily, Love it!
Melissa M. from Princeton, NJ
Use this daily! Definitely recommend.
I look crazy
Negan from California
This is a terrible brow pencil. It's so chalky and hard to apply. The pigment looks so uneven and makes me look like I escaped from a mental institution and haven't had my medications. How is it that Mac has such a poor quality product ? You can do better.
New Version is CHEAP!!
New Version is cheap!! from Washington
The currently released product is subpar. The pencil breaks, and does not cover over foundation. MAC Please listen to your customers and return the previous version!!
Tutu from Mid West
This brown pencil is very hard to get on and I certainly would not recommend it. Bring back the old pencil please.
Rfaith from Mississippi
WONDERFUL eyebrow pencil color. I have been using this pencil for at least 5 years. The STRUT color and SPIKED are great! I am excited about the recent smudge resistant improvement. Thank you MAC!!!
My Must Have
Angie from St Louis
My hair stylist/make up artist suggested this after getting my hair dyed five years ago and I have been using it since. It looks natural and lasts all day.
Love, love, love it!!!
Barbie from NMB, SC
Love this Eyebrow Styler
Sophie from Arlington Heights, IL
Long lasting pencil. I have been using the product for a while and love the way it fills in my brows and keeps my brows shaped very well all day long. Johanna from the Deer Park location introduced me to this product and I have been wearing ever since. Great place to learn to use the all MAC products.
Best Eyebrow Pencil
Michele from Las Vegas
Just sketch on eyebrows, but if you need to make a straight line, it still comes out thin enough to look great. Just soften your sketches with the spoolie. Everything is thin so it comes out precise.
Cookie from Kansas
This is by far my favorite brow pencil that I have tried and loved! I love that it stays on even after working out at the gym. The color matches pretty well too. I loved the Anastasia dip brow but I wanted something more natural and this is it! It's super creamy and you don't need to apply a lot of pressure to get the color payoff.
laura m from dallas texas
love this product
Favorite eyebrow pencil
Meli from San Lorenzo California
I have honestly used up 7 of them. I used to use brow wiz by Anastasia but Mac's eye brow pencil stole my heart
Love color and pigment, but too short
MissTara from Arkansas
Excellent shade in Fling. Goes on not too heavy for good precision and shaping. Hiwever, I only gave four stars because the product does not last long on the skin, also the stick is too short,causing me to run out in just a few weeks. Price could be better for longevity.
Old formula was so much better, this one breaks too much
GG from Colorado
I used to LOVE this product. The lines were so precise and thin and I never had a problem with the pencil breaking off. I was able to create a natural looking brow easily and the color was SPOT ON. It took me years to find an eyebrow pencil that actually matched my brow hair. That being said, the new formula feels cheaper. It doesn't last as long and frequently breaks. Color is still good and the pencil is still thin enough to create the look of individual hairs, but asking so much for something that constantly snaps in half seems silly.
Fantastic Brow Pencil
Taragvon from Williamsburg,Iowa
This is my go to brow pencil! My brows are blonde or as I like to say "clear". This pencil is a must have!
I really hope this is like the old formula.
MrsJJ78 from Michigan
I still have a little left of my old pencil in spiked. So I really hope this is like the old formula, stayed on all day and the color match was on point. MAC usually never disappoints🙂
Old formula is better!
Ladybug from California
I loved the original format. This one is too soft. The color pencil falls out of its casing and it breaks too easily.
I would buy this product again
Syryb from CT
last all day, define your brow perfectly.
I would never buy this product again.
Debbie from LaVerne, Ca
The pencil was dried out and kept breaking off to hard to use my granddaughters use Mac make up I thought I would try it didn't like it.
My favorite eyebrows!!
Blondielocks805 from Ventura ca
I use this this on a daily! I have blonde hair with brown eyebrows and have always had a hard time finding a brown that matches me. If you color your brows to dark with blond hair it always looks odd to me but Stylized by mac is the closest ive come. Easy application and no smudging!
I would not buy this product again
Trisha from Ma
Very disappointed in This Mac brow pen
Very Good Eyebrow Pencil
Michele from Las Vegas
I have sparse ash blonde brows. Most eyebrow pencils are too dark or too warm-colored. This one gets the color right. Also, the pencil is very thin, but tough, so it's pretty easy to fill in thin brows. The only issue that I've had with this product is that the tip gets a little dry after several uses and makes it hard to draw brows. However, I was able to remedy that by gently rubbing the tip on a tissue. I did buy it again.
Eyebrows That Last!
Jeanine from Texas
I love the fact that this pencil doesn't have to be sharpened, and it only has to be applied once during the day. The color lasts
Love, Love, Lovt It!
Kim B. from Houston, TX
This color really compliments my tone. It's perfect with so many shades that I apply. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a neutral color.