Rated 4.46 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review This Pencil LASTS!
I can never find a nude pencil to stay on my water line. Usually, by the time I finish my make up, my water line's naked again. I was so impressed with the color, creamy formula and staying power of this product. I actually had some left to wash off at the end of the day. I'm preparing to order the brown one and the green. Can't give this one enough praise.
Most Helpful Critical Review Does not last all day
I got this eye pencil because I was told that it was the best long lasting eyeliner for a lower price. The color is great and it is bold. I mainly wanted to use it for my waterline but I was disappointed when I looked in the mirror in the middle of the day and saw that it had smudged/disappeared. How is this waterproof if it runs and does not last? I guess you get what you pay for :(.
Reviewed by 412 customers Best pencil for the waterline
Kim from Reno, Nevada
I mainly only use this liner for my water line. I barely have to press for the liner to really apply which is great because you're so close to your eye. My favorite budget liner!
Great little liner even for a budget liner!
Kim from Nevada
I mainly bought this for using on my lower lash line and upper when I want to smudge it out and create a smokey eye look and it does the job.
The best I have found yet
SJKT from Colordo Springs, Co
I have doesn't a lot of money on other brands, and none have last as well as this one. Great price!
Smooth as butter
Jen from Carmel, IN
Really makes your eyes pop when placed as a highlighter in the corner.
Great buy and does the trick!
Mindy68 from PA
I bought this eyeliner to tightline and couldn't be happier. I have been using Marc Jacobs, and it typically is gone by the end of the day (eight hours). For a fraction of the cost, the Essence eyeliner stays put and lasts all day. I don't need to reapply. I highly recommend this product!
Very very good for the price
Marissa from Lexington SC
It truly lasts all day ,, if you don't touch it. I'll definitely purchase this again . The brown is such a beautiful shade. And it glides on SO smooth . So softly.
Kaylay from So Cal
This sucker doesn't budge period! Which also means be weary of mistakes, you won't be able to correct easily. I purchased the plain Brown, and it's great. I love Essence eye products and this did not disappoint. For a few bucks this was a hidden gem. I haven't tested waterproof test but even removing makeup at night it sticks really well.
Yes Yes Yes!
Jamie from Richmond, VA
Where has this eyeliner been? I got it on sale to try it out and I love it. All day wear...
Bri from Fort Myers
Creamy and pigmented!!!!
none from Arkansas
This eye pencil is great. Lasts a long time.
Super pigmented and doesn't transfer
LAmom from California
Goes on easily and is really pigmented. Most eyeliners transfer to my water line when I tight line, but this one didn't. It's a keeper.
Nena from Tx
Melinda from Issaquah
Same result as my Marc Jacobs gel liner. Great for inner rimming. Cheap cheap cheap. Love when I find A dupe.
Jaydah from Ulta
I love this eye pencil! It's so creamy and glides on smooth and it's really affordable, I highly recommend!
the CREAMIEST, most INSTANTANEOUS color
PW from US
I got the nude, brown, and black color and all three of them are absolutely AMAZING. I swatched them on my hand as soon as I got them and BAM, IMMEDIATE COLOR PAYOFF. And SO CREAMY! These are the best eye pencils ever, and the price is the icing and cherry on top! Would choose this every time over any other high end product.
Easy glide on. Zero tug.
Anya from Philadelphia
This glides on easier than a lot of high end brands. I'm shook. Zero tug!
Would buy again!
Denise from TX
This pencil is the best I have found! I bought because of the reviews and they are correct, it lasts! Stays on my water line. I have bought more expensive pencils than I can count and this one truly is the best and inexpensive too!
Saves me a ton of money
Melinda from Issaquah, WA
I have always bought Marc Jacobs gel liner. Loved that but the price is almost 30 dollars. This works just as well in the waterline and so cheap. Will buy again. Goodbye Jacobs...not self sharpening is a bummer but I can deal.
Stays put on
Makeup lover from Victorville, CA
I love to wear makeup and I always look for items that work the best. This eyeliner is super cheap and works so good it stays on for a really long time even if I'm working.
Erin from Virginia
Super smooth and creamy. Goes on like a dream
DTB from Castroville, TX
At this low price I'm going back to get one every color!!
Cstollings from Bayou Vista, TX
This is the only eyeliner that I've tried that does not smudge, it stays put all day even in my waterline. I was thinking about getting permanent eyeliner done but no more. If you haven't tried this one you need too!! Oh and price is great!!
Boss from Foster City
I'm dissatisfied..it smeared and smudged.
Better than the expensive eye liners
Kat08 from VA
I love this eyeliner! Before I tried this I was paying $25 for Marc Jacobs pencils and Essence is better than it. Great for the water line, glides on so well and stays put!
LolaStar from Somewhere, CA
I was surprised by how affordable these pencils are. They work great and last all day long. I'll pick these over any expensive brand any day. I use them when I want to wear liner in my water line or to do a Smokey eye.