Product Reviews Rated 4.45 out of 5 stars
472 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review This Pencil LASTS! I can never find a nude pencil to stay on my water line. Usually, by the time I finish my make up, my water line's naked again. I was so impressed with the color, creamy formula and staying power of this product. I actually had some left to wash off at the end of the day. I'm preparing to order the brown one and the green. Can't give this one enough praise.
Most Helpful Critical Review Does not last all day I got this eye pencil because I was told that it was the best long lasting eyeliner for a lower price. The color is great and it is bold. I mainly wanted to use it for my waterline but I was disappointed when I looked in the mirror in the middle of the day and saw that it had smudged/disappeared. How is this waterproof if it runs and does not last? I guess you get what you pay for :(.
Reviewed by 472 customers WOW!!! 5
Grace from San Antonio, TX
I use the NYX eyeliners but the Essence is even cheaper so I thought why not try it and if I don't like it's not a lot of money I wasted. OMG!!!! LOVE! LOVE! LOVE! It glides on smooth and it's a good deep black and once you put it on it doesn't dry to where you can't fix it. I'll definitely will be switching over to this eyeliner.
Super creamy ! 5
Nati from San Antonio
Honestly way better quality than high end cream eyeliners !
Gray "Midnight Sky" is too glittery for anyone over 20! 1
Muddymom3 from Snellville, Ga
I didn't see "glitter" mentioned anywhere in product description! Big, chunky square bits of silvery glitter! The eyeliner itself melts away like grease paint, but the darn glitter persists for days! Of course the glitter won't be where ever you used the pencil, even after thorough cleansing morning and night, it will still appear randomly - on cheeks, at the edge of hairline and even in eyebrows 2 full days later! (And no, it didn't come from cross-contamination of tools or brushes) The other colors may be just fine, but steer clear of the gray Midnight Sky choice! Unless its for Halloween or you're a teen who wants to look like a hot mess!!
Oh - and NEVER use glitter pencils in waterline or even to "tightline"!! (That's just begging for a scratched cornea or an eye infection!)
Teary Eyes 1
Tiffany from Fords, NJ
I personally wouldn't consider myself to have sensitive eyes, however, this eyeliner made my eyes tear all night long even when removed and sleeping. Really awful. I really wanted to like this but I will have to pass.
Love 5
Ariel from Texas
Wanting a nude eyeliner to put in my waterline for a long time and I finally found the perfect one. It's really easy to apply and it lasts a long time. I even put some on my hand to swatch it out and after washing my hands two times it still was on.
good 5
beth from va
very smooth and long lasting for me
Love this!!!! 5
Kris from Dalton ga
I love how easily this goes on and how well it stays all day. I will buy this again and again definitely
Loved it 4
Hailey from Toledo Ohio
It's kind of like a crayon which i like, but it's not as long lasting as it claims to be. I might just have watery eyes but it didn't seem to last at all on my waterline. Still good for the price and i would buy again
The best inexpensive eyeliner!! 5
Anita from Orlando, FL
This black eyeliner does the job! It is inexpensive, easy to use, and lasts throughout the day.
Decent Waterliner 3
Grace from United States
Used this for my lower waterline, lasts a decent while but is easily breakable and have to sharpen often
Silky Nude = Holy grail 5
OkDani from Florida
I just bought my 2nd Silky Nude pencil because I can't get ready without it. I use it to highlight under my brows! It makes them flawlessly highlighted & it lasts until I take it off. If you're on the fence about it, I recommend this little gem. Can't beat the quality and price.
almost perfect 4
Gracie from California
"Nude" very pigmented and creamy. But so creamy to a fault that the tip ends up breaking off completely and also is difficult to sharpen for that same reason. Lasts for many hours but not the entire day. But the price point is awesome for the rest of the quality
didnt work as well as id liked 4
mamallama21 from houston, tx
the color is very pigmented and smooth. i have watery eyes at all times sonit didnt last long on my waterline. maybe an hour or so.
Black stays on the waterline all day!! 5
Ade from California
this pencil doesn't smudge and is long lasting, great for the price!
I love it 5
Soli from Los Gatos
Stays there for at least 10 hours, love ig
I plan on making this my permanent eye liner pencil. 4
Toni from San Bernardino CA
Reasonably priced
Amazing!!! 5
Lina from NY
I got the shade silky nude and it is the perfect nude color. I feel that white sometimes comes off too harsh. This is super creamy and lasts all day on the waterline. I have very sensitive eyes that tend to get very watery due to allergies. This eye liner is the best i have ever used, you can't beat it especially for the price.
Smooth and lasting quite long. 5
Asifa from Houston, Tx
Finally I got what I want, a smooth waterline pencil. Love it.
I would buy it again 5
Violette from El cajon
I used it to outline my eyebrows and it really works, I love it
absolutely would buy again 5
Charm from Milwaukee WI
Love this liner! Price point is great and stays on all day.
Smudges in waterline, but it's solid 4
Angie from NYC
The Blacklove shade is great for a smudged out winged liner; like others have mentioned, you can easily blend it out with a brush. I can achieve a sexy Smokey eye with this shade, but I have to avoid adding too much of it when I tight line because it does transfer a bit.
Adding to my list! 5
Jessica from Texas
I've used "waterproof" eyeliner on my lower lash line before to only end up with raccoon eyes. This didn't smudge/move/smear/run...nothing. It does everything it says it should
Dupes for Tarte amazonian clay liners 5
Abril from Texas
These liners are as close as I could find to Tartes discontinued amazonian clay liners! Glide like butter, pigmented and long lasting!
Nice, inexpensive liner 4
Sd1188 from Wilmington, DE
I really enjoy these pencils. They are smooth and can be smudged with a brush. If placed on the lower lash line they may migrate a bit throughout the day, but still a great eyeliner at this price point.
Transfers 1
LAmom from Los Angeles
Transfers immediately to lower water line when tight lining. I also have this pencil in black and gray, and no transfer with those shades. But the brown immediately transfers and is hard to remove once that happens as it is long lasting!
