Rated 4.47 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review This Pencil LASTS!
I can never find a nude pencil to stay on my water line. Usually, by the time I finish my make up, my water line's naked again. I was so impressed with the color, creamy formula and staying power of this product. I actually had some left to wash off at the end of the day. I'm preparing to order the brown one and the green. Can't give this one enough praise.
Most Helpful Critical Review Does not last all day
I got this eye pencil because I was told that it was the best long lasting eyeliner for a lower price. The color is great and it is bold. I mainly wanted to use it for my waterline but I was disappointed when I looked in the mirror in the middle of the day and saw that it had smudged/disappeared. How is this waterproof if it runs and does not last? I guess you get what you pay for :(.
Reviewed by 438 customers I would buy this product again and again
T the trainer from New York, New York
Such an amazing product. Just what I needed
Great lasting eye pencil
maperez2004 from Fontana, Ca.
This is an excellent long-lasting eye pencil. Love the brown color for the waterline. Recommended
You can stop looking for the perfect eye light pencil!!!!
C from AZ
Finally! I have been looking for a nice pencil for my waterline. I bought this pencil in nude for the lower waterline. Love it! Creamy formula and natural but better with a brightening pigment. I bought LA Girl in retractable white ... also Inexpensive. It was a nice formula as well but not long lasting. The NYX epic wear liner pencil in white was too chalky/thick and it was TOO white! Brought the wrong attention to my eyes! This is such a pretty color and long lasting and not many brands carry a nude colour. Bonus ... the price!!! I got mine BOGO 50% off! TIP: it look plastic, but you can definitely sharpen it. Someone said it has to be used with an Essence brand sharpener, but I have had the same NARS pencil sharpener for years and I just used the smaller pencil sharpener on it and it worked fine!
Soft pencil good for lining lower inside line
Rocappella from Syracuse ny
Got the silky nude to line my lower lash line and it's really bright. I need to not use too much pressure but this works really well for that.
Silky nude for waterline
Meesh from Va
The silky nude shade for people who like lining their waterline is so natural and so pigmented and long lasting.
Great for watery eyes
Meggg from Tampa
I always get watery eyes and most eyeliners don't work for me but this one works ! And it's super black! And the price is great !
Civ2ru from Knoxville, TN
This pencil in Silky Nude shade + your waterline = instant wide-awake eye opener! Effect lasts all day. Dirt cheap. What's not to love?
Best thing ever
Raghad from Mi
Cali from Florida
Love this eyeliner it is so creamy and pigmented. It also glides so easily on the eyes. Can't beat the price and quality of this product
Luvbellaxo from Chino (CA)
I am constantly spending money on eyeliners trying to find a good one that won't smear. I've tried all brands and with in an hr I have racoon eyes. This product doesn't smear at all! It stays on all night and I absolutely love it.
An Absolute MUST
Jenny from Miami, FL
I have never had a pencil that glided so smoothly. I use a more liquid/felt tip eyeliner for my top eye line but I like using pencils like this for my lower lash line. The pencil is SO Pigmented and it goes on so easily and this lasts all day!
I only wish they had more colors!
Oh, and for the Price?! I will never use another pencil!
Jules from New Yoel
Lasted all day on my waterline. Great price!
Mimiballerina from North Providence, RI
This pencil rivals any high end pencil that I've used. The price is outstanding as is this eye pencil! It glides on easily and lines my waterline nicely. I'm not wasting any more money on higher priced eye pencils.
Best eyeliner pencil ever!
Terissa from Layton, UT
Angie from Hot&Flashy is right and these pencils for the price are the best. You can stop spending your money on the over priced liners you only need these, especially for tight lining or water lining.
It's the best
sky from US
Before I found this, I was using a $9 pencil. This works great and is priced better! It's so soft and pigmented, I'm almost comparing this to a pricey gel liner
No Factory Seal
Moi from Port Chester CT
Did yours come with a plastic zip top to bottom seal like most pencils do ?
Will definitely purchase this item again
Cami from Versailles KY
Stays on all day!! Not to to heavy or light. Love it!!
Bernie from Summerfield, Fl
This product has superb pigment - however, I would prefer that it stays put in the waterline. I mainly purchase because of the intense pigmentation.
No... I don't like how it goes on or stays
YiaYia from Sandy, UT
Everyone said it was great, I didn't like how it looked.
My favorite budge eye pencil!
Kanesharb from Florence, Al
I use this eye pencil on my upper and lower lash lids to give depth to my eyes. The black really brings out my brown eyes. The price point is really great, I feel like I am getting a steal. I don't have to tug at my lid to get product to apply. It's easily removed with coconut oil.
Taylor from Kentucky
This stuff goes on smoother than butter. I bought the nude color to wear on my waterline. It's very pigmented, so one swipe across the waterline and it's done. This product will be a staple in my makeup bag from now on.
Mad I didn't buy this sooner!!
Kay from Eagan Minnesota
Skip the expensive eye pencils. Buy this!
This is the only eye pencil that doesn't smudge! Even on my water line. in 90 degree weather. Doesn't do anything :)
Really good for price
A from MN
I use this to line my waterline and darken under - it does smudge hours later if have combination/oily skin. It's super black and creamy - easy to blend with Q-tip if want that effortless smokey look.
Good price, smooth application!
Bethann from San Diego
Price is great! Overall a great product for the price!
Love it so far
Ash from Ohio
I was very surprised by how well this goes on the waterline and it lasts a long time.