Rated 3.29 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Extra Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner--THE BEST
I love this liquid pencil eyeliner! I wear all the colors. Grey is my favorite! It glides on smoothly! I have been buying this product for years! Lately, I haven't been able to find the grey eyeliner anywhere. I will try ordering it online. I hope they still have it. I definitely recommend this wonderful eyeliner!
Most Helpful Critical Review Plastic and Counter-Intuitive
I had to come here to figure out how to use more than the exposed nib of this pencil. The packaging is unclear and it is definitely not normal or clear that you'd be sharpening a pencil by peeling away plastic. This pencil even has a twisting motion so you just assume you're out of liner even after using just the visible nib. Dumb design, poorly explained, unnecessarily complicated and wasteful. Bring back wood/pulp pencils.
Reviewed by 603 customers Love at first use.
Melva (Chesapeake VA) from Virginia
Love this eyeliner. I don't use anything else.
Jess893 from undisclosed
This is my favorite eyeliner! I'm not sure why a lot of people seem to be having a bad experience with it.... Mine sharpened all the way down. I bought a brand name eyeliner after I used up this one and am counting down the days until it is time to buy a new one so I can switch back to this!
DEPARTMENT STORE QUALITY!!!
TESSASWEET from NYC/BOSTON
I absolutely Love!!! EXTRA INTENSE LIQUID PENCIL eyeliner!
This eyeliner is as good as , but mostly
BETTER than , most department store BRANDS
That I've used and I've tried MANY!
I'm definitely a makeup AFICIONADO...
It glides on super smooth and Extremely Black with just One coat and that's exactly what I want!
I rate this eyeliner Number ONE!!!
People that are having a difficult time sharpening
This eyeliner are using the wrong sharpener.
Not all sharpeners are met for all liners .You need to experiment until you find the right one.
My favorite eyeliner!
Ebony27 from Ohio
I discovered this eyeliner nine years ago. It is amazing. I've tried other eyeliners, but nothing compares to this one. I appreciate the quality of this eyeliner. I've tried both Urban Decay's and Marc Jacobs eyeliner. This by far is superior in my opinion.
Nice and dark but too soft for comfort
3happykids from midland texas
I am in agreement with the other reviewers on the product. I had high praises for the eyeliner pencil until I needed to sharpen. Once you are pass the nib and need to expose more wax by sharpening, you can consider the pencil a waste of money and only good for the garbage. The soft wax gets imbedded in the sharpener and the pencil is unusable. It is messy. I was able to sharpen once and the wax was exposed BUT on application the entire waxy part slid out of the wooden pencil. I tried 4 different pencils (thinking that each one was deective) and 3 different sharpeners (it could possibly the brand of sharpener. Even after reading the reviews and LÓreals response to look into and improve the product, the same problem exists. DO NOT BUY!!!
Nice and dark but too soft for comfort
3happykids from midland texas
I am in agreement with the other reviewers on the product. I had high praises for the eyeliner pencil until I needed to sharpen. Once you are pass the nib and need to expose more wax by sharpening, you can consider the pencil a waste of money and only good for the garbage. The soft wax gets imbedded in the sharpener and the pencil is unusable. It is messy. I was able to sharpen once and the wax was exposed BUT on application the entire waxy part slid out of the wooden pencil. I tried 4 different pencils (thinking that each one was deective) and 3 different sharpeners (it could possibly the brand of sharpener. Even after reading the reviews and L?reals response to look into and improve the product, the same problem exists. DO NOT BUY!!!
total waste of money
autumn 19 from undisclosed
Once the visible nib of the pencil is used, that's it, it can be discarded as it has not further use. I don't understand the "liquid pencil eyeliner" part. Mine did not have any liquid.
1PCS from Citrus Heights, Ca
Second one I bought. First on I returned thinking it was faulty, it was not! Second one is the same way. You only get what is originally showing one the pencil and defiantly not worth the money.
Jan from Va
Love it because it goes on smoothly and stays. Just what I was looking for.
It's too soft
Roori from Chicago
The tip is too soft and kind of melts on the skin.
The only pencil eyeliner I have used in years!
Sarabear22 from Minnesota
Glides on so smoothly
Waste of money
RoxyBB from Dallas
This eyeliner works great until you use up the little nub of eyeliner that was originally sticking out. Can't sharpen. The rest of what's in the shaft is wasted. I've seen L'Oreal comment that they appreciate feedback and will work on the products and stuff but there's someone who said this two years ago and apparently they're still selling it :-/
Not User Friendly
Doobie from Orlando, FL
I bought this pencil, twice now and each time the experience was awful & messy! You cannot sharpen this pencil. If by chance you can get it to turn round your sharpener, the product is soft and ends up all over your fingers. This could be a good product, but the "liquid" needs to change to a more solid type. The wood most be flexible enough to be sharpened. I've thrown this pencil away both time before I even got half way through it. Such a waste!
Beth0914 from Iowa
I used this pencil for about a week. I loved it then tried to sharpen it. I bought and used the dual sharpener recommended. I tried several times to sharpen it but the plastic was always left with sharp edges that hurt my eyes. I loved the look and feel of the eyeliner, but you can only use it until the exposed nub is gone. Then it is useless unless you want to risk scratching you eyes. Very disappointed in this.
I usually love L'Oreal products, but this pencil was not a good purchase. I truly had to throw it away. I tried several times to sharpen it. I purchased the L'Oreal dual sharpener as recommended, tried soft pressure, medium pressure and hard pressure. It did not matter, the plastic was always sharp and would hurt my eyes. I even tried to take a small file and smooth off the edges. That helped a little, but is way to much work for an eyeliner.
I would buy this again
Liz from Mi
I use this eye liner everyday
Buffy 11 from warner robins, GA
This eyeliner is the best ever it is so soft. It goes on so smooth I am 61 and my eyelids are a little wrinkled but this eyeliner still glides on perfect! Thank you L'Oréal for a great product!
linerless in KY from Paducah, KY
I like the product, but after one use I dropped it and the tip came off. It would NOT twist up at all. I twisted and twisted and finally fit a metal prong inside of it and the entire product came out. I am disappointed that I was only able to use this product one time. There are NO instructions on the packaging about how to access the product (twisting did NOT work).
Should've paid attention of the other 99 neg. ppl.
Mare Bear from Monroe,WI
Loved this the first time . The tip was perfect and the application was perfect . However when I went to put the cap on it broke off the tip and it wouldn't sharpen at all . I am returning it to the store at least I can get my $7.50 back !
Loreal - Extra Intense Pencil Eyeliner
Stachia from Lancaster, SC
I have bought two of these and much to my disappointment. I could only use them about twice and they get so dull on the tip that I can not use them. I will never buy this product ever again. I like the Loreal Infallible but it does not last long either but it works much better than the Extra Intense. I tried to sharpen the pencil and it would still not work.
Love the texture
Shayla from Lanham, MD
Mine has a smudger sponge on the other end which i love and helps me blend the eyeliner to make a smokey eye.
Unfriendly - Needed to be quality tested more
NANAnana from new york, ny
I will never buy it again. It is incredibly difficult to apply well and without a sharpener, it's useless. I don't have one, so I'm just going to tear up the tip. What I've been doing is marking it on something, then taking the rubber tip and dipping it into the crayon. I'm calling it crayon, because that really is the consistency. LO - you really need to provide a sharpener.
I would not buy again
Gym babe from Woodstock, ga
I would not buy this again. Was only able to use it once
Don't buy this
Charo from Natick, MA
I bought it on a Wednesday. On Friday the point broke off, and there is no way to wind it up to sharpen it.
Great product, suffering from design failure
Tirtil from New York, NY
I bought this product thinking it was a twisting eyeliner, because it exactly looks like one and the bottom part actually twists. I did not notice an explanation oterwise on the package before throwing it away, maybe the writing was too small to pay attention. After failing to elongate the tip, I thought maybe the pencil I bought had a faulty mechanism. Then I came here and learned it needs to be sharpened. Although the eyeliner has great colour and staying on power, I would not have bought it if I knew this. Now two questions 1) Why does a mega-company like Loreal still does not make this more evident on the package, despite many customers being misled and kept complaining since two years? 2) Is there no way to produce a thinner version of this eyeliner with twisting feature?
So smooth and easy to create a cat eye! My go to!
Elle9900 from Erie, PA
I've been using this liquid pencil since L'OReal came out with it! Perfect lines and deep rich color. Easy to smudge too!