Rated 3.78 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Works Like a Charm
The Neutrogena liquid is my favorite eye makeup remover of all time, so I decided to try these pads out for a bit of convenience. They work like a charm. They are just as good as the liquid remover. The pads don't burn my eyes or sting and they remove all traces of eye makeup. The only drawback is, of course, you get more product in the actual liquid bottle. I will be repurchasing these because they are very convenient and come in handy when sometimes I just don't want to deal with the liquid and a separate cotton pad.
Most Helpful Critical Review Do you love wearing eye makeup? Don't buy this
I bought this because I thought it would simplify my evening/travel routine because I wouldn't have to worry about carrying a separate set of cosmetic cotton wipes to remove my eye make up.
The cotton wipes included in the product were not even moist, nor were they saturated enough to remove all of my (non-waterproof) mascara. The first use, I ended up going through three or four of these wipes just to get the job done. The next day, I had to go back to the store so that I could buy a separate bottle of eye make up remover to use IN ADDITION TO this product, which totally defeats the purpose of why I purchased this in the first place.The only good thing about this product is the soft/smooth texture of the cotton wipes.
Otherwise, unless you wear hardly any eye makeup, or you only wear clear mascara, this is not for you. Save your money and stick to a purely liquid formula that actually works.
Reviewed by 140 customers Too gentle
Hot Mama from Cincinnati
The are almost too gentle. Doesn't get mascara off very well. They don't have much moisture so I added some water which may have affected my results. I
so gentle and good
shadowhunter from Ohio
I highly recommend this product to anyone with extremely sensitive skin around the eye. Some makeup removers were so harsh that they caused eczema. No eczema or harsh agitated skin when I use these pads. I also do not have to aggressively rub to get waterproof makeup off.
The ultimate best in Eye Makeup Removals!
Jo from Lake Zurich, Il
This is a gentle yet thorough eye makeup removal. Individual pads make it so easy to removed the toughest of eye makeup.
It gets off waterproof mascara and glitter
AZ gal from AZ
I can't say anything bad about this product.
I would buy this product again
Cris from TN
Excellent Eye Makeup Remover
Jo from Lake Zurich, Illinois
The individual pads make eye makeup removal easy and clean!
Not online, half the price in store
Krista from Denver, CO
Makeup remover pads
Best eye makeup remover pads
Karen from Denver
These are the best eye makeup remover pads
Ellie from Vero Beach FL
Neutrogena products are reliably good. I liked these eye make up remover pads, but, I wish I didn't have to use more than one pad per eye. Could be a little more effective on waterproof mascara. Very gentle, though.
Probably not, at least this kind.
wanas from birmingham, al
Went to Ulta to purchase this produce and had to ask for help finding it. She told me at first they didn't carry those any longer but then found it. She then said you changed packaging. If that's the case you not only changed packaging by the size of pads are much larger, thicker and not wet enough. Will not buy this one again. I liked the ones that were in a smaller tub with thin pads. They worked great.
only one I would buy
Jay from Dallas, TX
none to add
Dorqueen from Vancouver
These make-up remover pads are great! I use them on my whole face even though they are meant for eye make-up. They are extra large, soft, odorless, and simply amazing! I use one everyday, love them!
Kim from Texas
BEST EVER!! I buy these in bulk and will never use anything else. Removes marcara and is SO gentle on the eyes. I love the packaging and the easy little pads. I usually use one pad 3-4 times. I use them after a short to take off the access mascara
Debi from Hot Springs AR
I really like to use this when I travel because of the easy access packaging.
LOVE THIS PRODUCT!
RachelS from Baltimore, MD
I love this product in both the pad version as well as the liquid. The only downside to the pads are that some of them are a little drier than others. The pads do travel well though and if I'm going on a trip, I would prefer to bring them over the liquid version!
Would definitely buy again
Rebekah from Near Delaware
Only product I use to remove my eye makeup
Soft and Effective
Shay from Baltimore, MD
This is my second time using this product. I initially used it because it was on sale. This is the second time I purchased this product. Its easy to use, effective, but I wish it were a little more wet/moist. It takes the eye make up off with no problem but I find it to be a little too dry. I still buy it though...
Easy to use
Vic from Minneapolis
Great to use in a hurry.
Esme from Fremont ca
Its easy to use but if you have sensitive skin i dont recommend it it does burn a lil bit
Wouldn't buy again
Caroline from Atlanta, GA
Not very effective.
It's okay for the price
Ana from Washington
It doesn't quite clean all the mascara off my eyelashes. I'm glad it's gentle enough to not exacerbate my eczema around the eye area.
A must for removing eye make up!
PG from Greenville SC
This its the only product I use to remove eye make up. Easy to use pads are great are great!
I would buy this product again. Loved it
SHIRLEY from TEXAS
First time to use this product and I love it.
SunnyB from Florida
I typically like Neutrogena cleansing products but this fell flat! Ithe takes multiples swipes and pads to remove eye makeup.
Will buy again..nice product
Angelica48 from MA
Light eye and brow makeup removal